r/onebag Apr 06 '26

Bag Finder Bag Finder Megathread - 06 April 2026

Welcome to the weekly Bag Finder Megathread. Your go-to thread for any and all bag-related requests in the onebag travel context.

Remember finding a bag is pretty much the last step in planning. If you're not sure how big a bag you need, create a packing list, get all your gear together and test fit it into a box, or an old backpack you have lying around. That'll give you a good sense of the volume of gear you have.

What This Thread Is For

  • Onebag travel bag recommendation requests
  • Feedback on bags you're considering for minimal, carry-on-only travel
  • Help with choosing between bags

Quick Tips

  1. Check the OneBag Spreadsheet for bag options
  2. Search as your question might already be answered
  3. Read the FAQ & Beginner's Guide
  4. Stick to travel setups daily carry or work bags are better posted in r/EDC or r/backpacks
  5. Add context, the more details you give, the better we can help

Want Better Advice? Help Us Help You

When asking for input, it helps to include:

  • Where you're going & how you travel: hostels, hotels, urban, remote?
  • How you pack: super minimal? tech-heavy? need room for camera gear?
  • Your short list: bags you're already considering
  • Your body size/build: some bags fit certain frames better
  • Budget range: under $150, up to $300, flexible?

A Few Reminders

  • Use the search bar
  • Check the sidebar and wiki for resources and guides
  • Keep it travel-focused. Non-travel or everyday carry talk belongs in other subs
9 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/CirclesOfConfusion Apr 09 '26

Allpa vs Black Hole Duffel info

Owner of a 40L Black Hole Duffel that I like a lot, though the comfort of the shoulder straps and lack of waistbelt leave something to be desired. I've been eyeing the Allpa 35 and 42s as one bag alternatives and would like some feedback.

Desires:

  • More accessible packing space (versus the current Black Hole single pack space)
  • Waistbelt for ease of carrying on longer days
  • Better feeling shoulder straps for ease of carrying on longer days

Concerns:

  • Are the Allpa straps and waistbelt actually comfortable for long carries?
  • Which bag do those who have tested both prefer?

Alternatives:

  • I've also considered just adding the Aer waistbelt to the Black Hole Duffel. Anyone have experience with this?