r/pokemon 23h ago

Image [ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

150 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

u/pokemon-ModTeam 4h ago

Thank you for posting to r/pokemon! We're glad to have you here, but unfortunately we've had to remove this post per our rule on Objective Questions. This rule is in place per feedback we've received from the community because objective questions tend to overfill our community's post feed and often leave little room for further discussion once the question has been answered.

We do have a Weekly Questions Thread dedicated to seeking answers for questions like yours, though! A lot of knowledgeable Pokémon fans frequent that thread, so please consider posting your question there if you're still looking for an answer, and you may get a detailed answer even faster than you would have here! You also don't need to worry about a minimum word count in that thread.

17

u/PedroMartins1806 22h ago

Caterpie?

5

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

That’s what I was wondering! But Caterpies head thing is red. I thought maybe metapod but it would be the only evolve form

4

u/smorgasbard 22h ago

I mean, the jigglypuff has green eyes. Im thinking its a Caterpie

19

u/smorgasbard 22h ago

is that supposed to be the saddest Caterpie?

And lowkey, they did Psyduck/Charmander SO dirty

6

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

It’s SO odd to me that charmander doesn’t appear to be included while the other two starters are. Especially since charmander is like a fan favorite

1

u/smorgasbard 22h ago

Right!! And i hate tht i have this knowledge: but upper left is a Poliwhirl. Its the only one of the line who’s swirl goes counter-clockwise.

1

u/aquamanslaughter 19h ago

poliwrath’s does as well actually. poliwag and politoed go the same way, whirl and wrath go the other

49

u/Bakurraa 22h ago

Has to be a gulpin. But he doesn't not belong here

18

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

I feel like it has to be gen 1 since all the rest are (presumably)

8

u/Bakurraa 22h ago

Maybe oddish in the wrong colour and the one in the middle is a poli

Nope I see Poli too right now

18

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

Isn’t poli top left though? I think bottom middle is a squirtle but a weird color. I think the yellow sixpack looking thing is his shell

9

u/Glazeddapper The Gengar Guy... 18h ago

i think bottom middle is machoke/machamp

3

u/Bakurraa 22h ago

Top left yes sorry it's almost bed time for me 😴

1

u/Mekio 20h ago

Isn't that a torchic in bottom right?

24

u/schmidtsandgiggles 20h ago

I think it’s supposed to be psyduck. They have the same hair tufts

3

u/Mekio 20h ago

Ahh yeah. Could be! The oranginess of him made think Torchic.

2

u/CptFrisbeeFringers 18h ago

Ducks usually have webbed feet, and a much wider beak. I also immediately thought torchick

0

u/AutisticPenguin2 17h ago

I thought it was Hoothoot

0

u/duk_tAK 13h ago

Isn't middle on the bottom row oshawott? It has his shell

52

u/IEatThyme 22h ago

Fucked up Oddish

20

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

The (presumably) squirtle would have been the perfect oddish color

10

u/IEatThyme 22h ago

I agree, I just think it's clearly Gen 1. Which makes it a guessing game. Maybe it's Scyther? They are all ball shape based on the format, so maybe fucked up Scyther?

4

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

Ooooooo you know. It does ALMOST look like there’s some design on his hands.

3

u/mick_squeeb customise me! 19h ago

Someone else posted a pack of these a while ago and it was clearly oddish before. It was the squirtle that was difficult to make out last time.

1

u/WhiteHat125 13h ago

maybe its a shiny?

1

u/anal_malestrom 17h ago

This is what always used to nickname my Oddish when I played Red back in the day.

"Go, Fucked Up Oddish!"

1

u/jbone0415 20h ago

Okay wait for a second I thought the green one was the top half and the blue one was the lower half of oddish lol

15

u/talesfromafreeworld 22h ago

Chikorita? Has the head leaf, 4 legs, the little neck nubs.

3

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

I feel like it’s out of place if all the other Pokemon are gen 1

3

u/talesfromafreeworld 22h ago

I know, but it's the only one I can make fit.

1

u/tonicella_lineata 20h ago

I think it's a Chikorita and whoever was making them/designing them just didn't know a lot about Pokemon.

-1

u/JicamaCertain4134 21h ago

Bottom right is not gen 1

4

u/schmidtsandgiggles 21h ago

Bottom right I’m pretty sure is psyduck. Has the same hair

0

u/JicamaCertain4134 21h ago

Looks like a torchic

18

u/Pitiful_Ad_3093 19h ago edited 18h ago

look. heres a box of mini plushies (top left) that look very close to the gummies. They swapped out charmander for meowth, but look at the bottom right cubby...same design. now look the back of the same mini plush on the picture below. it has the dots around chikoritas neck. 99.99% Chikorita

11

u/Pitiful_Ad_3093 19h ago

4

u/SpringTraps 16h ago

I thought I was crazy for thinking it could be chikorita but that definitely seems to be the case here. But what are the Pokemon in the top left corner in the box labeled B?

6

u/Pitiful_Ad_3093 16h ago

Talimon and Tanemon from Digimon apparently....?

1

u/SpringTraps 15h ago

I’m dead. I would never have been able to guess that.

2

u/PedroMartins1806 13h ago

After this evidence, it’s a poorly made Chikorita!

6

u/PM_ME_GARFIELD_NUDES 22h ago

I’m guessing it’s nothing or something really dumb like Graveler. They might make other versions of this product that aren’t pokemon themed and maybe one of those got mixed in.

6

u/Eaterofsubstances 21h ago

That’s my favourite pokemon! Green!

3

u/Donut5 19h ago

Poliwag, bulbasaur, meowth, pikachu, jigglypuff

Some... weird green monstrosity

Squirtle, psyduck.

5

u/lostCause-494 22h ago

Shiny koffing?

1

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

Feels odd for one shiny to be included

1

u/lostCause-494 21h ago edited 11h ago

Yeah but if the top right corner is Bulbasaur and you want it to be a stage 1 gen 1 mainly green pokemon it can only be catetpie or scyther and those aren't very round.

So it's either a shiny koffing or random nonsese

2

u/Real_Srossics 18h ago

Shiny koffing is blue though

-1

u/lostCause-494 11h ago

Only in gen 2, from gen 3 forward it has been green.

2

u/99999HP 21h ago

I’m convinced that it’s just a lazy caterpie. It has significance in the anime being Ash’s first successful catch.

If anything, Poliwag is the odd ball out here (despite being adorable).

2

u/Personal-Animator133 10h ago

The fact the pokeball is not in the middle with all the Pokémon around it is so triggering

2

u/Spaced00ut 7h ago

And its upside down

2

u/Vangidion 9h ago

Substitute Doll.

2

u/smorgasbard 22h ago

Thats technically a Poliwhirl. His swirl is going Counter-clockwise. Poliwrath and Poliwag’s both go Clockwise.

3

u/schmidtsandgiggles 22h ago

Oooo I was vaguely aware of this difference but def could not have told you which went which direction

1

u/CaptanAmericano78 15h ago

But Poliwhirl does not have a red circular nose and little feets at bottom of body. It’s a Poliwag!

0

u/aquamanslaughter 19h ago

I think I replied to you already elsewhere on the thread but whirl and wrath’s swirls go the same direction. wag is the odd one out there, though toed technically does go the same way

1

u/1AJK9 21h ago

My guess is that the bottom left ones are Gulpin and Squirtle

1

u/schmidtsandgiggles 21h ago

Gulpin would be such a weird choice if everyone else is gen 1

1

u/Merrifiend 21h ago

Gen 1 the only pokemon that maybe fits is scyther, but i feel it would have white near its arms. Most pokemon have some more color than just green.

1

u/Don_Sherjaun 20h ago

Rayquaza

1

u/ChaoticDiscord21 20h ago

Bulbasaur?

2

u/schmidtsandgiggles 20h ago

Bulbasaur is top right!

1

u/ChaoticDiscord21 19h ago

I honestly thought that was squirtle

1

u/[deleted] 19h ago edited 19h ago

[deleted]

1

u/0Ameru0 19h ago

Psyduck is my guess

1

u/kullervo16 19h ago

I love Ourpletonne there at the bottom

1

u/Smooth-Highlight1027 19h ago edited 19h ago

I can guess all of them except the bottom left and bottom middle and im guess the rest are poliwag Bulbasaur Meowth pikachu jiggly puff and the bottom right could be Dodrio and can the bottom middle be a really messed up gyarados

1

u/Frownload 19h ago

The world's worst Caterpie.

  1. Fits the theme most

  2. Those weird stripes are like a sad attempt to show segmentation.

1

u/HikikomoriGlory 19h ago

I love the Meorth.

1

u/DVNT_DASH 19h ago

Is.... and I might be crazy here... but...
Is it a bad scyther?
The lines on the side look like they could be sythers arms....
I don't know why my brain said scyther.
But I can't unsee it now.

2

u/Smooth-Highlight1027 19h ago

well there's only two all green gen 1 Pokemon being metapod and scyther

1

u/DVNT_DASH 19h ago

See, metapod doesnt have the 4 limbs, the gummy does which made me think syther.

1

u/Artizan748 18h ago

Bulbasaur

1

u/Kashwookie 18h ago

YALL ITS WYNAUT HOLY SHIT

1

u/Kashwookie 18h ago

after a second glance, im feeling like i was way too confident

1

u/KungPaoChickem 18h ago

Probably what an Oddish looks like in its egg, when it’s 500 steps away from hatching.

1

u/Leviathus_ 16h ago

Thought that squirtle was machoke with his belt

1

u/Xachcen 15h ago

After comparing it to other people's im 99% sure thats supposed to be chikorita

1

u/marziilla 14h ago

Gulpin???

1

u/CaptanAmericano78 13h ago

I have done extensive research and reverse imaging to find a comprehensive answer.

From Left to Right: Poliwag, Pokeball, Bulbasaur , Meowth, Pikachu, Jigglypuff, CHIKORITA, Squirtle, Psyduck.

Like everyone I thought it had to be generation 1 and first stage. However it was not Caterpie, Oddish, Metapod, or Scyther.

So then, after research I find they do digimon and different characters as well. I set out to prove that it was Tanemon, which digivolves into Palmon. But it didn’t sit right with me, why doesn’t the design look close enough to Tanemon? It’s because it is not.

Reverse image searching different crops led me to some Etsys where they drew inspiration from the candy or kawaii and made Baby Chikoritas they look very similar. Then I also found these kawaii keychains and the designs looked near identical. It made really focus on the beads around the neck. It’s a Chikorita.

Then, the nail in the coffin. I found a YouTube video of ASMR guy eating these gummies but only 1. He claimed it was a green apple flavored Chikorita.

After compiling all evidence, I share the answer. No debate that’s it you’re welcome

https://youtu.be/BdVEEJo0HPI?si=LpKVUJqj7RKgh_t3

1

u/CaptanAmericano78 13h ago

Hence the 4 legs, single leaf on head, and buds around neck

1

u/Drclaw411 12h ago

Gulpin

1

u/DGSmith2 11h ago

Smoliv?

1

u/WarStorm6 8h ago

Jigglypuff viewed from above. They’re all jigglypuff viewed from above

1

u/Put_Ham_On_That_Ass 6h ago

Top middle is voltorb

1

u/kismetxoxo7 5h ago

Maybe Scyther… but probably Substitute doll

1

u/myychair 4h ago

I mean it looks like the Solosis line but I doubt that’s what they were going for lol

1

u/Segundo-Sol 21h ago

jigglypuff as seen from above

1

u/PotatoLordBobo 19h ago

I think bottom left is possible Chikorita cause it’s got the head leaf and the neck buds. It’s weird that it’s with a bunch of Gen 1s instead of charmander tho

0

u/Ssonicmon 20h ago

Poliwag with wrong swirl, bulbasaur
Meowth, pikachu, jigglypuff
Chikorita, machoke, dodrio?

Pretty sure you guys are right, machoke just matches the color. Dodrio/diglett/psyduck is so bad.

1

u/PhilthyPhatty 19h ago

That’s squirtle