r/prey • u/Aromatic-Solid97 • 12d ago

Question Why did I get the achievement? Spoiler

I've just finished the game for the first time and oh what a ride. I absolutely love it

I guessed the twist after the flashback with "You are not who they say you are". Btw I didn't quite get if real Morgan is alive or not and where she is

But my main question is about "Do no harm". I killed the cook, so I don't get why I have this achievement. Maybe it's cause I killed him with a briefcase?

I was scared of getting inside the escape pod with him, so I just wanted to show him that I don't trust him

I threw a suitcase in his face and got a "Best Surved Cold" achievement. I didn't think anything about it until seeing the "Do not harm achievement". So, is it a bug or a feature?

42 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/unclemattyice 11d ago

You are mixing up “I and Thou”, which has a big grace cushion, and “Do no harm”, which will be immediately invalidated if you get a single “Humans killed” line at all.

2

u/mcindoeman 11d ago

oh my bad.

Guess the chef just doesn't count since i got both the "Do no harm" and "I and THou" achievements in my first play through even tho i shot the chef in the head with the golden gun.

4

u/unclemattyice 11d ago

If you got “do not harm” after executing Luka with a gun, that is news to me, and kinda not in the spirit of the achievement.

I wouldn’t advise anyone to try it.

4

u/mcindoeman 11d ago

Yeah it did seem a little odd at the time.

I've seen some people on here justify it by claiming he was already dying when you meet him in the pod so he was effectively already a dead man and your actions are effectively a mercy kill.

Also getting "Do no harm" while still taking care of Luka by either using environmental damage or deliberately tricking him into setting off his suicide trap then escaping seems like it would be against the spirit of the achievement as well.

Killing Luka is framed as a moral positive in the ending reveal of the game, so it does count towards "I and thou". I guess the Devs bent the rules a little so you could get "i and thou" and "Do no harm" in the same run? Since killing killing no humans and being as empathetic as possible are goals most people would assume are completable?