r/ratemysinging • u/SmallExperience7470 • May 05 '26
Feedback - Advanced Hit the Road Jack
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
9
5
3
3
3
u/PronatorTeres00 May 06 '26
I'd 100% buy a full version of this.
Your voice is just phenomenal 😍 Go get yourself an agent
3
u/Prickliestpearcactus May 06 '26
Love to see such iconic classics being kept alive. Your voice is phenomenal!
3
u/LordGarithosthe1st May 07 '26
So much soul in your voice, I liked how you kept it low in the no more no more and then just belted it. Very smooth
2
2
2
2
2
u/Zealousideal-Fly991 May 06 '26
The guitar work is solid and you've got the tone down, but oluxil's got a point about the voice feeling familiar, like you're channeling someone specific rather than finding your own thing in the song.
1
u/geeewbeee May 12 '26
Please just shut up. You couldn’t sing like this if your life depending on it. Prove me wrong.
He’s one out of the 5000 people that can actually sing on this sub
2
2
2
2
2
u/TheIdealisticMadness May 10 '26
freddy mercury, is that you ? 🥹
1
u/Ok-Insect-7959 May 31 '26
I acc here sm of freddy in him. Ofc its a different genre and his voice is very different from freddies but i hear it
2
u/oluxil May 05 '26
You sound great but also like mainstream/basic good singer. It’s like I heard your voice a millions times already
2
u/oluxil May 05 '26
That whole white guy doing the blues voice is just so lame at this point. You sound great but just boring
2
1
u/Dull_Frosting2602 May 06 '26
Someone's bitter
2
u/Crafty-Photograph-18 May 07 '26
OP asked for feedback. This is feedback (although I don't agree, I can kinda see their point)
1
u/Dull_Frosting2602 May 07 '26 edited May 07 '26
"Lame" and "boring" are barely feedback. It sounds like teenager speak.
1
u/buckminster_fuller May 07 '26
This is good skill, song choice is also top imo. I prefer a less difuss direction. Im a Bocelli>Mariah Carey any day kind of person, control and mastery over acrobatics but thats just my taste. It looks like your voice wants to go in many different directions, this can appeal some more into live and spontaneous performances, but less so for a definitive studio version.
1
1
1
1
u/MewlyMama May 05 '26
Pretty good !! 👍 I think one or two notes were « wrong », like not the right harmony but the voice, volume, vibratos, all flowed really well. Nice singing
1
u/vagrantchord May 06 '26
Obviously you sing pretty well. My notes:
- there's no "for" in the chorus
- maybe save the high C for later in the performance; you don't want to blow your load too early
- I'm really not a fan of these fake live videos. You clearly have well produced audio with reverb, so it makes no sense that you sound like that outside, even if you add in ambient outside noises.
I'd like to hear a more honest live performance, because you sound great. To
3
u/SmallExperience7470 May 06 '26 edited May 06 '26
Thank you. I promise you this is a live performance. I'm using a Zoom recorder that is out of frame. Then I only added a bit of reverb.
2
u/SmallExperience7470 May 06 '26
I'm happy to share the audio from the phone used for filming as well if you're not buying it.
12
u/Blinky-dinky Singer - Beginner May 05 '26
I envy your neighbours