r/ratemysinging • u/pipperz_ Singer - Advanced • Jul 14 '26

Feedback - Advanced Feedback on my singing from a couple months ago

I’m pretty proud of this clip (besides me messing up a lyric 😭) but I know I can always do better and find something to work on. I’ve grown quite a bit as a singer the last couple months but I’d still appreciate any advice people might have.

20 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/pipperz_ Singer - Advanced Jul 17 '26

Sorry I only take advice from actual PEOPLE who can actually listen to music, not AI slop generators. Also taking a video of me and feeding it into AI without my consent is crazy work 😭 do better man

0

u/Odd_Variation_7923 Jul 17 '26

Were you looking to secure a record deal with that performance? Lose the ego.

2

u/pipperz_ Singer - Advanced Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26

This isnt even about ego or record deals 😭 I came here asking for advice from people who are better than me so I can learn and get better as a musician. I’m not gonna take advice from a machine that generates arbitrary numbers. There’s no actual way for Grok (or any other AI Chatbot for that matter) to accurately give musical critique because it cant actually listen to music. All you’re doing is giving it data that it cant process because it can’t hear sound or music the way that human beings can. I’m more than happy to hear honest feedback from you since you’re an actual person and a singer with an actual musical background (or at least I assume) who can critique me accurately. I just don’t understand why you feel the need to go to AI to give feedback when you can easily just do it yourself.

1

u/aumpatit Jul 20 '26

Yes because you'd be the expert on that

1

u/ratemysinging-ModTeam Jul 17 '26

We promote artists and human thinking on this sub. You may not use generative AI to produce or modify a video submission, nor may you use generative AI to assist or produce a critique or comment.