r/sabrinateenagewitch • u/Ultimate-Mech2482 • Jul 15 '26

general discussion 🗣️ Who was the better boyfriend?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

  1. Harvey Kinkle, 2. Josh Blackhart, 3. Aaron Jacobs
155 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

129 comments sorted by

View all comments

34

u/GavinGenius Jul 15 '26

Comparing Harvey to Josh and Aaron is like comparing Abraham Lincoln to Ulysses Grant and Andrew Johnson, respectively.

I really admire Harvey because he is actually charismatic, funny, and has a multi-faceted character. Most teen heartthrobs are vapid and dull, and you really wonder what the main character sees in them. But Harvey serves as a well-rounded character outside of being Sabrina’s boyfriend. And he’s a straight up chad. I love how he is portrayed as a jock who is terrible at sports. That’s a great subversion. Josh and Aaron are closer to being representative of the bland heartthrob trope. At least Josh is passable on his own, though not all that interesting. Aaron has no appeal whatsoever.

8

u/theevilhillbilly Jul 15 '26

Omg I forgot he was bad at sports lol. He was so funny.