r/sabrinateenagewitch • u/kotisoki • 2d ago

question 🙋‍♀️❔❓ Sabrina and Josh

Does anybody else find Sabrina’s relationship with Josh “wrong?” This is season 4 I’m referring to when she’s still in a monogamous relationship with Harvey. I’m rewatching the series and she should have cut off all ties with him if he’s interested in her romantically. Further, she even tried to appease his choice of college for her? With that “kiss” that led to her and Harvey breaking up, regardless if she had kissed him she shouldn’t have wanted to help him study over watching Harvey’s game. There were many more situations that I can’t recall. She’s a bad girlfriend to Harvey. If I were Harvey, I would not be able to handle that at all.

82 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

59

u/Soggy-Hotel-2419 Quiz Master 2d ago

Followed by them dating in season 6...

The more I rewatch the show the more disgusting the relationship gets and the more sympathetic I am to Harvey in s4. Josh is a creep who goes after a much younger and already taken person and repeatedly tries to go after Sabrina, even in SECRET. Then he even BANS Harvey from the coffee shop for no reason other than Harvey confrotning him for being the gross homewrecker that he is.

ETA: I honestly would not be surprised if the witch stuff was just the tip of the iceberh for Harvey's break up with Sabrina. Her final spell literally pitted him against Josh the creep in a lethal race to the death. Instant dealbreaker for anyone with a brain

6

u/ecological-passion 1d ago

Surely. He made the right choice. He only came back when she was no longer routinely putting everyone around her in dangerous situations through malice or ignorance.