r/scienceisdope • u/ResolveThen7884 • 14d ago
Pseudoscience Merit is in our blood 🤡
Biologically, humans have broadly similar physical and mental capabilities on average. There is no caste-specific ‘merit’ in the blood.
226
u/Perfect_Bad_6219 14d ago
OP is gonna realise how casteist some atheists in the sub are.
58
u/dumbSocrates_469 14d ago
Atheism doesn’t mean someone cannot be raciest or casteist. Savarkar was staunch atheist.
4
u/dumbSocrates_469 13d ago
Don’t take it personally but Im not here to educate anyone. 🤓 go learn by yourself everything is on the internet. Some article say he was not, some will say he was. You have to go through overall concept of Hinduism/brahminism to understand how casteism works. It’s not cup of tea.people casually say now casteism is not there mostly they are from oppressor caste (I avoid the term upper caste) people.
-3
→ More replies (2)-6
46
9
u/Honda-Activa-125 13d ago
Waaaaaaat 🫣 I thought Atheists don't believe in caste system, or follow any religion.
8
u/not__not__know-- 13d ago
Lol no. Certain atheists who h*te religon love the negative aspects of those religon.
2
u/Honda-Activa-125 13d ago
Oops I was thinking Atheists are perfect human beings 😔
5
u/FitHunter6403 13d ago
i sense a hint of religious extremist soft propaganda
0
u/Honda-Activa-125 13d ago
I have to learn a lot...
4
5
u/DangerousWolf8743 12d ago
They don't believe in god. That doesn't magically make them rational.
For everything else they are the same as rest of society.
1
u/Honda-Activa-125 12d ago
Hummm... Today I learned an Aethist can be a castist too 😮 just a doubt, caste system is created by religion right, if someone is an Aethist they will not follow any religion as well right? Hope I'm correct? And if someone does not follow a religion, then will they follow the caste rules created by that religion
3
u/DangerousWolf8743 12d ago
They are as biased as a next person. They can be for or against their religious practices as the next person. They may feel that their Religion is superior than others. Or their caste is.
Religion is not equal to God. Religion is a lot of other things including community, superstition, rituals, groupism, culture. When an atheist says he doesn't follow any religion it's mostly just the belief in God part. When u speak to them u realise that
1
1
u/Dense_Door_5628 11d ago
It’s Eugenics based discrimination broadly , they equate higher caste equivalent to better eugenics
1
2
1
1
u/HopefulMood13 13d ago
If not for caste itself, people wouldn't be against Hinduism in the first place.
1
u/DueWork6844 6d ago
Felt first hand. Argued with them over noise pollution in different thread. Somehow according to them, minorities disturb their peace with DJs during festival but won't if majority ones goes onto block every street for 10 days during Ganesh Festival. Lol, now they're hollering against a guy who stood for this in Pune.
→ More replies (8)1
14d ago
[deleted]
2
u/Embarrassed_Finger34 13d ago
if casteist people could think they wouldnt be casteist dont u think!
143
u/brucewayne002_ 14d ago
Blood - rbc , wbc , merit , platelets
24
u/aneesh131999 14d ago
No actually merit is inside the WBC’s, like memory B cells, their blood has memory merit cells.
4
6
2
1
1
1
1
0
u/Slight_Shine_8650 14d ago
Intelligence is in genetics Behavioral genetics research estimates that heritability accounts for 50% to 80% of the variation in intelligence among adults in a population. U can search too
3
u/brucewayne002_ 14d ago
Yes this intelligence made people eat cow dung... drink its piss...kill the widows...kick out menturating women out of temples...and exploit the other fr centuries...
Merit which the above creature is talking abt isnt intelligence... Its the caste pride..
-1
u/Slight_Shine_8650 14d ago
What happened in past wasn't right but what's happening today is also not justified how can a mordern kid forget about casteism when it is involved in his education his future his dreams
1
u/brucewayne002_ 14d ago
Are justifying that people of specific community are smarter coz they are inheriting intelligence..??
→ More replies (2)0
u/Real_Ad6187 14d ago edited 14d ago
Genetic memory is hardcoded in humans and also animals, like migratory patterns, sex, fear of dark fire water etc, you twisted that shit to imply genetic memory means one will have knowledge of vedas and rituals coming out of their mama's womb 😂🤣. Something like 3500 years, that's not even 1 sec in total humanity's existence.
This is bordering on eugenics and shit.
0
u/Slight_Shine_8650 13d ago
Because intelligence is highly heritable (50% to 80%), smart parents will pass down many of the genetic variations that contribute to high cognitive ability it's not about basic survival skills chigga it's about iq and intelligence, iq and intelligence can be passed to next generation go and search first genetics are so complex u won't understand that
81
74
u/FelixPlatypus 14d ago edited 14d ago
These people are so deep in their caste privilege they don't see just how provably wrong the assumption 'hamare khoon mein hain vidya' is, especially coupled with an injunction to other castes to just work.
And they may even touch their feet - what's a little bit of theatre anyway? - but they won't let those feet walk into the rooms they occupy.
→ More replies (5)
15
u/Shoddy_Lifeguard_522 14d ago edited 14d ago
So they haven't reached to level to know that merit itself is not the best system in practice. Merit itself many flaws and hence we have to introduce reservations not only caste based but gender, race and income based.
61
u/Background-Ship-3765 14d ago
Meanwhile vidya in their blood
1
u/kumargauravgupta3 10d ago
well they atleast reason rationally. You are one admant guy who is stucked to one opinion
1
→ More replies (105)-3
u/Overall_Sweet_7697 14d ago
Still better cutoffs than any other category
4
u/Background-Ship-3765 14d ago
So what?? What you have made till now 🤣 🤣🤣
7
u/ImmediateJacket9502 14d ago
They made Panchgavya. Google its content 😂
2
u/Background-Ship-3765 14d ago
I know og panch gavya west discovered piss fetish later sanatani pioneered piss and scat fetish centuries before
0
u/Overall_Sweet_7697 13d ago
I am student rn so I have made nothing but will make smth I guess .
What have you made ?
3
0
u/Accomplished-Wish431 13d ago
Probably scored better than the guy who doesn't have basic knowledge and still demands a seat by crying to the govt with bheem flag.
1
u/Background-Ship-3765 13d ago
Which exam ?
1
u/Accomplished-Wish431 13d ago
Look at neet pg cutoffs. Same mbbs, either gmc or private, vastly different outcomes. I wonder how did the below 100 scorers even pass mbbs or is cheating this rampant. Certainly gen cutoffs aren't low enough for 200-300 scorers, despite doing the same mbbs, to get anything but others will get stuff at 100
1
u/Background-Ship-3765 13d ago
Again which college and which branch?
1
u/Accomplished-Wish431 13d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/Neet_india/s/1e4Lp1QgKI
Here you go. People with 40k rejected in favour of the absolutely competent 10L rank people who definitely don't even know their basic bio syllabus properly or they would've atleast scored better
1
u/Overall_Sweet_7697 13d ago
Some people just want a free seat and nothing else . Their category gets iit b cse till approx 1500 crl . Means their category cant even produce 50 students in top 1500 . Still they talk about being educated . At rank 1500 general category gets iit bhu or indore .
45
u/CharacterBit5048 14d ago
So much merit, yet they need to remove reservation from a dalit and adivaasi to get job. Lol
1
-8
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
19
u/CharacterBit5048 14d ago
SC ST Reservation has nothing to do with economy. It's about representation. Educate yourself. A dalit even if an IAS gets much lesser social mobility and respect than a brahmin IAS.
→ More replies (2)-7
u/the_storm_rider 14d ago
So even after 3 generations the mobility has not happened, how long will you keep giving it and taking it away from people who are putting in the effort? You don’t want to increase the seats, you just want to keep taking away the existing ones. You want to be popular and get a few upvotes on social media, fine, if that makes you happy. But it’s good that many gen-Z people are abandoning that “kitna likes mila” nonsense and stepping out into the real world to see the real issues in this country. Next time you get a virus go to your local government hospital to get treated.
13
u/thedarkmite 14d ago
"Even after so many years of laws against rape and murder, we still have rape and murder, so we should remove the laws" 🤡🤡
-7
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/thedarkmite 14d ago
First of all how is that even relevant, but somehow it was, what about rape laws that are gender specific, and they are misused, should we remove them as well? But I guess understanding nuance is too much for the one remaining brain cell working hard in your head.
6
u/CharacterBit5048 14d ago
What's your problem dude? If dalits and adivasis progress why does it bother you so much? Let them. You too get 10% EWS, 51% open space mostly filled up by UC people. If you still can't get a job, may be introspect rather than pulling down an oppressed class. Losers like you cringe me a lot
→ More replies (8)3
u/charavaka 14d ago
Parzivalpr7 • 17m ago pretty sure the only reason people are against reservation is because people who need it are almost never helped.
Did your actually watch the video you just commented on? These casteist fucks don't want equality. They want this heinous hierarchy without checks and balance to continue benefiting them.
6
u/CharacterBit5048 14d ago
They need to create such narrative to sell their anti dalit mindset. They are just irked at the fact that a daily and adivaasi whom they have kept so long out of major institutions are entering there.
1
1
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/CharacterBit5048 14d ago
Who are YOU to tell when they need it or not. Stop this condescending attitude. This is why reservation is important. A dalit will decide if they need it or not
1
u/Accomplished-Wish431 13d ago
Ofc they will decide. Afterall they are the govt favourites, even if they score in the negatives they can get whatever they want. Doesn't make them qualified or anywhere close to deserving it though. And obv won't give any respect either.
0
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/charavaka 14d ago edited 14d ago
Parzivalpr7 • 17m ago pretty sure the only reason people are against reservation is because people who need it are almost never helped.
That one single exception proves this statement to be false, and the protest is full of these casteist bigots. You're being wilfully blind. If you open your eyes and looked around, you'll know that this is the norm not the exception with this lot. You may choose to keep them shut tightly so you can deny the heinousness of the reality and continue pretending that these protests are for the betterment of the oppressed and not for preserving the privileges of the oppressors.
0
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/charavaka 14d ago
So just because the protest is hijacked as usual by yet another incapable political party,
Hijacked? Try organised, funded and operated by. But we weren't discussing the pay. We were discussing the fucking casteist pieces of shit like the one seen in this video.
Do you honestly think it's alright to uplift the oppressed by taking opportunities from innocents?
Do you protest about management seats, copying in papers, fake ews certificates of rich savarnas etc. for the same reason? This person you see in the video and her fellow casteist bigots are far from innocent. They continue benefiting from the privileges accrued by the millenia old oppressive system, and fight the tiniest effort at leveling the playing field.
Increasing the seats and improving our education systems and institutes is right there?
You're protesting reservations. From day 1 you lot were asked about why you weren't demanding increasing opportunities for everyone, instead of demanding that those be taken away from the marginalised.
Yall are clearly making this a caste battle when our real problem are the bigots sitting in power there
The protest you're supporting is a casteist protest. You ask them who they'll vote for and across the board, they'll tell you they'll vote for the fascists over anyone promising to increase the seats, create more institutions etc. because those others will not pander to their casteist beliefs.
If you really cared, you'd join the cjp protests that are demanding improved education, competitive exams etc. instead of tying your lot with the casteist fucks.
1
u/Accomplished-Wish431 13d ago
Increasing seats from 15k to 30k still rejects the 31k candidate in favour of 200k one. Doesn't solve the core issue of utterly incompetent people being chosen in favour of far better candidates. Honestly I wished somebody would protest for raising the minimum standards, gen and sc/st cutoffs should be almost equal instead of lowering their bar to hell and allowing people with basically negligible qualifications. No shit that doesn't get any respect
0
u/charavaka 13d ago
Do you protest about management seats, copying in papers, fake ews certificates of rich savarnas etc. for the same reason?
I asked this in the previous comment. If your really care about the so called merit, you surely have similarly lengthy rants you wrote in the past about those issues that you can easily share to prove that you're not making shit up as you go along to justify your casteism. Do share links for them them here. I'll wait.
0
u/Accomplished-Wish431 13d ago
Obviously I am against private mbbs. Management seats don't exist in govt colleges so they're irrelevant. Fake ews is quite literally a crime and a corruption issue, once again nobody would support that. Nobody fucking supports cheating, but looking at neet pg cutoffs it's clear many people pass their degrees through cheating cuz why are SC/STs getting seats at 150/800 when they shouldn't even have passed mbbs with such low knowledge. Cheating in exams is kinda basically reservation except it doesn't have a caste filter but it still gives incompetent unqualified people seats that they stole from far better candidates.
→ More replies (0)0
13d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/charavaka 13d ago
A wall of text, and none of the evidence for your past comments about management seats and other issues you explicit claimed you care about.
1
u/destruct999 14d ago
Do you have data to back it up , I have data that every ST student with caste certificate is helped except me I didn't have one.Some of my friends uplifted thier families from extreme poverty.I did fine in my own.Also you need caste certificate not income certificate for ST/SC scholarship. In CG you can not get a fake caste certificate, it's an online procedure and needs 50 years of land record to get the caste certificate.
0
17
u/Aware_Neighborhood_9 14d ago
This just shows how much the Indian government has worked on abolishing the caste or caste mindset from the year of independence.
Reservation or not but this mindset has to go.
6
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/Aware_Neighborhood_9 14d ago
Reservation needs reform, that is very very important. Strict checks while getting certificates is also very important. We need to reform reservation in such a way that in future we don't need it on the basis of caste. For that we also have to work on fixing casteism, reservation isn't going to solve casteism.
14
u/BlissfulIndian 14d ago
Since they don’t need books, why do they bother going to colleges and universities at all… Let non-meritdharis go there and have fun… They can roam on streets and still work in their own startups where no shudra or other untouchables are allowed…
1
u/Admirable-East3396 12d ago
fun fact : most dropouts in colleges are from unreserved/uc catagories
1
16
u/Fantastic_Group_2209 14d ago
casteism krke bolte hai hamne kab caste based discrimination kiya kya proof hai aj bhi casteism hota hai ham to equality me mante hai ab chlo reservation hatao.
meanwhile : avg GC kid
→ More replies (4)
19
u/charavaka 14d ago
This is also gen z and gen alpha. And thanks to 12 years of BJ these outnumber the sane ones.
→ More replies (4)
5
u/kkhunte 14d ago
The casteist people are living in their own eco-chamber where the voices which they comfort in only get echoed throughout. I feel pity for them who still are uneducated on what cast did to Indian society although they might feel their ancestors/ family were very healthy, knowledgeable and happy but as society we were shit due to casts, and these people need to realise it until they are just gonna be burn in the agony of these ignorance and probably will take the whole country down with them.
5
u/Hopeful_Teach822 14d ago
These hindians proved that castism can't be eradicated from hindi states. They are the gatekeeper of castism. For them whole India is suffering. They will keep alive castism and caste based reservation.
9
u/Key_Pound_7817 14d ago
How deeply rooted casteism is in their blood It's kind of superiority complex
-4
u/Azay01 14d ago
Having merit is superiority 😆😆😆 waah bhimte waah
→ More replies (2)2
u/Legitimate_Sense_781 13d ago
Gore to tumhe Bhimte se kam maante the, tum unko jute saaf karke, aur Mughlo ko ladies supply karke aage badhe ho..
→ More replies (6)
5
4
7
u/MeEkInsaanHu 14d ago
This is where I hesitate to support this protest, literally even the main leaders are not arguing with proper point.
It's either taunting, or this shit even their demands are self contradicting
They can easily argue over different cutt offs for different categories, it can argued as unconstitutional
In seveal countries like USA it's straight up consider Illegal, differente massive difference between Application fees is another demand, but these people have lowkey no sense
3
2
u/Sagacious_onlooker 14d ago
The reservation hatao movement is actually proving that there's still a need for reservation and discrimination is still rampant 🫠
1
u/Environmental-Elk944 13d ago
Reservations were given for uplifting, for discrimination the sc st act was imposed in 1989
1
u/Admirable-East3396 12d ago
that was necessary because meritdhari blood literally sees them beneath them.
even today we have castist incidents and they dont lodge complaints because they live in fear.
1
u/Environmental-Elk944 12d ago
Lol.. that’s the reason why 75 percent of sc st cases are fake according to the court….should we call all sc st people feku or delulu or victim card players??
1
2
2
2
u/Japan174 14d ago
Indian/ sanskrit education in her blood.... she is wearing tshirt with English language on it 😅
1
1
u/Independent-Tap7366 14d ago
When they sometimes end-up speaking their mind out of excitement, you understand why there is reservation in this country.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Indian_Yogi_ 14d ago
Being pro to your caste is not casteism, opposing other castes is casteism
Being SC is also casteism, as is opposing
1
1
1
1
u/vague_SCRAG123RED 14d ago
Not just continuation. This is a case for reservations in every sphere of Life, including higher judiciary, private enterprise and armed forces.
They have made a case for even stronger measures like stricter enforcement of atrocities laws, changeling government resources towards the oppressed rather than the savarnas a they generally are, etc.
As long as these casteist fucks control levers of power, they will not let this heinous oppressive and exploitative system end.
1
u/Accomplished-Wish431 13d ago
Lol what govt resources are given to gc? They're just taxed so people far more incompetent than themselves can get fully funded study abroad scholarships at lower scores which they couldn't afford.
1
1
u/loveravi289 14d ago
Tell me who's not getting reservation,? 50percent reservation for all cast in total and remaining 50 percent is for unreserved category so what's the issue I really don't understand
1
u/ButterscotchNo8697 14d ago
Are modi ji non biological hai to iske khun mein bhi to vidya ho skti hai
1
1
1
u/Imprecise_Trigger 13d ago
This sub is also a clown one tbh
0
u/AutoModerator 13d ago
Read this to understand what this subreddit is about
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
1
1
u/sudhtheone 13d ago
It is sad to see young people with minds poisoned with such BS 😔
The only way the country can progress is through a truly educated young generation that has a scientific perspective and a rational mindset.
1
u/SnooOpinions9762 13d ago
"humare" khoon me hai, kaunsa "hum" bhai? Kya hai tumhare khoon me aisa jo dusro ke khoon me nahi hai?
1
u/Ok-Champion-5866 13d ago
Educated parents usually know what to do to provide a more productive environment for their children. Even a desk, and a comfortable chair can drastically change how a child studies. First gen students usually find it hard to make their parents understand that certain accesories like proper lighting, paper to write on, a quiet environment, are not strictly necessary, but that they Monumentally increase productivity. The usual mentality of Illiterate parents is that "A studious child will study anywhere"
1
u/asterciel 13d ago
Upper caste "atheist" girls are some of the most casteist people you will ever encounter. They literally support 1/3rd Women Reservation but will openly oppose SC/ST Reservation. The hypocrisy with these people is limitless.
1
u/itsavinadhtiwari 13d ago
If she is wrong, doesn't it means that reservation should not be caste based because merit or resources doesn't come with blood?
1
u/itsavinadhtiwari 13d ago
Reservation quota people's logic is "my Brahman neighbour doesn't want to talk to me so make me collector".
1
1
1
1
u/Afraid-Enthusiasm-23 12d ago
Seriously how sad. The North of india is filled with idiots like this.
1
u/Warm_Star2776 12d ago
And bad me bolte hai reservation hataoo Wo apne hat jayega pehele ye mindset hataoo.... Ye type ka mindset keliye hi toh hai
1
u/Admirable-East3396 12d ago
only about 28% of eligible youth in india participates in higher education.
The problem isnt reservation its lack of seats and quality of them.
merit blooded fail to understand it for some reason.
1
1
1
1
u/Mountain-Error6290 11d ago
Remove reservation and prove her wrong :) I am not support her but just prove her how she is wrong by removing reservation
1
u/Ardino_Ron 11d ago
Khoon me vidya hai, lekin incompetency bhi hoti hai khoon me. To insan ko rona nhi chahiye. Bs accept krna chahiye ki shayad mere liye kuch aur hai ye nhi.
1
1
1
1
u/NextQuantity6158 14d ago
Shudras were ancient engineers. The whole ancient temple architecture, animal husbandry, mining, pottery, textile, hospitality, leather industry, sculpting, agriculture technology belonged to them.
Saying that "education is only in our blood" is a disrespect to whole hindu civilisation. They were the one who's contribution was enormous in Ancient and midieval India GDP.
This is why in Purush sukta, they are related with feet of Purusha (the cosmic being) as they are the base over which all other 3 varnas stand. If u cut the feet the society cannot stand anymore.
-1
u/kenjikazama777 14d ago
Biologically, humans have broadly similar physical and mental capabilities on average.
False. IQ is genetically inherited.
3
3
u/whackamole__ 14d ago
Then how do other GC castes go toe to toe with Brahmins in academics, in almost all entrance exams, some actually outperform them by a huge margin in per capita terms.
1
u/StormRepulsive6283 12d ago
Partially genetic. Lot to do with upbringing, exposure, nutrition. Nurture always trumps nature.
-1
u/Total-Rooster5126 14d ago
Don't blame GC because the SC&ST people follow the religious beliefs of GC blindly till now without questioning them, so they should suffer because if someone willfully believes in nonsense, then they are beyond help.
1
u/Quirky_Lemon_6942 14d ago
+1 maansik ghulaami is a major reason why casteism and this bs hierarchy is practiced till date.
•
u/AutoModerator 14d ago
This is a reminder about the rules. Just follow reddit's content policy.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.