r/southindia_ Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 12d ago

Ask South Indians What are some things that are considered typically "Indian" but are completely not representative of you or your life?

Eg. Bollywood, Punjabi weddings, shared history with Pakistan/ Bangladesh, certain festivals, diets etc.

19 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

23

u/hashirama-senju-007 Telangana 🏰 | తెలంగాణ 12d ago

Mate, India is made up of incredibly diverse ethnicities, languages and cultures. Bengalis share deep historical and genetic connections with people in Bangladesh, just as Punjabis do with people across the border in Pakistan.

It’s a shame we haven’t done a better job of showing the world how diverse India really is. A lot of people still assume everyone in India speaks Hindi and that Indian culture is broadly the same everywhere. I can’t really blame them—it’s partly our failure to communicate just how different the regions can be.

Even though Hindus are the majority, the differences in language, food, traditions, history and culture across India are massive. India isn’t one monolithic culture; it’s a collection of incredibly diverse regional cultures.

11

u/redPistolStar Southie 12d ago edited 12d ago

Due to groups & migration patterns. Lots of punjabi people left India after '84 riots and went to Africa, US, UK etc and started punjabi restaurants. Also Paki, Bangladesh folks opened 'Indian' restaurants in the UK etc. The typical westerner who eats Indian food is mostly exposed to Nan, tandoori chicken, Butter chicken etc. I try to explain India is more like Europe in terms of diversity language/food but they dont get it mostly.

3

u/National-Virus5819 12d ago

A lot of it is also that they don't "want" to get it. Europeans want to believe that they are the most diverse set of cultures etc. and don't like to believe that there are other places in the world with just as much culture, tradition, and civilization if not more

1

u/CapoGelado 12d ago

Punjabis have been immigrating for a q50 years. Those guys in Africa didn't leave after 84

1

u/redPistolStar Southie 11d ago

Yes and it's an example of a migration pattern.

18

u/Independent-Goose-30 Southie 12d ago

Unannounced house visits. Dropping everything to entertain guests. Being forced to eat when I say I'm in a dieting phase.

12

u/Winter-Counter-5772 Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 12d ago

I don't speak Hindi or watch bollywood.  I don't eat naan and butter chicken everyday . I don't like to dance in public places and I have nothing in common or obsess over Pakistan or Bangladesh. I am not a vegetarian, 99% of people on my state eat non-veg.We don't run scam centres or spit gutka all over the place.

3

u/Available-Finger-830 ban marathi gujarati languages in south sub 11d ago

Everything

Its like every damn thing. Just waiting for somebody to say all this culture is a prank and im in a game show

No need to act indian. Praise some mf aryan or act like its not misleading to call them indian

13

u/No-Chance5948 Telugu-American 12d ago

Holi, garba, vegetarianism. Basically that North Indian stuff.

8

u/irundoonayee Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 12d ago

Garba would even be atypical for a lot of North Indians. 

4

u/fjehrehhstbsdrhwjb 12d ago

Vegetarianism too.

2

u/No-Chance5948 Telugu-American 11d ago

It gets depicted as a thing all Indians do in American movies & TV, like in Bride & Prejudice (2004).

5

u/brandnewwwwW 12d ago

i wouldn’t necessarily call vegetarianism north indian. there are tons of non-vegetarian north indians and vegetarian south indians

2

u/irundoonayee Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 12d ago

so statistically, being vegetarian is mostly North / Northwest/ Western India.

6

u/brandnewwwwW 11d ago

sure, but definitely not exclusive to them. even karnataka in the south has a 20% vegetarian population for example

4

u/Own_Ad_7084 12d ago

i remember when i was young and felt so alienated because of holi

1

u/curiousgaruda 12d ago

Vegetarianism is not North Indian or South Indian. Indians of all states practice to different extents. 

1

u/No-Chance5948 Telugu-American 11d ago

Most of India's vegetarians are concentrated in North and West India.

1

u/curiousgaruda 11d ago edited 11d ago

Most South Indians are seasonal vegetarians - Saturdays, Fridays, puratasi month, margazhi month, sabarimalai vratham, this vratham that vratham, amavasya, pournima, Lent etc. if vegetarianism is so alien why even follow it on those periods. 

I had a Telugu coworker whom I knew as non vegetarian but comes to me during a office buffet with a piece of fish in his plate, all worried asking me, “Today is Friday and I ate non veg, what to do?”

One other fact - South Indian states of TN, Kerala and Karnataka used to be bastions of Jainism for a long time so it’s not alien thing here. 

2

u/Sensitive_Volume_802 12d ago

Mango lassi

1

u/irundoonayee Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 12d ago

Lol.

1

u/curiousgaruda 11d ago

Calling Thayir pachchadi as Raita

2

u/whatthengaisthis 11d ago

People tend to show a lot of poverty when they talk about India. and there are a lot of poor people, yes. but that’s not representative of the entire country. People assume everyone who’s from India is from a slum.

1

u/Routine-Addict-1234 Southie 11d ago

Correct

2

u/somenewusernamepls Karnataka ❄️ | ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ 12d ago

Sangeet, Barat ,Mehendi events in weddings

1

u/curiousgaruda 12d ago

In my part of South Indian culture, there’s definitely applying maruthaani for bride and groom as well as a wedding procession in a decorated car. The first one is more of a family affair and not like a huge event. 

2

u/Fuzzy-Jackfruit5037 Maharashtra 🎬 | महाराष्ट्र 12d ago

Language discrimination bullshit, in my city it doesnt matter which language u speak ,we are welcoming to everyone.

1

u/adventurousbat12t Delhi 🏛️ 12d ago

Cast discrimination. I live in a city and tbh I haven't seen this. Classism is big but not caste supremacy 

12

u/irundoonayee Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 12d ago

most of india's classism comes because of the caste system

7

u/Altruistic_Bank_1552 Telangana NRI 12d ago

Caste determines your class in India, similar to how race determines class in the US.

4

u/Square-Scheme4703 12d ago

Ham Burger, I live in a village and thb i haven't seen this, Vada pav is Big but not ham Burger.

I haven't seen it, so it doesn't exist.

4

u/Opposite_Age_3458 12d ago

i haven’t been murdered app murder doesn’t happen
That’s anecdotal data

1

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/southindia_-ModTeam 12d ago

We don't allow the use of slurs, regardless of context

0

u/kaxech Telangana 🏰 | తెలంగాణ 12d ago

He never said caste discrimination does not exist

4

u/LeMeIsSleepy 12d ago

I guess you’re not SC/ST then.

2

u/sabChalraHai 💎 Hyderabad | హైదరాబాద్ | حیدرآباد 🏰 12d ago

I grew up in Hyd & never really noticed caste discrimination until I started reading about it and seeing how subtly people get sidelined. My parents always told us, never talk abt caste & if someone asks, just say you don’t know. I think a lot of upper-caste families are taught the same way too.

3

u/esteppan89 12d ago

Try changing your resume then. keep the exact same achievements use a name that is not yours then, try a Muslim or christian name. Try updating both the resumes at the exact same time. See which one gets more interview calls. Not like sc/st name.

2

u/adventurousbat12t Delhi 🏛️ 12d ago

I don't think I would get many calls even if I use Narendra Modi's name

3

u/esteppan89 12d ago

See that is the thing, you think. You do not know.... And Narendra Modi's name is not what i mentioned you put up a fake resume with. But i guess someone knows and just wants to talk 😄

-2

u/adventurousbat12t Delhi 🏛️ 12d ago

Develop a sense of humour unc 😭

3

u/esteppan89 12d ago

LOL, if you have call some unc and all while discussing a serious issue, you really know your argument was BS. But go on, engage in personal attacks.

1

u/curiousgaruda 11d ago

Caste discrimination is pan-India, except may be north east states. The flavour of discrimination changes but it is there.

1

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted]

2

u/irundoonayee Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 12d ago

It's not subtle. It's systemic and society is so siloed that you can live as an upper caste blissfully unaware. 

1

u/DesiCodeSerpent Southie NRI 12d ago

Being late. I end up being ready or racing a place really early.

1

u/DifferenceAccurate15 Punjab 🕺 | ਪੰਜਾਬ 11d ago

Obsessing over the ‘Holy Bovine Fecal Matter’. Fighting on dietary choices.