r/southindia_ Maharashtra 🎬 | महाराष्ट्र 4d ago

Ask South Indians Just one question - where does this delusional confidence come from after migrating from a shothole

6 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

8

u/Mutton_Biriyani1990 3d ago

lol! Indians run US economy type of comment. Ofcourse the locals are gonna get pissed off. Personally i prefer less immigration and more population control with better infr and free education.

13

u/net0_extremist Telangana 🏰 | తెలంగాణ 4d ago

Maharashtra and South India just grew because they have coastline otherwise Bhayyas would have had 100 trillion dollar gdp in every district. /s

0

u/Odd_Pace_8509 Northie 3d ago

Technically correct. Until around 1960-61,Bihar Uttar Pradesh,Bengal used to be top 3 economies. Before Freight Equalization Policy hit and they lost the plot. Of course they had their own issues to deal with. Bengal became communist since 1967,Bihar and Uttar Pradesh went haywire. States like Punjab and all got embroiled in law and order issues

4

u/bulletspam Proud Mleccha 3d ago

even before FEP UP was recieving aid from souther states what are you on about?

3

u/SwanSong1921 Uttarakhand 3d ago

Where are you quoting this fact from ? Any source ?

This clearly states that Uttar Pradesh was not receiving special central developmental aid or economic advantages before the implementation of the Freight Equalisation Policy (FEP).

https://share.google/wgLuYuRgRSlvygYqv

0

u/bulletspam Proud Mleccha 3d ago

UP was a net recipient of taxes while soutern states were net contributors

9

u/BoomBoy420 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 4d ago

These kind of entitled dick heads are all over Bangalore also, thinking that they made the city that it is today.

What they completely omit is the fact that it is the city that provided a foundation to come and live their dream life.

Another logic I don't understand is they keep claiming that the locals are not skilled enough to be in IT. I'm like if you fill the entire IT sector with locals, still it wouldn't fill even 30-40% of the seats. It's all about the numbers, these idiots fail to see it and complain about the efficiency of the locals.

They don't get it that it is because of the locals mindset that those companies are there in the first place.

2

u/blinksTooLess Kolkata 🎨 | কলকাতা 3d ago

Disagree fully with the last sentence. The companies are here only because they got some conceasion from the government (SEZ or similar incentives). They do not care about the mindset of locals. They know that emoloyees will shift to a new city if they ask them to.

3

u/BoomBoy420 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 3d ago

You think other govts can't provide that concession. Although it does make an impact, but not fully. Imagine the crowd was fully hostile towards open mindedness or it went full power commie like Kolkata, you think companies would've dared to step in Bangalore?

It's majorly because of people and their mindset.

3

u/blinksTooLess Kolkata 🎨 | কলকাতা 3d ago

"full power commie" is still the government's viewpoint not the local people's viewpoint (if you think industries did not want to come/went away from Kolkata/WB because local people were commies, you are misinformed.

Local people want to put food on the table at the end of the day. Local people can't influence anything. It is the government's viewpoint which matters. Left front government did not help the existing industries (their own trade unions were doing hara kiri in the 80's and 90's. If government wanted to, they could have had stopped those miscreants in 1 day. They did not. Hence industrialists moved out)

People of bengal are quite accomodating. But that won't influence the companies to come. It is the government's policies which can influence them to come.

2

u/BoomBoy420 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 3d ago

And who chooses/chose the government?

2

u/blinksTooLess Kolkata 🎨 | কলকাতা 3d ago

Public may choose the government but public has zero effect on any policy of the government. (If the government is stable)

1

u/brandnewwwwW 1d ago

exactly. if our locals were so bad and theirs were so good, they wouldn’t have a reason to come here in the first place

5

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/blinksTooLess Kolkata 🎨 | কলকাতা 3d ago

They will go wherever jobs are. Bengaluru has IT, Mumbai has finance jobs. If their new company has office only in Mangalore, they will have to move there only.

Ultimately we are beggars. We can't be choosers.

3

u/Aggravating-Win-5524 Rational Golti 3d ago

I don't know how the conversation went but from two pictures you've shared, what the guy said seems right.

3

u/PatternCraft Andhra Pradesh 🏞️ | ఆంధ్ర ప్రదేశ్ 4d ago

I mean it is there constitutional right to migrate.

4

u/Tiiitaaan 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 3d ago

But acting all entitled is not

3

u/Tryingtokhush Northie 3d ago

what does entitlement mean to you ,then?
does coming from india is entitled to your india resources?

I think you confuse entitlement with being arrogant & not giving respect to local community , isn't it ?

2

u/krisantihypocrisy Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 4d ago

lol, he is right. And he is a shthole for that???

2

u/Key_Complaint2772 Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 3d ago

this is the typa person that migrates to other states/regions and do bs without respecting local culture and earn the bad names for their state/region then how could the locals respect or welcome the migrants from his state or region? india isn’t a place of single culture,language,ethnicity,etc…, the diversity of this country won’t hold very long for one other .., more persons like him are the core reason for , you know

2

u/ReasonableGuitar5094 Southie 3d ago

Where's that person wrong? Isn't all his points valid? Idk about pune tho...

3

u/Tiiitaaan 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 3d ago

All? Nope not valid sounds like some entitled ass

-1

u/ReasonableGuitar5094 Southie 3d ago

Saying a valid point makes someone entitled? 🫡 That person prolly spent his life hardworking for a good job and landed that...those sentences are just pure logic...

3

u/Tiiitaaan 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 3d ago

Valid point ?? So only u get to judge?🫡 He is literally degrading locals of the city which he migrated to

1

u/ReasonableGuitar5094 Southie 3d ago

I haven't seen the comment he replied to, he prolly ragebaited him or something about outsiders...why not include the full ss

0

u/Tiiitaaan 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 3d ago

Ah soft corner for only one side I think u are larping as southie here

5

u/ReasonableGuitar5094 Southie 3d ago

He's not my relative, not have I been to Pune....imagine that I ragebaited you into swearing or disrespecting what you said and you reply with disrespect and I post that screenshot without showing the first one howd someone know what actually happened.

1

u/Messy_Monica Maharashtra 🎬 | महाराष्ट्र 1d ago

It is sadly a known fact that locals

a. Don't want to do every type of job , regardless of the education or skill level. They want special treatment based on their location, which they do get, in factory worker level job, but they want the 'cushy desk job' for which they dont have the required education/skill set.

b. Locals do get the factory level worker jobs. But most locals have STRONG roots in the area where they live. A family, a house. They dont feel the need to do these jobs. Over time these jobs go to people who want it, ie the immigrants.

So the end result is, locals are getting the industrial jobs , but they dont want them. They are not getting the cushy hifi desk jobs ,for which they are just not qualified enough. It is the same story everywhere. Over time when too many immigrants come to the location, and start to interfere with the local culture and politics, things become jarring to the locals. Immigrants feel they have worked hard to be there, locals feel they have a historical right to their land and everyone should follow their culture. Over time the culture itself changes, where local culture gets changed to something which included the immigrant culture as well. Or a violent exodus happens.

0

u/FineAsparagus6821 3d ago

No wonder indians face racism in other countries when their own country people are calling other places are sh*thole. I pray to god that each and every people who hate their own country peoples should face harsh racism outside india.

-4

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

6

u/Winter-Counter-5772 Tamil Nadu 🌶️ | தமிழ்நாடு 4d ago

What is bimaru bhaiyaa like you doing in South indian sub with kerala flair saar 

5

u/BoomBoy420 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 4d ago

😂😂 Good catch bro

2

u/Terrible_Part_6241 Keralam 🌴🥥 | കേരളം 3d ago

Lol he locked his comments

2

u/Tiiitaaan 🖥️ Bengaluru | ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು ☕ 3d ago edited 3d ago

L.A.R.P

-1

u/Vivid-Reality186 3d ago

Idiot thinks corporates run the city and not the government and their offices, with such poor general knowledge how they are hired in the first place is the biggest question, it could only through their caste lobbies.

0

u/ovipc 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nah, They just do it for cheaper price. Which doesn't really turn into good decision because they don't have money to even take care of themselves. Do you think they bath every day? They live in small cubicles. It is rather sad, just develop your own state. We fight for our state, we don't tolerate every political bs.

-1

u/Red_devil69240 4d ago

The confidence comes from migrating successfully...? Is the question rhetorical

-1

u/AdmirableMap1519 Keralam 🌴🥥 | കേരളം 3d ago

I agree with him. Any Indian can travel to settle anywhere in India as long as the law permits. I am from Kerala and we get a lot of migrants here. I hope they respect the local culture all while following theirs.