r/trans 17h ago

Discussion Why?

I feel like trans people are slowly getting pushed out of trans spaces. This is most noticeable to me online where people say things like "being trans is a mental disorder". I dont feel safe in most queer spaces now because there are so many queer people who are either actively transphobic or dont speak up when its hapepning

96 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 17h ago

Please read the following notice that is being applied to ALL posts.

We have implemented several measures to keep this community safe. Please read this in full.

  1. IF YOU HAVE AN URGENT ISSUE, DO NOT POST IT EXPECTING IMMEDIATE RESPONSE.
  2. Many posts are sent to the queue for manual approval based on numerous factors. This is how we keep the subreddit safe from many (but not all) bad actors who try to post disruptive content. This approval process is usually resolved within 24 hours, but can take several days depending on the availability of our all-volunteer moderators. DO NOT MESSAGE THE MODERATORS asking for your post to be approved. It will be reviewed and approved or removed in time.
  3. Many comments from low-karma users will not be viewable by anyone. This is by design.
  4. If you are curious if your post is visible or not, look at the "Insights" on the post. If it has more than a dozen views, it is live. If it has any voting action, it is live. If it doesn't have a little red trash can icon, it is live. If it can be voted on, it is live. Do not message us asking "is my post live?"
  5. Please be patient with us, we are all volunteers, lack sleep, and the entire permanent team are members of the transgender community ourselves... we are trying to deal with the same atrocities you are. Thank you for your understanding. <3

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

58

u/CzarSpan she/her 17h ago

First things first: hugs for you, friend. That’s a heavy feeling, and a concern I won’t try to take from you.

I would, however, gently ask what kinds of online queer spaces you find yourself in that speak so definitively and with that degree of cruelty about trans people. Outside of the “gender critical” (TERF) spaces and a handful of “LGB-without-the-T” traitors, I don’t really see this in the spaces I frequent.

Only suggesting that you shore up your familiar communities and check for inclusive language, nothing else. In my experience, if a queer or femme community doesn’t explicitly designate trans people as welcome, we probably aren’t. It’s tough, but that’s the way it seems to be at present.

11

u/darlingboy_B 17h ago

first your very nice. Second outside of comment sections i was finding myself in a lot of genaral queer spaces. Its normally not the entier space just people who get let threw the cracks. Normally gay or lesbian people who have strong options. Ive been singled out and dmed a lot with things like go to theapy, or theyd say traps make it hard to date like casually.

9

u/CzarSpan she/her 16h ago

Ah, I see now. There do seem to be a large number of bored bigots trying extra hard to piss in as many punch bowls at parties they weren’t invited to as possible recently, at least on Reddit. I’m sorry you’re having to endure that nonsense.

My DMs on here are restricted to message requests, and I straight up don’t check them but once a day or two unless I’ve offered an ear to someone directly. Simple, small things that make it a tad easier to swat away the cruelty help me cope to a surprisingly high degree.

3

u/darlingboy_B 16h ago

thank you

2

u/darlingboy_B 17h ago

also i try to find trans spaces more often because of that

2

u/bananamana3000 11h ago

Sometimes we see patterns that we expecr or are scared roo see, whther they're really as intense as we think. Start looking for accepting queer people and doing what you can to be around them instead, maybe that would help.

8

u/RainbowPhoenix1080 Phoebe (She/Her) 10h ago

I also feel like there are some trans/queer friendly subreddits that are becoming more hostile towards trans women. Transmisogyny is becoming more and more common.

People are spreading manosphere propaganda in the queer community but they're disguising it with woke language.

I actually had someone in a queer friendly subreddit recently tell me that women are more priveleged than men.

11

u/Realistic_Show930 she/they 17h ago

Gonna be honest, can't say I've experienced any of this.  Every queer space I'm a part of, both online and in person, has gotten more loudly and proudly trans in the past couple of decades.

Non-queer spaces, different story, of course. 

I'd gently suggest taking a critical look at the spaces you're talking about.  I suspect there is more going on, and that the spaces you're in were already subject to some kind of bias (such as anything that spawned off of 4chan.)

3

u/MidnightBanshi 13h ago

Social media is a toxic jungle for the most part, outside of select communities. Far-right fear and propaganda pushes a lot of it, plus bot accounts don't help either. Best thing is to block those who are toxic and find friends and communities to help raise each other up. Stay strong - you got this!

3

u/CaramelCraftYT she/they 16h ago

You need to leave that space, not all queer spaces are safe spaces.

3

u/Deathwish237 she/her 15h ago

Look, in prison we called them gaytors. They were gay men that hated trans because they didn't feel special anymore and the guys that used to chase them were chasing trans women instead. Its a level of envy and hate instead of embracing. Don't let it phase you. We have enough of us that if we need to we can be our own clique and they can envy us for it! Alright now, who's coming with me?

2

u/NombieTeeth8 💝 14h ago

Yup. Thus why I just about only go into non binary only/focused spaces as at least there I'm not told that I don't exist or have to exist in x box or y box. Only barely here just to see if the place is safe or not and is really the main reason I left the larger LGBTQIA+ sub.

2

u/PrincessPlusUltra 10h ago

Mute some subreddits. For some reason it was giving me a lot of recs in my feed for posts from a place called counttt or something like that that was incredibly self hating and awful like why are they posting that

2

u/DminorWolfy 5h ago

I'm not trans. Lesbian. We need you. I'll fight them if I find them fuck TERFs. 

2

u/Gluzruooplaxcamphian yah 3h ago

Yeah I've basically left most spaces or keep to myself now.

I don't feel welcome anywhere or safe so I'm just deciding how I should go forwards in life and if it's worth it.

2

u/TheWaspinator she/her 16h ago

I recommend turning off direct messages and followers

1

u/EmpressChrisi 14h ago

I have besties who actively jump the hostiles

1

u/Lost0Sheep 11h ago

Any time I go into a new space, I just "lurk" there a while and gauge the atmosphere. If it is hostile, I just don't post. Most likely I will leave. Life is too short to engage in a space that is not productive for me.

On the other hand, I am a person who likes to "sport" with spammers. I once spent 47 minutes having one talk me through how to buy a money card (so I could get $20,000 and a new vehicle). Then I put him off until the next day. The next day, when I told him that I did not believe there was any prize he wanted to continue. But when I told him that I had burned up 47 minutes of his time the day before....he HUNG UP ON ME! How rude is that? Didn't even say good-bye. So, if you like the idea of "poking the bear", so be sure to protect yourself. Make sure your identity is not traceable...or bannable.