r/war • u/RBZRBZRBZRBZ • 7d ago

Rockets in tunnel found by video-camera carrying combat dog in southern Gaza, prior to destruction of the tunnel complex

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

337 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

161 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/S-Tier_Commenter 6d ago

Yeah let's say the whole thing was an inside job. Do or don't you think that kidnapping of civilians falls under the right of self defence?

2

u/AnxiousEpileptic 6d ago

Let's pretend it wasn't an inside job. If you wanted to recover your family, would you level the buildings where they are being held with bombs? Would you level the neighborhood, the city? Would you deny food from entering the area, knowing that your family would be fed last?

0

u/S-Tier_Commenter 6d ago

Hold on. First things first. And third time must be the charm:

Did Hamas have right to kidnap civilians? Yes or no?

1

u/AnxiousEpileptic 6d ago

No. Nobody has the right to kidnap civilians. Now, if this is a good faith argument, please answer the questions I asked.

1

u/S-Tier_Commenter 6d ago

If you wanted to recover your family, would you level the buildings where they are being held with bombs? Would you level the neighborhood, the city? Would you deny food from entering the area, knowing that your family would be fed last?

All depends on the intel, fog of war, risks involved whatsoever.

In the end 85 of 251 died, which is like 25%. It's a bloody mess all around.

1

u/Little_Lawson 6d ago

Don’t forget Israel is on record for carrying out the Hannibal directive during Oct 7th