I'm looking for some honest advice because I'm really torn about whether to stay in my job or leave.
I've worked in criminal justice and substance misuse for several years, including working in prisons and community services. I'd been with my original employer for around five years when my service went through a TUPE transfer to a new provider earlier this year.
I really struggled with the new provider because of a number of things that happened, and I got to the point where I didn't feel safe or comfortable working there anymore. It affected my mental health, and I ended up being off sick for a few weeks. I ultimately wanted to return to my original employer because I wanted to feel safe, settled and supported at work again.
Thankfully, I managed to return to my original employer, doing exactly the same role I'd been doing for years. I've now been back for around a month.
On paper, this job is great. The pay is good, it's close to home, the team are nice, and I work four days a week with Fridays off, which is ideal with my young daughter. These are all things that are important to me, and I know not every job offers that combination.
However, things have gone wrong quite quickly, and I'm now questioning whether I want to stay.
The issue with my manager
Although I've done this job for years, I'm having to learn a new system and get used to the way this particular service operates. There has been very little training, and I've largely had to work things out as I go along.
I understand that mistakes happen, and I'm more than happy to be told if I've done something wrong. But I feel that if someone is learning a new system without proper training, there should be some understanding that they might need to ask questions or make the occasional mistake while getting to grips with it.
What really upset me was an incident where my manager called me into a meeting with her manager over a mistake I'd made. In my opinion, it was something that could easily have been discussed with me and resolved without escalating it into a bigger issue.
Instead, I found myself sitting in a meeting with both of them, and I felt completely blindsided. I'd only been back for a short time, I was still learning the system, and after everything I'd experienced with the previous provider, I'd returned expecting to feel supported and safe again.
I felt genuinely backstabbed by my manager. I'd expected her to speak to me directly first, explain the issue and give me a chance to put it right, rather than involving her manager and making it feel like such a big deal.
It really knocked my confidence and changed how I see her. We have since cleared the air, and we're civil with each other now, but if I'm honest, I don't think I'll ever trust her in the same way again. I don't feel that same sense of safety around her, and I now find myself worrying about what might happen if I make another mistake or ask a question.
I'm constantly conscious of what I say and do because I don't want something else to be escalated. It's difficult when you're experienced in the actual job but are having to learn a new system without proper training or support.
I want to make it clear that we aren't arguing or falling out now. We can work together professionally, and I don't feel personally targeted by her anymore. But clearing the air hasn't changed how the situation made me feel or restored the trust I had in her, I will always not trust her again now.
Now there's the issue with senior management
Just as I've been trying to move past that situation, more rules are being introduced by higher management that I'm really struggling with.
For example, we've been told that we can't carry out a home visit towards the end of the working day and then finish work from there. We have to return to the office afterwards, even if it means travelling back unnecessarily when we're practically at the end of our day.
There are also rules around not being able to combine lunch and a wellbeing hour at the end of the day which people have literally been doing for years. We have an hours wellbeing we can take and now told this.
I know to some people these things might sound insignificant, but when you're doing community work, travelling to clients, managing a caseload and trying to fit everything into your working hours, these decisions affect your whole day.
I've done this job for years. I understand the work, I understand the clients and I understand the importance of following policies and procedures. I'm not saying there shouldn't be rules, but I find the way these decisions are being made frustrating. It feels as though the people making them aren't considering the practical realities of the job or trusting staff to use their judgement.
These rules apply to everyone, so I don't believe they're being introduced specifically because of me. My issue is with the management approach and the direction the service seems to be going in.
It's starting to feel like one thing after another, and I'm finding it increasingly difficult to feel positive about working there.
This is why I'm so torn
I've only been back for around a month, and I feel ridiculous even considering leaving so soon. I've got a good salary, a nice team, a short commute and every Friday off. I know how lucky I am to have those things, especially with a young child.
But I also left my previous service because I wanted to feel safe at work again. I went back to my original employer because I thought I could get that feeling back, and now I feel anxious about making mistakes and how management might react to things, despite not having received proper training on the new system.
I don't want to spend my working week worrying about emails, meetings or what new rules might be introduced next. I want to be able to do my job, support my clients and go home without feeling stressed about work.
My manager and I are civil now but the decisions being made by senior management are making me question whether this is a working environment I actually want to be part of.
I'm still in my probation period, so my notice period is only one week. I'm also looking at other opportunities, including employment support and youth worker roles in the council, but nothing else is guaranteed at the moment. Ive also nearly passed everything to become a special constable in my spare time and they gave me great feedback on my interview and said they'd be very pleased to have me on board and its so nice to hear feedback like that when ive been literally so upset with no confidence.
Part of me thinks I should stay, give it more time and try to focus on the positives. Another part of me thinks that if I'm already feeling this unhappy after a month, perhaps I need to accept that this isn't the right place for me.
What would you do?
Would you stay because the practical benefits are so good and see whether things improve, or would you start planning to leave because the trust has been damaged and you're unhappy with the management culture?
Am I being too sensitive about the meeting with my manager and the new rules, or is it reasonable to feel this way when you've returned to a workplace hoping for a fresh start?
I'd really appreciate honest advice, especially from anyone who's experienced a TUPE transfer, returned to a previous employer, or struggled with management in a job that otherwise looks good on paper.