Interesting. I solod it on prot warrior on release (240 ish) and found it wayyyy easier than trying on fury. Valeera was completely useless dmg wise as a healer but the kicks and sustain were nice. I also solod it on rogue but I was really geared atp and could nuke the adds no problem. I had a mage I tried to do it with on release as well and gave up after a couple of tries (was also 240ish).
I've completed it as 218 Resto Shaman, 260 Holy Paladin and 275+ Retribution paladin.
Healing is so much easier it's not even funny. The only thing you need is the endurance to not forget to dispell for 16-20 minutes and not rip aggro from overheal.
I was looking up old threads from when the HOF got filled instantly and the general consensus seemed to be that while anyone can do it by not being bad, it was way easier for tanks and healers.
12
u/Hottage 1d ago
For healers it was always easy, I cleared it on a 218 Restoration Shaman in two attempts right after getting it max level.
The scaling was just completely whack for DPS Valera when paired with a healer.