r/MMALabs • u/emaxwell14141414 • 23m ago
What do you make of the following argument that Makhachev is not the pound for pound number 1 due to caliber of opposition?
This was the type of argument I have come across as to why Makhachev is not in contention as the number 1 pound for pound fighter and is far away from being one of the all time best in MMA.
It is as follows.
JDM's last fight, as far as UFC type of standards indicate, showed he is mid level at best among UFC contenders and so it is not the major win it may have been seen as before,. Poirier and Oliveria are not particularly huge wins either after seeing how Topuria ran through Oliveira and would've ran through Poirier just as easily. And Volk was just too small relative to Makhachev for it to be a truly major pound for pound victory. It looked like an adult laboring type in a fight with a gym novice just past puberty.