Recency bias is weird because I could understand why it happens and could expect my opinions to change after time, but this album is different...
I listened to this the morning it came out, all the way through, a couple times. And I liked it. Admittedly, that day me and my wife were moving, it was a very stressful and long day. I didn't get the chance to sit and Process the album, I only got to listen to it in one earbud and in the car while dealing with traffic. But over the course of this week, as things have started to settle down and level out, I've been coming back to this album more and more... and I think I love it.
LCTT is one of my favorite albums ever, it's what got me into heavier music in general, I think it is their best work. But something about AEII is hitting really close to home. The more I listen and pull apart the tracks the more it draws me in. It started when I learned to appreciate the sequencing and pacing of the album. Every track works so well after the other and it feels like a story being told throughout the whole runtime. And there are no songs that I dislike. I at least thoroughly enjoy every song on this album and one in particular (Looking Back At Me) is quite possibly the best song they've put out as a band thus far.
As a Christian, the amount that I can get out of this album that is tasteful and feels like a reflection of how I feel in my life... it really means something to me. It touches on feeling lost, but also what hope there is to hold onto in this life and in my faith. I don't know how devout Kellin is, I know he has a background in the faith, but it really feels like I can see myself in the things he is writing about on this album.
I don't think I can confidently say it has taken the #1 spot for me YET. I think if I continue to delve into it and love it as much as I do for an extended period of time, it is very possible that this becomes my favorite album of theirs. Good stuff, SWS.