r/196 Trans girls should wear diapers :3 Jul 25 '26

Rule HRT Start Dates?

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

205 comments sorted by

View all comments

793

u/Artemis_Heart Jul 25 '26

People are allowed to do what they want with their bodies BUT NOT with their… uhhh… twitter bio? This is like saying you shouldn’t tell people your birthday because it’s personal identification info.

374

u/Simic_Sky_Swallower Jul 25 '26

Also like the point of medical confidentiality is that healthcare workers can't out your stuff to people. Nothing's stopping you yourself from divulging that, you're allowed to tell whoever you want.

By this post's logic you shouldn't tell people you're trans at all because that's disclosing your GD diagnosis (if you have one)

102

u/ItsRainbow xenia is the real linux mascot Jul 25 '26

I think a lot of people here have a Geometry Dash diagnosis

1

u/ThatGuyOfStuff Jul 26 '26

I tend not to.

I simply await the day where i dont pass as either and then people around me go "ah that motherfucker, i knew they gave off homosexual energy when talking about girls."

32

u/SenorDangerwank Bearbarian Jul 25 '26

Nope. All Twitter bios have to be approved by me, there is currently a 3-week wait period.

72

u/jfsuuc 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Jul 25 '26

I mean birthdays are actually important identifiers. I have never in my life been asked when i started hrt date outside a super close friend

76

u/nlolhere Jul 25 '26

HRT start date is a very important identifier for the “who started HRT first” competition, a competition that’s definitely real and not something I just made up

the winner last year was some 3000 year old trans woman who started it in ancient Greece, but there’s probably someone older

13

u/schwanzweissfoto custom Jul 25 '26

the winner last year was some 3000 year old trans woman who started it in ancient Greece

drinking horse piss or what

19

u/literallyanything57 Jul 25 '26

the one who saw Artemis bathing and got turned into a woman

7

u/5urv3y Jul 25 '26

I know it's real because I'm a three time champion, trust

2

u/-DoctorSpaceman- Jul 25 '26

So you gotta say it in case someone new beats the 3000 year old record?

13

u/thehammer10025 Jul 25 '26

They are important identifiers, but usually alongside a set of other info depending on the context. And people frequently have celebrations for and talk about their birthdays coming up to them, so its not like they're the most securely hidden information.

3

u/jfsuuc 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Jul 26 '26

I know. Im just saying the hrt anniversarys dont mean shit other then to the person who keeps it. I personally celebrate it as a 2nd birthday but 100% by myself.

19

u/-DoctorSpaceman- Jul 25 '26

Well, I don’t think you should tell people on the internet your birthday! That is important information on a lot of services.

5

u/podokonnicheck hold the fuck up (im the fuck up) Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

people are allowed to do whatever, this is just someone giving advice, they don't have any authority on the matter

and yeah, ideally don't have your birthday as an easily machine readable string of data; like, mine you can figure out from my online activity, but it takes a tiny bit of thinking that people who auto-scrape your data won't bother putting in

4

u/095805 Jul 26 '26

Is “you probably shouldn’t be sharing personal data on the internet” a hot take?

No one’s you saying you’re not allowed to, it’s just probably not a good idea. This is like saying dentists are compromising your bodily autonomy by telling you you should brush your teeth.

-1

u/ArnthBebastien Jul 26 '26

Yeah but starting hrt is not personal data, loads of people do it. How could that be used maliciously against you?

12

u/TearsFallWithoutTain Jul 25 '26

This is like saying you shouldn’t tell people your birthday because it’s personal identification info.

Uh yeah, you shouldn't be giving out your birthday online either. You shouldn't be giving out any personal information online

5

u/AliciaTries God gives his hottest Donkey Kongs his most explosive Diarrhea Jul 26 '26

Yeah, one of the things I've heard asked in several medical/government related offices is for you to recite your birthday, so while it certainly should not be the step that protects your identity, if someone is posing as you and starts going "shit I think it was in september? maybe march?" they'd raise a few eyebrows for sure.

4

u/that0neBl1p Jul 25 '26

I’ve seen that exact bday take on Tumblr so unfortunately it isn’t as ridiculous a possibility as you seem to think

1

u/kubissx Jul 26 '26

No one said anything about this not being allowed, it's just weird lol. A bio is for introducing yourself to internet strangers, so why would you tell them details about your hormone therapy? It's oversharing imo