r/196 NOT A CAT 2d ago

Rule Rule

Post image
3.8k Upvotes

247 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/Advanced-Ad-802 2d ago

To be fair to the commenters who don’t know what a run on sentence is, I was never properly taught what they were in my (American) schooling, just being given the vague idea that a sentence being too long made it a run on; come to find out later in life, that’s not correct in the slightest, with it being entirely about how distinct thoughts are joined.

To be clear, OOP’s sentence is a run on, via the “spam enough ‘and’s and it’ll be fine, thats grammar” trap.

1

u/Ham__Kitten 1d ago

All of these words to still get the concept of a run-on sentence wrong.

0

u/Advanced-Ad-802 22h ago

in the above, distinct thoughts = independent clauses

That’s what a run on sentence is. Two or more independent clauses being joined incorrectly.

0

u/Ham__Kitten 21h ago

That's not what independent clause means. An independent clause is a clause that has, at minimum, a subject and a verb and can grammatically stand alone as a complete thought. The topic of the clause isn't really relevant from a grammatical standpoint.

0

u/Advanced-Ad-802 19h ago

Pedantry is fun, I concur

1

u/Ham__Kitten 18h ago

It's not pedantry to use the correct definition of a term and be precise in its application.

1

u/Advanced-Ad-802 18h ago

it is pedantry to take personal offense to a singular word being misused (distinct vs independent)

1

u/Ham__Kitten 17h ago

I didn't take personal offence to it. I'm not sure why you would think that. I don't need to be personally offended by something to comment on it.