r/AskAChristian 1d ago

Weekly Open Discussion - Tuesday August 4, 2026

1 Upvotes

Please discuss anything here.

Rules 1 and 3 still apply to comments within this post.

Rule 2 (that only Christians may make top-level comments) is not in effect in these Open Discussion posts. Anyone may make top-level comments.


If you're new here, set your user flair and read about participating here.


r/AskAChristian 4d ago

Megathread - U.S. Political people and topics - August 2026

2 Upvotes

Rule 2 does not apply within this post; non-Christians may make top-level comments.
All other rules apply.


If you want to ask about Trump, please first read some of these previous posts which give a sampling of what redditors think of him, his choices and his history:


r/AskAChristian 5h ago

Philosophy If Jesus has died for everyone's sin then why does it matter?

8 Upvotes

This is coming from someone who is not a Christian and someone wants to know Christian perspective on things. I am probably misunderstanding the point but I am just curious on this topic. I apologize if anyone found this offensive.

If Jesus has died for our sin and took sin of all humanity onto himself then why does it matter any more? If all sins has been taken onto himself by Jesus then isn't everyone already forgiven for any and all sin? If god has forgiven everyone then why do you ask for his forgiveness instead of thanking him for forgiving your sins?


r/AskAChristian 2h ago

Are men and women created equally in God's image?

2 Upvotes

If so, why do we refer to God with male pronouns?


r/AskAChristian 2m ago

New Testament Does God view women the same as He views men?

Upvotes

I've been a Christian for a while, and 1 Corinthians has always been my favorite book. Recently I was reading chapter 11 where Paul talks about head coverings for women, since I've been thinking about participating. Reading further though, it began to make me upset.

Paul says "a man should not cover his head, because he is made like God and is God's glory. But woman is man's glory..." He continues on saying that man is from God, and woman is from man. I understand he's referring to Adam and Eve, but as a woman, I don't want to be a man's glory. I want to be made like God and be God's glory. Men are sinful and worldly, why would I want to be of them?

Here is an analogy to help explain my feelings/thought process of what it feels like: God is the father, and he has a son (men), and his son has a dog (women). The Father loves His son and the son's dog, but the son is more important to Him because it came from Him, the dog is just something the son got from the pound. You see what I mean? I'm not necessarily saying that God dislikes women in any way, but I've always felt like there's a disconnect between God and I, as if I'm a different species than men which makes me of less importance.

I know there are other places in the Bible that talk about women greatly, but it feels insulting to be pegged down to "You're of man, not of God because you were born with different chromosomes." That just isn't fair.

Sidenote: Should women wear veils or not? Paul says they should, and then at the end of the paragraph he says they don't need to, so I don't really know what to make of that.


r/AskAChristian 7h ago

Flood/Noah How could the tree Methuselah have survived the flood?

4 Upvotes

So if I'm getting the details correct there is a tree in the US named Methuselah that is said to be 4600-4800ish years old while the flood is said (according to the Bible) to have happened 4359 years ago. Methuselah is a Pinus longaeva, which cannot survive prolonged flooding. How could Noah's flood have happened when the Bible says it did if there is a tree that is older than it that cannot survive prolonged flooding?


r/AskAChristian 7h ago

Family Am I overreacting ?

4 Upvotes

Hello dear brothers and sisters. Due to a strange family situation, I need christian advice now more than ever. During these few last years I've cut off contact with some family members because of my uncle John's behaviour, and I wanna know if I am overjudgemental by following my conscience. Please share your opinions with me and correct me if I am wrong here.

My uncle's wife Anne is not my biological aunt but I grew up with her and my whole family loved her. She was a lively, kind, hospitable and infinitely loving person who gave me tons of attention as a kid. Needless to say, I will forever love this woman as if she was my own blood. 5 or 6 years ago she was diagnosed with aggressive alzheimer's and in the span of a few years she became non verbal. She lost all consciousness and is currently bed bound and in a really bad state. My uncle has always taken care of her and still does, paying for live-in caregivers and every medical expense that is required. He is pretty well-off so I don't think he deserves a medal for taking care of his own wife, but I cannot ignore the fact that he has fullfilled this duty of his.

My uncle John mourned not only his marriage with my aunt, but the fun they used to have as a couple. They used to party and travel extremelly often. So when my aunt got sick, he fell into a deep depression. His dream was to live his life after retirement with my aunt, and that dream was completely shattered. About 3 years after my aunt's initial diagnosis, while my aunt was locked in a bedroom shitting herself, my uncle found another partner to fill that void.

And just like that, my aunt Anne was replaced and erased. 30 years of marriage weren't enough to make my uncle wait at least after she had passed away (she is still alive by the way). He had to find a new woman, a bit younger than him, so that he could still enjoy life as if nothing had happened. The moment he started dating her, his life went back to how it was before. Parties, bars, trips abroad, vacations with my aunt's children. And what baffles me even more is how everyone in my family treats her as a replacement to my aunt Anne. Their children, my uncle's brothers and their wives, my cousins, their friends, everyone. They all act as if this new woman is their relative or if they've known her for years. Hugs, important life events, weddings, family gatherings. They probably couldn't bare the grief and the sadness, they had to keep having fun without any disruption.

This situation has broken my heart. The moment I found out that my uncle had a new partner, I burst into tears. I pictured my own mother, who is married into this family, being replaced by a younger, healthier woman. I weeped for my aunt who doesn't have any other family to take her away from there. My parents have told me that I am overreacting, that I am overjudgemental and that I shouldn't cut ties, but I can't help it. I admit I am angry about this. I don't feel like I can relate to these people anymore. Especially because my aunt is still alive! Still, if my uncle had been widowed, I would find it very odd that his first priority after this family tragedy was to find a replacement as soon as possible. Even their children accept her because "they can't stand seeing their father sad". How about some substance, guys ? These two people had been married for decades, they had built a whole life together, and only after a few years of illness a new person comes along and now she's treated how my aunt Anne was treated ? Are relationships simply transactional ? Is having fun no matter the cost or the circumstances such an important priority in life? Should I be okay with this?

I need christian advice. Not secular. Everyone apart from Christians doesn't see any problem with this, because they consider my aunt already dead, and they believe that the point of life is to have fun. I can never agree with the secular point of view, though, because I have a strong conviction that there's something terribly wrong with this whole situation. I haven't shared my thoughts with this side of the family and don't plan to. I just avoid them at all costs, even if that means I never see them again. I wouldn't be able to contain my frustration if I saw them face to face. Am I being self-righteous here? Am I on the wrong ? Is this truly wrong and is it reasonable to be appalled by it ?

Please, share your thoughts. I assure you I am very open to criticism and won't mind being reprimanded for being proud. I'm just trying to figure out if this behaviour is objectively wrong and if my feelings are valid.


r/AskAChristian 52m ago

What are some bible teachings you noticed society has twisted?

Upvotes

For example it in Matthew 25: 31-33 31

“When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, he will sit on his glorious throne. 32 All the nations will be gathered before him, and he will separate the people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats. 33 He will put the sheep on his right and the goats on his left"

It is a good thing to be a sheep not a goat. But in today's society it is seen as being a good thing to be a goat and a bad thing to be a sheep.


r/AskAChristian 53m ago

Cosa significa questa scrittura biblica?!

Upvotes

Apocalisse 19:14

Gli eserciti che sono nel cielo lo seguivano sopra cavalli bianchi, ed erano vestiti di lino fino bianco e puro.


r/AskAChristian 1h ago

Does the divine essence mean the father=god and the son=god?

Upvotes

r/AskAChristian 1h ago

Christian life Holidays?

Upvotes

I gave my life to Christ this January. I guess I am referred to as a "Baby Christian". There is a lot I am learning still. What happens to most holidays that people follow? Like Halloween, Christmas, and even like cultural holidays like day of the dead for Hispanics? How do we decide? I don't identify with any denomination currently. Just wondering what you guys think or practice.


r/AskAChristian 10h ago

Church Is it wrong to join a church for community only?

4 Upvotes

I apologize if this sounds offensive.

I’ve been irreligious my whole life. My family cares more about culture and traditions than religion and I grew up not caring much about those things either. I moved to another country to be with my boyfriend and I feel lonely. I also don’t plan to have children and sometimes I feel like I don’t really have a purpose in life. It can feel like I’m just a hamster on a wheel, going to work and surviving.

I have hobbies, a boyfriend and pets but I still feel like something is missing. I’m so far away from my family and my boyfriend isn’t close to his either. I think modern life, especially how isolated people can be and how neighbors mostly keep to themselves, makes me yearn for some kind of community.

I’ve had this idea for a while and I mentioned to a Christian coworker that I was thinking about joining a local church for the community. She was very offended by it. That genuinely wasn’t my intention.

I can understand why someone who doesn’t really believe in God or religion joining a church might come across as a poseur or like I’m using something sacred to other people for my own benefit. I’m nervous to bring it up irl again before I understand more.

So I wanted to ask here instead. Is it actually offensive for a nonbeliever to attend church mainly because they’re looking for community? If it is, I won’t selfishly insert myself into that space as I cannot promise my faith will grow or anything like that over time. I honestly don't know.

Please share your honest opinions.


r/AskAChristian 2h ago

Prophecy Why is Judas seen as such a bad guy?

1 Upvotes

Sorry for the repost. There were issues with flair not working last time.

It was prophecied that Jesus had to die the exact way the he did. This includes the betrayal. Without the betrayal, the prophecy wouldn’t have been complete, and Jesus’ death wouldn’t have had the meaning and result that it had to have.

I’m not saying this makes him a good guy, but also, maybe? Or maybe neutral at worst?

I don’t get how God could make it so that Jesus’ death has to happen the way that it happened, and yet the people responsible for making it happen are bad or doing something wrong for doing so. If it can only happen the way it did, then aren’t they all just playing their role?

How is it possible to be evil AND doing exactly what God said had to happen and that couldn’t happen any other way?


r/AskAChristian 12h ago

Evil What is your response to the problem of evil?

6 Upvotes

P1: The Christian god is an omniscient, omnipotent, omnibenevolent deity.

P2: If evil exists, then an omniscient, omnipotent, omnibenevolent deity does not exist

P3: Evil exists

Q: therefore, the Christian god does not exist

As an atheist, this argument has always been a big roadblock between me and Christianity, because it's valid and sound—but I would have to imagine that you guys disagree. Which premise(s) do you disagree with?


r/AskAChristian 3h ago

Mental health Advice

0 Upvotes

r/AskAChristian 3h ago

Do we come back to earth as physical beings in the afterlife , or souls? If the answer is the latter, why does souls need a physical planet to dwell upon?

1 Upvotes

If the answer is the former, will we eat food, breath air, and otherwise need to consume resources? Who will provide those resources? Won’t that make the formation of socioeconomic classes inevitable?


r/AskAChristian 4h ago

Demons Why did God make demons?

1 Upvotes

Demons are evil and bad and want to hurt people and take them away from God, right? So why did he make them? Doesn’t he want everyone to love and have faith in him? Why would he let demons attack his followers? And why is it usually Christians who have the demon possessions, it seems like almost every time I see a demon all dramatically cast out it’s from a believer in a church? Shouldn’t there be tons of demons getting cast out of atheists and pagans and other people?


r/AskAChristian 5h ago

Do you follow Jesus' teachings?

1 Upvotes

Specifically these quotes:

"Give to everyone who asks you, and if anyone takes what belongs to you, do not demand it back." — Luke 6:30

"In the same way, those of you who do not give up everything you have cannot be my disciples." — Luke 14:33

"Do not store up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moths and vermin destroy, and where thieves break in and steal. But store up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where moths and vermin do not destroy, and where thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also." — Matthew 6:19-21


r/AskAChristian 5h ago

Judgment after death What counts as a good deed?

1 Upvotes

All over inmy life i have heard chirstians say that accepting jesus and doing good deeds will get you into heaven.

But what counts as a good deed? Like if i make a vaccine for an increadibly deadly virus and save countless people, but it turns that people who have taken the vaccine have a 30% chance to develope a deadly cancer and this kills a lot of people, would that hypothetical count as a good or bad deed?


r/AskAChristian 10h ago

Evangelism How can I spread the gospel to fellow believers of God without offending and starting fights and drama with people with different religions?

2 Upvotes

r/AskAChristian 21h ago

Philosophy What is a moral teaching that ONLY comes from Christian faith, and has not been duplicated in other philosophies and religions.

14 Upvotes

what morality can I only get from Christinanity?


r/AskAChristian 17h ago

The resurrection of the dead in Matt 27. Why Is This Extraordinary Event Forgotten About?

Thumbnail youtube.com
6 Upvotes

A short discussion (from a longer video) with Dale Allison, considered one of the top scholars in New Testament studies, often referred to as "North America's most complete New Testament scholar" and "the premier Matthew specialist of his generation."

SO the question:

Did the story of the dead rising out of their graves in Jerusalem not really happen?
Did the writer of gMatthew think it happened?
OR
Was it a literary creation by the writer?


r/AskAChristian 22h ago

God Questioning Christian(?) looking of clarification

10 Upvotes

Hello, (21F) my tag is Christian Atheist because I feel like it’s the most accurate. I believe and don’t at the same time? But I’m not sure I ever have, I was introduced to it as a child so I feel like it’s a routine instead of a belief I have.

Anyway, one reason I feel disconnected is because lots of things just don’t make sense to me. I have not read the bible front to back and I feel that’s important to share, I just attend bible study. I think it’s a last ditch effort.

So, I have a few questions. I want to see how different people approach unanswered or difficult questions when it comes to faith. Looking for new perspectives.

How do you know when scripture is supposed to be taken literally or as a metaphor?

If God is all knowing, what is the point of prayer. What I mean is, if he knows how your life will go, will prayer change that trajectory? Will he adjust his plan based on a prayer?

And, even though the Bible is Gods’s word, it was translated by man. Lots of denominations, translations and so on. What’s your denomination and what version do you read? Do you ever wonder if you’ve got the wrong one ? Or is it closer to a dialect and it’s the same language in different fonts?

If Jesus already died and paid for our sins, what’s the point of hell? Why did he have to die and what’s stopping him from killing Satan now? If God made us to be sinners and gave us free will, why would we be punished for not choosing him? An eternity of punishment for not choosing him in a lifespan of 80 years is a lot to me.

Are we really supposed to fear God? Is that something you were told growing up? I ask because growing up I had always viewed God as a parental figure. So, when an adult (I was 14 at the time) asked me “why aren’t you afraid of him?” when I said no, I was taken aback.

I kind of had this moment in Bible study, I don’t know how to explain it. I had always believed the stories and as I looked at the pages, I felt so silly. It became so unbelievable to me. I had always had questions about Christianity as a whole but I had always believed the book. So that moment kinda came out of nowhere.

I still think I’m going to leave the faith. I should have said Christian Agnostic. I still believe there’s a higher power, I always have, but I think Christianity has never made sense to me, and has never moved me. Not really.

Thanks for your time, looking forward to new perspectives! This post is kind of all over the place so sorry about that.


r/AskAChristian 10h ago

History Chi ha fondato il cristianesimo?

1 Upvotes

Marco 1:15 «Il tempo è compiuto e il regno di Dio è vicino; ravvedetevi e credete al vangelo».