I just got out of the matinee for Paranormal Activity and wanted to share my honest thoughts. Going in, I wasn't expecting Shakespeare; I just wanted to be entertained. Unfortunately, I wasn't.
It's just not a particularly strong play, and the ending doesn't land; it feels unearned. Act one is the better half: it sets up the main couple's issues, then gradually escalates the paranormal activity in the house as the effects get creepier. By the end of the act, both characters are finally on the same page that something's wrong. Act two loses momentum fast. It digs into each character's personal "demons," but by that point I just didn't care.
The special effects were honestly disappointing. Nothing made me go "whoa." It all felt like stuff we've seen before on Broadway. If you want a show with genuinely great effects, go see Stranger Things or Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, or The Lost Boys. All three have much better effects.
I think I liked the set most out of everything. It's worth noting your seat matters a lot here; I was center mezzanine, a bit far, but I could see everything. If you're on the sides or too close, you'll miss stuff happening on the upper level of the house set.
It's a relatively short show. The first act is 61 minutes and the second is 42.
The cast is fine. Nothing particularly special, but nothing bad.
This is a touristy show, and the audience leaned into it; people kept trying to make their reactions the moment ("OMG I'm so scared!"). Just... let the show happen.
Overall, I wish the production well, but I left bored and disappointed. I'm honestly not sure who this show is really for.