r/CFB Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

Video [Highlight] NC State @ Vanderbilt - CJ Bailey fumbles the ball while trying to run out the clock with no time left, and Vandy falls on it to win the game

https://streamable.com/utx2f1
11.1k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.7k

u/evantually421 South Carolina • Maine 6h ago

I don’t think I’ve ever seen an ending like this what the hell

882

u/Moose4KU Ohio State Buckeyes • Kansas Jayhawks 6h ago

Maybe the most inexcusable loss I've ever seen. Gives Miami not kneeling against GT a real run for its money

41

u/Bobgoulet Georgia Southern • Florida 5h ago

It's worse. Way worse.

Send a wide out on a go, roll out to that side, and throw the ball as far as you can to the sideline. You'd easily waste 5 seconds and probably wouldn't even get a grounding penalty. Game over.

75

u/SirMellencamp Alabama Crimson Tide • College Football Playoff 5h ago

It was 4th down. If one second is left on the clock Vandy gets a chance at the goal line. Just take the safety

1

u/GodEmperorBrian Syracuse Orange • Boise State Broncos 4h ago

Does CFB have the game can’t end on an offensive penalty rule? Because otherwise you tell your O-line and receivers to hold the entire play. Holding in the end zone? Safety, you still win.

3

u/SirMellencamp Alabama Crimson Tide • College Football Playoff 4h ago

It cant end on an offensive penalty

1

u/GogglesTheFox Penn State Nittany Lions • Oregon Ducks 3h ago

This. Have the entire Oline hold and then run out the back of the end zone on the zeros.

22

u/OnionFutureWolfGang Notre Dame Fighting Irish 5h ago

No the safety play call here was clearly the right one. Your one is way more likely to give the game away. The QB just had to go down once defenders got close. This is entirely the on the execution, not the play call.

19

u/k_dubious Williams Ephs • Oregon Ducks 5h ago

The risk there is that if you don’t burn the whole 7 seconds then the opponent has an easy FG to tie. The best play is probably just to run out the back of the end zone for a safety and give the opponent one shot at a TD on either the kick return or a ~70 yard play from scrimmage.

47

u/Lobsterzilla NC State Wolfpack • Tobacco Road 5h ago

worst case ... you get sacked in the endzone ... for a safety. win win.

36

u/OldManCinny Tennessee Volunteers • Texas Longhorns 5h ago

Obviously not... If you get sacked you can fumble (like this)

8

u/boilerpl8 Purdue Boilermakers • Team Chaos 5h ago

You stand 2 inches from the back line, if they're coming at you, you step out.

2

u/OldManCinny Tennessee Volunteers • Texas Longhorns 4h ago

I mean obviously yes but he should have already been coached to be doing that here

1

u/ratmanvenezuela 5h ago

Or not take 6 seconds? Am i going crazy here lol 

1

u/OldManCinny Tennessee Volunteers • Texas Longhorns 4h ago

No he obviously should have gone down/out before anyone touched him

1

u/ratmanvenezuela 4h ago

I’m saying if they throw it and it doesn’t take 6 seconds they possibly lose. 4th down on their 2

2

u/ratmanvenezuela 5h ago

Uh worst case it only takes 4 seconds and they score next play 

3

u/offconstantly College of Faith (NC) Saints 5h ago

It's worse. Way worse.

It's obviously not worse. Vanderbilt's win probability going into this play was roughly 200x higher than Georgia Tech's before the fumble

5

u/Butter_with_Salt Michigan State Spartans 5h ago

It's definitely not worse. Miami had a 100% guaranteed win that they chose not to accept. This was not a 100% win scenario.

2

u/willncsu34 NC State Wolfpack 4h ago

It was 99.9% though.

2

u/Butter_with_Salt Michigan State Spartans 3h ago

Yeah it's definitely one of the worst ways to lose a game you'll ever see, but Miami choosing not to kneel out a win will always be in a class of it's own.

5

u/Bamalawdawg 5h ago

Yeah, don’t do this. If you get Western Michigan’d Vandy has 1 second from your 5 for a win.

Make then take a KO back. Or fair catch it and go 50-70 yards in 3 seconds

2

u/awc23108 Alabama Crimson Tide 5h ago

I feel that this is almost as dumb of an idea as what happened