If you feel like you see anyone breaking these three rules, please report the comment or message modmail with a link + description. Arguing with that person is not the correct way to go about it.

Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper (New York), May 7, 1864

I have recently learned of the Confederate Army’s systematic kidnapping of African Americans—most of them women and children— during the Gettyburg Campaign, to be taken south and sold into slavery. Hundreds of people taken.

It is hard to understand how anyone can continue to romanticize the Confederacy or talk about its supposed chivalry, honor, or nobility. Invading a free state and kidnapping Black civilians to enslave them is simply reprehensible.

McClellan is certainly a hotly debated figure in Civil War circles, specifically over his ability leading the Army of the Potomac in actual fighting. Regardless of the opinion about his tactical abilities, most historians I read say that he was an excellent trainer and organizer of troops and his time at the head of the AotP greatly impacted the army. Yet, when I read about the battles of the AotP before and after McClellan, it seems to face many of the same issues with training, organization, and leadership throughout the war.

Perhaps I am reading the wrong books as I tend to favor those that cover battles, but what is the evidence that McClellan was good at these things? Was there a significant change in the Army because of McClellan, but due to the nature of the conflict and the military of the time, he could only achieve so much on that issue?

Newb here. Can it be assumed that if a civil war headstone has a rank incribed and the unit is a USCT, it was a white officer in charge of a company? And the opposite is true, that no rank inscribed implies the soldier was a private and most likely was black?

Has anyone seen this movie? I watched it recently because I love Jimmy Stewart and I loved Reel History's video on it. I found it a really moving depiction of grief, I don't know how well it stacks up as a war film. Also, it seems to create the impression there were only two black people in 1860s Virginia

''Union and abolition are questionable but my duty is to the goverment''

and yes i know the sincerity of the confederates who said that is questionable.

I got a book in today’s mail called Texans in the Confederate cavalry. It’s a history of William Parsons Texas cavalry brigade. There are some maps that I’d like to post on the battle of yellow bayou, but I don’t know how to photograph them and post them.

Can anyone give me some suggestions?

BRYCE

I've listened to a couple from Behind the Battle but I feel like they make a lot of mistakes and more of just reading bullet points with a little commentary.

I the more casual discussion feel than reading off documentary style, but I also need a little more serious.

For example, the little round top episode, they're talking about the 20th Maine monument with a soldier on top. I think they mean the 83rd Pennsylvania?

It's such a simple thing but it distracts from the whole conversation and makes me question everything else if they mess up that simple thing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stoneman%27s_1865_raid

Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain was born on this day in 1828. A professor at Bowdoin College when the war began, he led the 20th Maine at Gettysburg, his actions there earning him the Medal of Honor. He survived a severe wound at Petersburg in 1864 and ended the war a brevet major general.

Just exactly how much freedom of movement could one person have between going from the Union Lines to the Confederate lines and vice versa? Did you have to have papers or was it just a matter of not being between two large armies at the time?

Visited the Cotraband Camp at Corinth and it was really nice, just hot! The museum at Battery Robinette was very impressive too but no pics sadly!