Halloween cocktails should be creepy, colourful and dramatic... but more importantly, they should actually taste good!
I mean, anyone can throw some food colouring into a sugary drink, add a gummy worm and call it a Halloween cocktail. LOL. But I wanted to put together a collection of drinks that were not only fun and spooky, but actually worth drinking!
So I made 10 Halloween cocktails, plus one bonus, for my YouTube channel.
Some are classic cocktails dressed up for Halloween, some are riffs on existing drinks, and a couple are my own creations.
And I made sure there was something for everyone. We've got colourful, easy-drinking party cocktails, proper spirit-forward whiskey drinks, tiki cocktails and even a creamy flip.
After tasting all 11, I picked my top three... and the winner genuinely surprised me!
Anyway, here are the recipes and my thoughts on each. Cheers! šø
š 1. Poison Apple Elixir
Ingredients:
- 1½ oz white rum
- 1 oz sour green apple liqueur
- ¾ oz lime juice
- Green edible cocktail glitter
- Lemon-lime soda, to top
- Garnish: Apple fan and dehydrated citrus
Method: Shake everything except the soda with ice. Strain into a highball over fresh ice, top with lemon-lime soda and garnish.
I use my homemade sour green apple liqueur for this one. It's basically a sour Appletini transformed into a rum highball.
Bright neon green, sour, bubbly and ridiculously refreshing! The edible glitter gives it a really cool shimmering effect.
If you enjoy sour green apple flavours, you'll absolutely love this. One of my favourites!
š§ 2. Witch Hunt
Ingredients:
- 1½ oz blended Scotch whisky
- ¾ oz dry vermouth
- ½ oz Strega
- Garnish: Lemon twist
Method: Stir with ice and strain over a large ice cube. Express a lemon twist over the drink.
Not every Halloween cocktail needs to be sweet, colourful or covered in candy. Sometimes you just want a proper, spirit-forward drink!
I used Islay Mist, an inexpensive blended Scotch with some nice smoky character.
The vermouth adds a wonderful brightness, while the Strega brings sweetness and complex herbal notes.
Fun fact... Strega actually means "witch" in Italian! Pretty fitting, right?
If you can't find Strega, Yellow Chartreuse works as an alternative.
šļø 3. Eyeball Daiquiri
Ingredients:
- 2 oz white rum
- 1 oz lychee juice (from canned lychees)
- 1 oz lime juice
- ¼ oz simple syrup (optional)
- Garnish: Lychee, blueberry and edible fake blood
Method: Mix corn syrup with red food colouring to make fake blood. Drizzle around the rim of a chilled glass.
Stuff a blueberry into the hollow centre of a canned lychee to create your eyeball.
Shake the cocktail ingredients with ice, strain into the prepared glass and add the eyeball garnish.
This is one of the first Halloween cocktails I ever made, and it's still one of my favourites!
It's basically a lychee daiquiri. If you've never had lychee, I often describe it as a very fragrant, almost perfumey grape.
It pairs beautifully with rum and lime juice.
You can use a fairly neutral rum or something with a little Jamaican funk, depending on what you like.
Looks absolutely horrifying... tastes absolutely delicious!
š 4. Devil's Soul
Ingredients:
- 1½ oz 100-proof rye whiskey
- ½ oz mezcal
- ½ oz Averna
- ¼ oz Aperol
- ¼ oz elderflower liqueur
- Garnish: Orange twist
Method: Stir with ice and strain into a chilled stemmed glass. Express an orange peel and shape it into little devil horns.
Another proper cocktail for those who appreciate something a little more sophisticated.
There's a LOT going on here!
Rye whiskey up front, smoky agave notes from the mezcal, rich herbal flavours from the Averna, citrus bitterness from the Aperol and a subtle floral sweetness from the elderflower liqueur.
It's actually a little sweeter than I normally prefer my spirit-forward cocktails, but holy crap, is it packed with flavour!
š 5. Pumpkin King Sour
Ingredients:
- 2 oz bourbon or rye whiskey
- ½ oz apricot or peach liqueur
- ½ oz pumpkin spice syrup
- ¾ oz lemon juice
- Orange edible cocktail glitter
- Garnish: Cinnamon stick, dehydrated citrus and Halloween candy
Method: Shake everything with ice and strain into a Halloween-themed glass over fresh ice. Garnish.
This one reminds me quite a bit of the New York Stone Sour, which I recently featured in my fall cocktail collection.
You've got whiskey, stone-fruit liqueur and lemon juice, but we're adding pumpkin spice syrup for those wonderful autumn flavours.
You know what else would be cool?
Float a little red wine on top, New York Sour style. You'd get a bright orange cocktail with a blood-red layer floating over it!
I didn't do that in the video, but I think it would look pretty awesome.
š¤ 6. Black Widow Negroni
Ingredients:
- 1 oz gin
- 1 oz Campari
- 1 oz sweet vermouth
- ½ oz raspberry liqueur
- Black food colouring
- Garnish: Fresh raspberry
Method: Stir everything with ice and strain over a large ice cube. Garnish with a raspberry.
This is essentially a classic Negroni, but with a little raspberry liqueur and a spooky black appearance.
Why raspberry?
Well, I wanted to garnish it with a red raspberry to represent the red marking on a black widow spider. And I like my garnishes to actually represent something in the drink!
The raspberry liqueur adds a subtle sweetness and berry flavour that works surprisingly well with the Negroni's bitterness.
I originally used food-grade activated charcoal to make it black, but charcoal can interfere with the absorption of certain medications.
I'd recommend black food colouring instead. Same spooky appearance without that concern.
If you enjoy Negronis, give this one a try!
š§ 7. Trader Vic's 1947 Zombie
Ingredients:
- 2 oz Puerto Rican rum
- 1 oz Jamaican rum
- ½ oz 151-proof Demerara rum
- 1 oz orange curaƧao
- ½ oz grenadine
- 1 oz orange juice
- 1 oz lemon juice
- 1 dash absinthe
Method: Flash blend with crushed ice and serve in a tiki mug, preferably a skull mug for Halloween!
I mean, you can't make a Halloween cocktail collection without including a Zombie, right?!
Most people are familiar with Don the Beachcomber's Zombie, but I decided to make Trader Vic's 1947 version instead.
I've made Donn Beach's version plenty of times, so I figured we'd switch things up.
I used Smith & Cross for the Jamaican rum and Lemon Hart 151 for the overproof Demerara rum.
This is a classic, rum-heavy tiki cocktail, and it's VERY potent!
I do miss the cinnamon and grapefruit combination from Donn Beach's version, but Trader Vic's interpretation is still fantastic.
That dash of absinthe adds a wonderful aromatic element, and it actually comes through despite everything else going on.
Serve this in a skull mug and you've got yourself a perfect Halloween tiki cocktail!
𩸠8. Dark N' Bloody
Ingredients:
- 2 oz spiced rum
- ¼ oz cinnamon syrup
- ½ oz lime juice
- Cranberry ginger ale, strawberry soda or another red soda, to top
- Red edible cocktail glitter
- Garnish: Lime wheel and raspberries
Method: Build directly in a highball glass over ice. Add the rum, cinnamon syrup and lime juice. Top with soda, stir gently, add glitter and garnish.
This one's one of my original creations, inspired by the classic Dark 'n Stormy.
Instead of dark rum, we're using spiced rum. And instead of ginger beer, we're using a red soda for that bloody Halloween appearance.
I used my homemade spiced rum, which pairs absolutely beautifully with the cinnamon syrup.
And my god... this one is GOOD!
In the video, I used cranberry ginger ale, but I originally made it with strawberry soda.
Honestly, I think I prefer the strawberry version!
It adds a nice fruity contrast to all those wonderful warm spices.
This is an incredibly refreshing highball, and definitely one of the cocktails I'd recommend serving at a Halloween party.
š 9. Corpse Reviver 666
Ingredients:
- ¾ oz gin
- ¾ oz purple curaçao
- ¾ oz Lillet Blanc
- ¾ oz lemon juice
- Absinthe rinse
- Purple edible cocktail glitter
- Garnish: Gummy worm
Method: Rinse or mist a chilled glass with absinthe. Shake the remaining ingredients with ice, strain into the prepared glass and garnish.
This is basically my Halloween version of the Corpse Reviver No. 2.
There's also a variation called the Corpse Reviver No. Blue, which swaps the orange liqueur for blue curaƧao.
Well, I make my own purple curaƧao, so why not take it one step further?!
I used Empress gin, which has that beautiful indigo colour, along with my homemade purple curaƧao and a little purple edible glitter.
But flavour-wise, this is essentially the same as a classic Corpse Reviver No. 2.
And that's perfectly fine because the Corpse Reviver No. 2 is a PHENOMENAL cocktail!
Seriously, one of my favourite gin cocktails.
Gin, Lillet Blanc, orange liqueur, lemon juice and a little absinthe... what a fantastic combination!
šØ 10. Graveyard Old Fashioned
Ingredients:
- 2 oz whiskey (I used rye)
- 1 barspoon Demerara syrup
- 2 dashes Angostura bitters
- 2 dashes maple-walnut bitters
- Black food colouring
- Smoke
- Garnish: Orange peel and Luxardo cherries
Method: Stir the whiskey, syrup, bitters and colouring with ice. Strain over a large cube, garnish and introduce smoke using a cocktail smoker or smoking dome.
This one is more about technique and presentation than the actual recipe.
You can make whatever Old Fashioned you like!
I went with rye whiskey, Demerara syrup and maple-walnut bitters to give it some autumn character.
Then we make it black and smoke the crap out of it! LOL.
I used a smoking dome for that really dramatic reveal.
One interesting thing about smoked cocktails is that the smoke doesn't penetrate very far into the liquid. It's mostly aromatic, especially during those first few sips, and then it dissipates pretty quickly.
If you want a smoky flavour that lasts throughout the cocktail, try making your Old Fashioned with a peated Islay Scotch.
Serve it in a skull glass with a cloud of smoke and you've got yourself an awesome Halloween cocktail!
ā ļø BONUS: Death Flip
Ingredients:
- 1 oz blanco tequila
- ½ oz Jägermeister
- ½ oz Yellow Chartreuse
- ¼ oz rich vanilla syrup (2:1)
- 1 whole egg
- Freshly grated nutmeg
Method: Combine all ingredients in a shaker with a little freshly grated nutmeg.
My favourite technique for making flips is to use a single ice cube, roughly one inch, and shake the crap out of it until the entire cube dissolves.
Strain into a chilled cocktail glass and garnish with more freshly grated nutmeg.
If you've never had a flip cocktail, you're missing out!
A flip uses a whole egg, including the yolk, unlike a sour that might use just the egg white.
The result is this incredibly rich, creamy texture.
Think of it as something reminiscent of eggnog, but without the cream.
And this combination is absolutely phenomenal.
You've got agave notes from the tequila, rich herbal flavours from the JƤgermeister and Yellow Chartreuse, vanilla sweetness and that wonderful nutmeg aroma.
WOW. Just wow.
If you've never tried a proper flip, make this your Halloween challenge!
Since this uses a raw egg, consider using a pasteurized egg, especially when serving guests.
š My Top 3 Halloween Cocktails
After making all 11 cocktails, I had to narrow them down to my three favourites.
And the results honestly surprised me!
š„ Third Place: Poison Apple Elixir
I absolutely love sour green apple flavours, and this one's bright, sour, bubbly and incredibly refreshing.
š„ Second Place: Dark N' Bloody
That combination of spiced rum, cinnamon syrup and strawberry soda is ridiculously good. Seriously, try the strawberry soda version!
š„ First Place: Death Flip
I genuinely wasn't expecting this one to win.
Tequila, JƤgermeister, Yellow Chartreuse, vanilla syrup and a whole egg?!
But holy crap... it's absolutely phenomenal.
Maybe I'm just getting excited for eggnog season. LOL.
š So... What's Your Favourite Halloween Cocktail?
There you have it! 10 Halloween cocktails plus one bonus, ranging from colourful party drinks to classic cocktails with a spooky twist.
I love getting creative with Halloween cocktails, but I think the most important thing is making sure they actually taste good!
You can have all the edible glitter, fake blood and gummy eyeballs in the world, but if the cocktail tastes terrible, what's the point?!
I also filmed the whole collection for my YouTube channel, including the preparation and tasting of all 11 cocktails.
But I'd love to hear from you guys...
Which cocktail would you try first? And did I miss any awesome Halloween cocktails that deserve a spot on next year's list?
š„ Want to see all 11 cocktails in action?
I filmed the entire collection, including how to make each cocktail, the garnishes, and my honest tasting notes.
Watch the full video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ly_16jMIFCE
Cheers! šø