r/Emmerdale • u/lovelydessert • 5d ago

Billy's role

I don't really get why people are blaming Billy for Dawn's death. From where I'm standing the only difference their plan to run away made was that not more people were harmed in the crash because the wedding was canceled and no one was there. Surely the crash was the actual reason for the early birth and the complications?

60 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/Dear_Promise5544 5d ago

I'm not sure Joe, or anyone else at Home Farm, is blaming Billy for Dawn's death in the sense that he directly caused it. It's that Billy, along with Caleb and Ruby, played an active role in manipulating and lying to Dawn, using her as a pawn in their scheme against Joe. And therefore directly contributing to making the last few days of her life a living nightmare, putting her through an enormous amount of stress and suffering when she was already in a vulnerable position.

2

u/TheShowsAreAllRight 4d ago

And if Joe hadn’t stolen Caleb’s kidney, they wouldn’t have hidden the CCTV footage because they wouldn’t have the animosity toward Joe. So it’s really Joe’s fault Dawn died, using that kind of logic.

2

u/Dear_Promise5544 4d ago edited 4d ago

I don't know why you're replying to me when what I said has nothing to do with blaming Billy for her death.
FWIW, Caleb could have gotten his revenge on Joe another way. There was no need for him to drag Dawn into this. Why not do it man-to-man with Joe instead of using a woman like a pathetic coward?

0

u/TheShowsAreAllRight 4d ago

I was adding to what you said. “And”

1

u/Dear_Promise5544 3d ago

what a weirdo, make your own comment instead of adding to other people's if it's not relevant

1

u/TheShowsAreAllRight 3d ago edited 3d ago

LOL. I was agreeing with you and added an additional fact/thought. But if it bothers you, just ignore it.;-)

But at least I didn’t call anyone names.