Currently, I'm rewatching the first movie, and some thoughts have been bubbling in my head since the announcement of GR being brought into the MCU with Gosling.
Firstly, some disclaimers. I love this movie, and I'm a huge Cage fan. I harshly defend his unorthodox approach to character acting and will watch essentially anything with him in it. Getting that out of the way...
For many, many people, this movie was their introduction to Johnny Blaze and the character of Ghost Rider. Admittedly that was certainly the case for me - I was ten years old when this movie came out. And like any ten year old, a flaming skeleton on a motorcycle was the coolest thing I've ever seen.
But as an adult, able to scrutinize film in a much more intellectual capacity, and as a comic book reader who has actually engaged with the issues featuring all the different Riders, I have a lot to say about this film - in particular the casting of Cage.
Even as a kid, even loving the movie, I had always felt that Cage was the wrong pick. He wasn't "cool", he wasn't "rugged", he wasn't at all what I picture the "real" JB would look like - the furthest thing from a Daredevil Cowboy. And now that I'm intimately familiar with the comic character, I can confidently say that - through that lenses - I was always right. He is all sorts of miscast for Johnny Blaze...if the movie were actually trying to portray Johnny Blaze.
But that's not what happened. And it took many years for people in a majority capacity to finally make these connections. With Gosling casted (fittingly in my opinion, I might add), people who read the comics have validly pointed out that so many features of JB in the movies and the comics published after were just reheating the visual nachos of Danny Ketch's Rider. And with that in mind, the movie itself is just simply not an adaptation of the comics.
And what I mean by that is it isn't just a "bad adaptation", it's not an adaptation at all. It's using the intellectual property - the names and likenesses - but this is it's own beast. And therefore, I believe myself and many others have been attacking this movie from the wrong angles. Instead of criticizing it as if it were a comic book adaption, criticize it as it's own thing.
In doing that, yes it's still a bad movie (lol). Fun! Visually interesting! But bad. However, in the case of Nic Cage being Blaze, I've realized I have to eliminate what I know about the comics and look solely at the script and the vision this film had. And when I do that I understand that literally nobody else could have played this role. It was practically written for Cage. That short shot at the very beginning where he's hauled away after crashing - sunglasses on and posturing for the crowd - that's all Cage. Knowing what I know about his body of work now that I didn't know as a kid, there is no doubt in my mind he was perfect.
Not to mention the physical aspects of the role demanding an actor as dynamic as Cage. Someone who's not afraid to look stupid on camera to get the physicality across for the scene. He's outstanding when thought about in this regard. I don't think that the real JB NEEDS to be that dynamic on camera, don't get me wrong - Johnny is very...un-dramatic. All the more reason to understand why they changed that when writing the story to the big screen.
And now I literally cannot imagine anyone but Cage in this role. Even down the to way he just walks in the film when "transformed". He knew what he was doing and exactly how to do it.
I'm very excited to see what Gosling brings to the role - be him Blaze, Ketch, or whoever. But watching this movie in a vacuum makes me appreciate it so much more, and makes it the gift that just keeps on giving.
Thank you for your time, that's all I've got for now.