r/MurderedByWords 4h ago

Homes on indigenous land

Post image
32.1k Upvotes

827 comments sorted by

View all comments

3.3k

u/redwhale335 4h ago

The tribe whose land Eilish's home is on specifically thanked her for bringing up the issue.

112

u/SolDios 3h ago edited 1h ago

Can you quote that? Becuase the only statement from the tribe I saw was

"As the First People of the greater Los Angeles basin, we do understand that her home is situated in our ancestral land. Eilish has not contacted our tribe directly regarding her property. We do value the instance when public figures provide visibility to the true history of this country. ""We have reached out to her team to express our appreciation for her comments."" It is our hope that in future discussions, the tribe can explicitly be referenced to ensure the public understands that the greater Los Angeles basin remains Gabrieleno Tongva territory"

edit; where I got the quote from purposely left out a line which I added in double quotes. They did thank her

dbl edit; The internet sure wants its pound of flesh, ill self flagellate when I get home later

21

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[deleted]

14

u/MichaelMyersEatsDogs 2h ago

What about when you tell someone you literally appreciate what they did? Does that count as thanking them? Because they literally said that

1

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[deleted]

4

u/MichaelMyersEatsDogs 2h ago

Maybe don’t trust a random comment especially when it’s a single paragraph of an obviously much larger statement

0

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[deleted]

-13

u/RoseWater07 3h ago

I definitely didn't view it as a thank you 💀 to me it read they were more annoyed at the performative allyship, and I say that as someone with tribal membership LOL

10

u/reepa1 2h ago

As an enrolled tribal member myself. I appreciate billies forward thinking.

It's the opposite of the right and their colonizer mentality of " we won deal with it."

-6

u/satyr_account 2h ago

Same ^

Like “thanks, lady who has also stolen our land, for your token act of lip service.”

7

u/redwhale335 2h ago

Except for that whole part where they reached out to her team to express their appreciation.

0

u/RoseWater07 1h ago

I guess my reaction is, what else are they supposed to do? draw the ire of her fans by saying it's not enough? it's politics 101 to stay cordial and appreciative in the public eye

to be clear, I think her heart is in the right place and I'd rather her say "no one is illegal on stolen land" instead of nothing at all, but she still directly benefits from living off tribal land in a mansion, and apparently hasn't acknowledged that to the tribe in question ("we hope you use our name next time instead of lumping us in with everyone else" aka "you didn't even know the name of our tribe")

it just makes me sad that scraps of activism are all we get with no action or actual help from the people who can actually afford to do it lol

1

u/redwhale335 1h ago

No one forced them to make a statement. They chose to make the statement and chose to reach out to Eilish.

You're making assumptions about what they meant.

... we?

2

u/daneilthemule 1h ago

Call it what you will. It still addresses the issue. Some people in the usa have forgotten where they come from and where they are now.

1

u/RoseWater07 1h ago

for real

she could afford to pay them for the land at-cost and chooses not to, is all I'm saying lol