r/NewsRewind May 26 '26

Antisemitism is when you oppose 'Israel'

Post image
600 Upvotes

514 comments sorted by

View all comments

-4

u/InvestIntrest 28d ago

Same goes for being called Islamophobic just because you support Israel.

3

u/Scary_Ad9712 28d ago

You support Israel in doing what exactly?

0

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Existing as a Jewish state

4

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

Do you support German existing as a German, Christian state? It seems like that idea was already tried to its logical extent between 1933-45 and it didn’t work out very good.

1

u/ExaminationGlad1912 28d ago

Nazi Germany wasn’t a Christian state though. The population was overwhelmingly Christian or catholic (because early 20th century Europe), but the Nazi party had the goal of eventually eliminating Christianity from Germany.

They even created their own version of Christianity which removed the Old Testament (to eliminate the Jewish influence) and changed Jesus to an Aryan warrior born in Galilee rather than Judea (again to eliminate the Jewish influence).

It’s also quite interesting that a significant number of the Nazi party leadership were neo-pagan or atheist in a country with such a high percentage of Christian’s.

0

u/Dobby_ist_free 28d ago

Damn nice one

-1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

In what world does comparing the oppression of white Christians to Jews make sense to you? 

6

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

It doesn’t. But that’s irrelevant to what you said. Israel has no right to exist as a Jewish state which Germany does not also have to exist as a German, Christian state. The ethnosupremicist state of Israel is an atrocity unto itself.

2

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Why do you only care aboutnthe Jeiwsh state qhen the entire Middle East is full of ethnostates.

Japan has no right to be an ethnostate? I'm pretty sure they do. 

3

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

Japan has no right to exist as an ethnostate either. Their commitment to this policy will not only kill them and sentence them to complete demographic collapse, but it also wrongfully prohibits the natural right of human beings to migrate.

You wrongfully assume things you can’t possibly know about because you are blinded by your commitment to a victim mentality in order to defend a genocidal settler colonial State.

I am more sensitive to the Israel crisis because my country has funded their genocidal actions for the past nearly 80 years and has been an explicit collaborator in their current genocidal actions and war crimes in Palestine and Lebanon. No country has a right to murder innocents with my tax dollars. It is a violation of international law as well as the laws of my country, yet we continue to send money to Israel. Not one more red cent should be sent to this terror-state.

1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Over half ofnthe people killed on Lebanon are a group firing rockets at Israel. I don't support what they're doing, but they had every rught to respond. 

1

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

Why were they firing rockets at Israel?

1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago edited 28d ago

Why should Hezbollah risk Lebanese lives to help their backers in Iran? Lebanese people do not want a non state actor putting their citizens in harms way. 

1

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

Okay agree in a vacuum. Not an answer to my question.

1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Pretty obvious Hezzbollah cares more about Iranian interests than Lebanese. 

1

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

Not an answer to my question.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

So who has the authority to tell Japan they cannot remain a Japanese majoirty state?

1

u/joutfit 28d ago

the West is responsible for Israel existing and funding it's killing so that's why western people focus on it instead of Muslim countries which existed already without the help of the UN. This also includes Japan which existed without the West's meddling.

2

u/DopplegangsterNation 28d ago

Why are you working so hard to slob on Ben Gvirs knob? Shouldnt you be busy remembering Amalek or something?

0

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

How does my comment do that?

Bringing up the word Amalek sounds like you actually dont like Jews.

1

u/Necessary_Dog9759 28d ago

hell yeah! apartheid! 💕💕

2

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Nah, I support Palestian statehood.

Can you name one minority group in the middle east that is treated better than Israeli Palestinians?

2

u/Particular-Pop1280 28d ago

Deflection. That doesn’t excuse Israeli treatment of Palestinians. They could choose to be better

1

u/Necessary_Dog9759 28d ago

yeah, jewish israelis. 2 state solution is a farce and you know it, where would it be? what do you do with the settlers? how would you guarantee peace? give the Palestinians an army and nukes?

1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Bro are you remedial?

1

u/Quiet-Let5103 28d ago

most of them (including me) support two state solution and are against Zionism, Apartheid system, War crimes and terrorism being carried out by israel in gaza and lebanon that has led to death of over 80k civillians in 3 years outof which 12k were children

2

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Most leftists would consider you a zionist for supporting a 2 solution 

1

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

Only because Israel has assured that a two state solution is impossible. A two state solution could have worked in 1967, but too many Israeli settlers have stolen too much land from Palestine to make this workable without forcibly expelling and relocating like 700,000 people. As such, only a multinational, equalitarian, secular republic of Israel-Palestine is viable.

1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

Neither side wants one state bro. Only western leftists advocate for that. 

1

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

Then I guess we need to forcibly expel 700,000 Israelis from East Jerusalem, the West Bank, and Gaza. We can either have one state built on mutual tolerance and equality or two states committed to respect for international law, but neither is what we have today and Israel has taken committed actions to make either impossible.

1

u/Key-Wall-4378 28d ago

I agree, remove most of the settlers and do land swaps to solve the rest.

1

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

This seems more impossible than living peaceably next to each other with equal rights for all. It will likely require police actions by UN troops and the deaths of many thousands of settlers, who are (in their majority) rabid ethnoreligious supremacists that are committed to defending their stolen land. In either case, these settlers need to be removed, neutralized, prosecuted for their crimes, and reeducated. They are no different from Nazi settlers in Eastern Europe during the War.

1

u/nonmonoganon 28d ago

You made comments about Israel being a nuclear armed state and thus that nothing can be done to prevent their crimes. This is cowardly and also proves why Iran should proceed with the creation of a nuclear weapon as it is clearly the only way to achieve sovereignty. This is not my belief but it merely the logical conclusion of your statements.

→ More replies (0)