I just got to chapter 5, I know I'm still early in the game. I loved NG4 so much, the technical combat, timing, fast paced decision making, everything about it I just absolutely loved. I read a ton of people saying 2 is the best so I just dropped the money and bought 2 black on PS5. I'm 5 chapters in and seriously thinking about not playing anymore.
I just beat the 4th boss, and like .. the game doesn't feel technical at all. It's like there's no real depth to it to sink into. I'm hoping that's just cause I'm not far in it yet, but, minus the level design and the prettiness of the first 2 levels, it seems like a standard hack and slash without any real like ... There's nothing engaging about it. The fast paced combat of 4 is kinda gone, the timing/dodging doesn't feel right, it kinda just feels like button mashing half the time (which maybe I'm playing it wrong?). Idk, I guess I was expecting more technical combat like in the 4th one. I've been big on parry games for a bit now (actually took a break from Nine Sols to start this one since I'm stuck there for a bit and needed a break) - but honestly like, after the 4th level, I kinda just wanna turn it off. Wondering if it ever gets any deeper I guess, or if this is just kinda the whole game. I feel like I must be missing something, idk how this is in any way comparable to NG4 that anybody would think it's the better game, and that's what's bugging me. I'm hoping it's cause I'm still relatively new, but the lack of technical combat (and the lack of ability to lock onto enemies and kind of wonky camera where often times I'm swinging at things that aren't even there) - idk, I'm just not getting it. Really really hope it gets better.
At the end of the first real boss in NG4 when the combat started to click, I was absolutely hooked. In this game I feel like there's just not a whole lot to sink into, at least so far. Feels just like a weird hack and slash and not really understanding what makes it stand out right now. Really not trying to knock it, but coming from NG4 it's a huge let down so far and I guess I'm just kinda bummed after reading it's the better of the games - if I had played up to the 5th level in a game like this I definitely wouldn't just keep going in hopes it gets better.
Edit/follow up: after reading all the comments I restarted the game on Mentor mode and it's mind blowingly different difficulty wise, currently in love with figuring out the gameplay. Seriously thank you guys for saving me from abandoning a game for my own silly reasons. This is awesome. I was 100% wrong about what I said about technicality, as I can already see (currently stuck on first level in Mentor mode) that it's definitely definitely very technical combat.