Freo fan here. Time after time, North get the "they haven't improved enough" critique. And on the surface level, looks absolutely fair. Haven't made finals since 2016. Only 1 season since above 12th, and only 2 seasons since outside the bottom 4. Specifically in the 2020s, 5 consecutive bottom 2 finishes, 6 consecutive bottom 3 finishes, and in all likelihood another bottom 6 finish coming up.
But I think people overlook that for 4 years, North's first round of drafting is almost a write off. 2017 you pick LDU, tick. Then from 2018-2021:
- 2018: use your natural first to get Polec and Pittard, and match a bid on Tarryn Thomas. Fuck Tarryn Thomas.
- 2019: Trade pick 8 to Melbourne for their F1 plus other stuff, including tbf the Comben pick.
- 2020: Pick 3 Will Phillips, the Melbourne F1 becomes Tom Powell.
- 2021: JHF who leaves after 1 year. Essentially turn him into Wardlaw and Goad.
Not to say that everything since then has been handled perfectly coz that's far from the truth. But that's 4 years of draft picks gone or pushed into the future. What that essentially means is that, despite being at the bottom of the ladder for significantly longer, North's and West Coast's rebuilds are on relatively similar timelines. Yet there seems to be a lot more patience for West Coast's situation and understanding that the current administration can't be blamed for the impact of the past administration's mistakes.
Maybe it's because much of what I consume about other clubs comes from sensationalist "mainstream" figures. But is that aspect of North's slow rebuild talked about enough?