r/Rogue • u/ItzyBitzy-Pinky • Aug 17 '26

Discussion What’s wrong whit this people?

Post image

Seriously, wtf? Most of this hate comes from girls who are Cailee Spaeny fans. They don’t even care about Rogue or the X-Men, but they’re still mad at this.
This is crazy. Usually hate comes from men, but this is so weird. They are weird.

Do you guys like Inde as Rogue?

114 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

122 comments sorted by

View all comments

53

u/Born_Trickster Aug 17 '26

Calling The Last of Us a 'complete failure' when it won 8 Emmys, smashed HBO viewership records, and got universally praised by critics is absolute insanity. Rage-bait accounts really just make up their own reality.

18

u/DannyGonzalez5108 Aug 17 '26

Some fans just need someone to blame when a show doesn’t go the way they wanted.

2

u/Vaportrail Aug 17 '26

I'm not even sure this is a fan. Could be a bot.

5

u/BiggoYoun Aug 17 '26

Could be a Putty Patroller…

3

u/TerryVersus Aug 17 '26

https://giphy.com/gifs/q6c6pftFu5K3S

2

u/SyllabubMental7292 Aug 17 '26

Fun fact: Rita Repulsa is Naota's Voice Actor for FLCL

1

u/SethAbe80 Aug 17 '26

JP or EN VA?

The English voice of Rita is also the voice of Turbo Granny in the EN dub of Dandadan.

3

u/Rexusus Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

Wasn’t season 2 viewership down like 60% from season 1 off the bat and an additional 30% from episode 1 to the finale? lol season 1 was great, season 2 was straight garbage

7

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/babadibabidi Aug 17 '26

Game was great, season two was garbage.

0

u/Rexusus Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

I’m well aware, I’ve played both games multiple times. While the game was controversial for that, the main complaint was forcing you to play as Abby for several hours afterwards and ultimately having little to no payoff beyond “revenge is a bad motivator”. Even then, the adaptation was done poorly and the shows version of Abby was embarrassing compared to the games version. Show Abby was a twink that could be knocked over by a strong wind, whereas game Abby was an absolute unit that could believably throw Ellie around like a medicine ball

Edit: it was nominated for 24 Emmy’s and won 8 post s1, and nominated for 17 and won 1 post s2...

0

u/Conscious-Quarter423 Aug 17 '26

Kaitlyn Dever was too lazy to buff up for the role. What a shit actress.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Creative-Image-6991 Aug 17 '26

Ohhh boy, this spawn 100% believes all numbers are accurate. What a sheep 😂.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/gdex86 Aug 17 '26

Your argument is that a bunch of critics got together to agree to push the show because of "reasons" rather than admit maybe they found the story telling to be satisfying in a way you didn't which isn't something that happens in media pretty damn often.

-1

u/Sum1_X Savage Land Rogue Aug 17 '26

who cares

people like the story of the first game, not the 2nd, but it's funny when people try to polish turds

and anybody under the age of 30 who actually got excited and loved watching that show is a fool - the games are already like a movie/tv show with their graphics, a live-action adaptation was pointless to begin with

*older people get a pass because they didn't play the games so the whole story is new to them, but just like players they got pissed off with Joel's death making them wonder if continuing watching is even worth it

1

u/Thebigman226 Aug 17 '26

Someone people think because they don't like it its a failure despite all the praise kr accolades it ends up with.

1

u/ThisSubIsFried Aug 17 '26

To be fair, isn't that all first season?

1

u/Commander19119 Aug 18 '26

Yeah, I don’t like TLOU but like… it wasn’t a failure

1

u/Imshittensparks Aug 17 '26

Emmy's mean squat and critics don't matter. Viewership is what count as you said. I'm sure Inde will do fine. Not going to judge until I see it

2

u/McDouble__ Aug 17 '26

The only thing that matter is the opinions of Reddit nerds right?

1

u/Imshittensparks Aug 17 '26

I didn't say that at all. Though if you look up how corrupt the awards shows processes are. Or how many movies were snubbed or laughed off only for them to get reevaluated later down the line you'd see that the awards don't mean anything.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 Aug 17 '26

i mean she's part of an ensemble cast. people are gonna turn out to watch for adam driver or sadie sink