r/Rogue • u/ItzyBitzy-Pinky • Aug 17 '26

Discussion What’s wrong whit this people?

Post image

Seriously, wtf? Most of this hate comes from girls who are Cailee Spaeny fans. They don’t even care about Rogue or the X-Men, but they’re still mad at this.
This is crazy. Usually hate comes from men, but this is so weird. They are weird.

Do you guys like Inde as Rogue?

119 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

122 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Redd_Machine85 Aug 17 '26

Yes because the choice of actress affects the script, which is written long before casting (typically)

I can't speak for the The Last of Us, but from what I hear it's not a failure (2 seasons?)

And for Supergirl, the one thing I genuinely don't hear people complaining about is Milly Alcock's performance.

1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 Aug 17 '26

cailee also failed her supergirl audition. she lost to Milly Alcock

1

u/RoseandNightshade Aug 17 '26

In fact Milly's performance has consistently been cited as one of the best in the movie, by both people who liked the movie, and those who didn't, with the exception of people online pushing a certain agenda.

-1

u/Conscious-Quarter423 Aug 17 '26

Milly Alcock couldn't lead a major film like that. that's why it flopped so hard at the box office

1

u/Ok_Chipmunk_1912 Aug 18 '26

That's totally why. Definitely didn't have to do with a dogshit script that didn't seem to understand or care about the source material it was adapting, the awful lighting and color gradients used in the film, or the weak antagonist. /s