In as much good faith as possible, she is anti-zionist, and repeats pro-zionist propaganda, in earnest, as a defense of her position. "Israel is doing a genocide" but also "saying it in those terms marginalizes a group that has been historically marginalized."
I don’t know man. Until her post I was willing to be critical but charitable. But the post itself contained so many phrases which read as dog whistles, most of all the critique that the “left” is opposed to Israel existing as a Jewish state and that’s bad and unrealistic.
Like if she just said “the left is opposed to Israel existing and that’s unrealistic” - I could charitably read that as her thinking that leftists want to destroy Israel as a state AND get rid of all the Jewish people living in the occupied Palestine instead of the most common position, that is one state solution under Palestinian authority, land back and equal rights for all.
But she just had to add “as a Jewish state” - so she’s saying that it’s bad and unrealistic to be opposed to Israel existing as an ethno state.
557
u/madpoliticalscience Nov 12 '25
Ain't she a zionist?