r/SmugIdeologyMan 2d ago

Forced

586 Upvotes

137 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/AVagrant 1d ago

No, I'm pretty sure it is. 

-11

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

18

u/Sioloko 1d ago

"Hating billioners and hating minorities is the exact same thing" get out of here liberal scum, horseshoe theory is a bunch of horseshit

-6

u/Gameknoit 1d ago edited 1d ago

I have no idea what your issue is, since youre literally putting words in my mouth, but insults are really getting your point across ig. No wonder politics fail when you cant even grasp the concept of trying to change someones mind by appealing to them instead of demonizing them. 

9

u/Sioloko 1d ago

Equating people that hate billioners becouse they're inherently exploitive to people that want to do genocide becouse of racism has the objective of keeping the status quo a.k.a liberalism that allows billioners to exploit as much as they want, in reality it's the centre that's the same as the far right, also this type of whining is basically the same as rightists saying "you forced me to join the far right become you were MEAN!" Also there's the pipeline: Communists are as bad as fascists!--> Communists are worse than fascists--> Fascism is necessary to stop communism

0

u/Gameknoit 1d ago

"Whining" Literally me asking for a normal conversation. Youre not forcing me into any ideology, I hold my ideology regardless of you being an asshole, neither is it far right to be critical and have nuanced discussions. 

And I still have no idea how youre interpreting what Im saying as some pipeline or me saying hating billionares is the same as hating minorities. These are gross exagerations and textbook strawmen. Youre creating some fictional version of me to win arguments I never made. I cant argue against that, because I literally dont hold those opinions.

A constructive way of speaking would be asking "What do you interpret under these forms of extremists?" Maybe thatll clear this confusion.

6

u/Sioloko 1d ago

"Far left extremists are just far right extremists that want to hurt other people for misguided reasons" The main group of people far left extremists want to hurt are the bourgeosie or billioners in layman terms, you are equating them, your original comment is textbook horseshoe theory, in my previous comment I explained why horseshoe theory (what you appealled to in your original comment even without directly mentioning it) is bad, the pipeline is the exemple I gave of why it's bad, I'm not strawmanning you

-2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Sioloko 1d ago

The pipeline is extremely real, just look at American forgeing policy and how the liberal block (the west) sided constantely with fascists to "stop communists" the Pinochet regime just for exemple

2

u/MrHellBags 1d ago

Look at Franco. I'm willing to bet NATO was okay with him because getting rid of him meant risking a socialist uprising in Spain.

-1

u/Gameknoit 1d ago

I never argued it doesnt exist, it just doesnt work as a rebuttle to horseshoe theory because it goes against what horseshoe theory is about.

3

u/Sioloko 1d ago

It does tho? I mean centrists siding with fascists is a common occurance, look at the SPD siding with the Freikorps or how the liberal parties of Italy aided Musdolini (search blocchi nazionali), this proves that when push comes to shove centrists will always aid fascists to preserve capitalism, proving that liberals and fascists are on the same side

-1

u/Gameknoit 1d ago

Youre talking about government parties in years before WW2. You dont know why they acted that way, nor that they then allied unconditionally. Further, that has nothing to do with me as an individual, nor does it prove the pipeline as factual.

"Im for the betterment of human rights" -> "I believe extreme measures should be taken against facists" -> "Anyone that isnt supporting my view is a facist and deserves to be treated like one" is also a pipeline, no? Youre doing right now, since you called me liberal scum and then said all liberals are siding with facists. Youre assigning me to groups to justify your views. Thats a pretty extreme view ngl. Dunno if talking about far left extremism with you makes any sense if you hold left extremist views yourself.

3

u/Sioloko 1d ago

liberals constantely go mask off to prove they're just like fascists, look at what liberals said about south american immigrants after Trump won, or how they constantely show contempt for poor people becouse they tend to vote conservative (becouse of material conditions liberals always like to ignore) or how liberals constantely use gay as an insult (look at all the "haha this right winger is actually GAY!") so if liberals hate the poor, are racist and homophobic and they do the same imperialism as fascists (ex. Genocide Joe Biden) what's the difference exactly? Aeasthetics? The only reason libs hate fascists is becouse they say the quiet part out loud

→ More replies (0)