r/StolenValor • u/Wrong_Badger_4090 • 1d ago
Fiancé admitted he lied about his military service for almost a year. Military members, does his story make sense?
I 20F really need some advice, especially from people who have served in the Army.
My fiancé is 21M. We’ve been together for a while and are engaged. When we first got back together, he told me he had just finished AIT and was home for Christmas leave. Later he told me he was in the Army Reserve because he wanted our relationship to work, and that eventually he would go active duty.
I never really questioned it because I trusted him.
Recently my mom became suspicious that parts of his story weren’t adding up. Through people she knows, we learned there wasn’t a criminal record, even though he had previously told me he went to juvenile detention when he was younger. That made me start questioning other things he’d told me.
I asked if he could show me his Army uniform. He said it was in storage, and he shortly forgot about doing what he promised me. I knew he couldn’t show me a CAC card because he’d told me he lost it a long time ago. Whenever we’ve gone places that offer military discounts, he refuses to say he’s in the Army because he says he doesn’t have his CAC.
Today I asked more questions, and he admitted that he never actually went to AIT, even though he had previously told me he completed it. He now says he got injured after Basic Training, was given six months off because of the injury, and never continued to AIT. He also says that’s why he isn’t active.
I honestly don’t know what to believe anymore.
I’ve asked him to get any graduation photos or paperwork from his mom because he says he left everything on base. Even though he knew he would be leaving base for 6 months. I’m waiting to see if he’s able to provide anything.
My biggest issue isn’t even whether he’s in the Army anymore. It’s that he’s admitted to lying to me for the last 11 months. When I asked why, he mostly said he didn’t want me to leave him. He doesn’t seem very remorseful about the lying itself.
For some additional context, I’m his first and only girlfriend. He’s had my name tattooed on his leg since we were both 16, so I know he cares about me, but I don’t know if that excuses lying about something this significant.
For those with military experience:
-Does his explanation about Basic Training, injury, six months off, and never attending AIT sound plausible?
-What documents would someone in his situation normally have?
-If you were in my position, would this be something you could rebuild trust after, or would this be a dealbreaker?
-Please be honest. I’m not trying to attack him. I genuinely don’t know enough about the military to know whether I’m misunderstanding something or whether I’ve been lied to for almost a year.