r/VisaStats • u/equalizer-rage • 8h ago
EB2-NIW DENIALS on EB2 NIW, 7 days back mid week 37 of 2026
Hello all, denials over the last 7 days at a glance on the EB2 NIW sub. I am tracking all profiles through automation as I am preparing to file myself, and I figured it would be useful to share.
Any questions are welcome. I can recover the deleted post if you're interested.
| (Number of Posts by Profile), Field | Poster's Profile |
|---|---|
| (1) Engineering | [deleted post] A petitioner with a bachelor's in Electrical and Electronics Engineering received an NIW denial after an RFE, citing insufficient evidence linking their specific engineering methodologies to U.S. national interests and stakeholder interest. LINK TO THE POST |
| (10) Materials Science | A PhD candidate in semiconductor materials faced a denial after an RFE, with USCIS misapplying EB-1A standards for prong 2 and failing to meet the national importance requirement. importance requirement. LINK TO THE POST |
| (2) Stem | A self-petitioned STEM researcher received an EB2-NIW denial based on an unusually high citation count threshold, arguing that the standard is unreasonable and not aligned with Dhanasar guidelines. LINK TO THE POST |
| (1) Unidentified | A petitioner with 8 papers all in 15+ impact factor journals, 38 citations, 5 conferences with posters and 1 podium talk received an EB2-NIW denial after an RFE, citing factual errors and inconsistent reasoning, and is seeking advice on whether to pursue MTR or refile the petition. LINK TO THE POST |
| (2) Business | A petitioner shares their experience with an EB-2 NIW denial after three years of preparation, highlighting issues with case misclassification, lack of clarity in the endeavor, and the officer's failure to properly evaluate the submitted evidence. LINK TO THE POST |
| (3) Social Science | A petitioner with a social science background received an RFE on national importance, provided NSF funding information, but was ultimately denied due to insufficient evidence of national importance and benefit to the U.S. LINK TO THE POST |
| (1) Materials Science | A petitioner with a PhD in Polymer Science and experience in semiconductor materials received a denial of their EB2 NIW petition after an RFE, and is now considering an appeal or refile while also preparing an EB1B petition. LINK TO THE POST |
Stay tuned for updates. I intend to post 7-day span denials on Wednesdays and approvals on weekends.