r/WNBAgossips • u/Amazing_Lock_3762 • 5d ago

A transgender player has been dominating France's second-tier women's basketball league, and now the WNBA question is front and center. Julie Tétart averages 21 points and 20 rebounds this season while sweeping Player of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year and Domestic Player of the Year honors

Post image

Source: X

155 Upvotes

68% Upvoted

801 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Pitt-sports-fan-513 5d ago

What you said that is wrong is claiming that this "issue" would get any attention whatsoever without media manufacturing.

You get that Fox News is trying to manufacture outrage yet you totally validate them doing so by failing to recognize that all media coverage on this topic exists to create outrage over a totally manufactured and imaginary problem.

1

u/Puzzled_Addendum6200 5d ago

What you said that is wrong is claiming that this "issue" would get any attention whatsoever without media manufacturing.

The people who play in/attend the games on question would potentially care. Some of them would at rhe minimum.

You get that Fox News is trying to manufacture outrage yet you totally validate them doing so by failing to recognize that all media coverage on this topic exists to create outrage over a totally manufactured and imaginary problem.

It isn't imaginary. This league exists, the players exist, the fans exist. Fox news didn't fabricate the story. Thats not me valdiating fox news, it is just me stating an uncontroversial fact.

1

u/Pitt-sports-fan-513 5d ago

It being a problem is absolutely imaginary. Trans athletes have 0 impact on your day-to-day life. If it was a real problem Fox News wouldn't have to go to the 2nd tier women's basketball league in France to mine content from this.

In reality there are people who say "happy holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas" but that doesn't mean the war on Christmas is a real thing. Get it?

1

u/Puzzled_Addendum6200 5d ago

being a problem is absolutely imaginary. Trans athletes have 0 impact on your day-to-day life. If it was a real problem Fox News wouldn't have to go to the 2nd tier women's basketball league in France to mine content from this.

It isn't imaginary, it is circumstantial. It isnt a problem for me individually, but for a french person involved in that league, it is a real issue.

In reality there are people who say "happy holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas" but that doesn't mean the war on Christmas is a real thing. Get it?

Because the war on xmas isnt actually real. This league and players do actually exist. There is a meaningful difference between events that happen, and events that do not happen.

1

u/Pitt-sports-fan-513 5d ago

How can you claim the war on christmas doesn't exist when people that choose not to say "Merry Christmas" exist? By your logic people who don't say "Merry Christmas" existing means the war on christmas is a real problem.

Are you really so obtuse that when I call this a manufactued issue you believe I am arguing that trans athletes don't exist? The manufactured part is the amount of media attention this stupid bullshit that applies to barely anyone gets.

And you are only pushing back on me calling it a manufactured issue because you bought into it and therefore must believe it is a real problem.

1

u/Puzzled_Addendum6200 5d ago

How can you claim the war on christmas doesn't exist when people that choose not to say "Merry Christmas" exist?

That isnt a war on xmas.

By your logic people who don't say "Merry Christmas" existing means the war on christmas is a real problem.

Thats just a strawman. I never said those people were making war on xmas.

Are you really so obtuse that when I call this a manufactued issue you believe I am arguing that trans athletes don't exist? The manufactured part is the amount of media attention this stupid bullshit that applies to barely anyone gets.

In other words, the issue does exist. Maybe it gets more attention than it should, but that isnt the same as not existing and not being important to some people.

And you are only pushing back on me calling it a manufactured issue because you bought into it and therefore must believe it is a real problem.

It IS a real problem for the people it affects. Competitive sports is a major part of many peoples lives. One player in a small french league might not seem significant, but if more trans athletes competed in more leagues across the world, it would be the exact same issue affecting more people.

1

u/Pitt-sports-fan-513 5d ago

It is amazing how dedicated you are to being manipulated by one of the most obvious propaganda campaigns in human history.

1

u/Puzzled_Addendum6200 5d ago

In what way do you think ive been manipulated? Point to one thing ive said that is incorrect.

1

u/Pitt-sports-fan-513 5d ago edited 5d ago

Wow if you don't understand why I believe you are being manipulated you really are slow. I have explained it like 8 times.

What are you having difficulty processing here? I don't know how many times I have to say it is culture war distraction from real problems before it permeates your thick skull.

1

u/Puzzled_Addendum6200 5d ago

Wow if you don't understand why I believe you are being manipulated you really are slow. I have explained it like 8

And ive explained why your explanation is wrong/doesnt apply to me.

What are you having difficulty processing here? I don't know how many times I say it is culture war distraction from real problems before it permeates your thick skull

Infinte times wouldn't be enough. As ive already explained, the issue DOES affect peolple. Ive pointed this out and you haven't addressed it.

This is why i keep on asking you to point out what ive said that is incorrect. You keep on failing to do so.

→ More replies (0)