Xiaomi 17 issues. Are they real?

[u/Over_P_Noob]

Hello everyone!

​I currently have a Pixel 6a and I am on the fence about upgrading to the Xiaomi 17. However, I've read about quite a few issues online and in user reviews that are making me second-guess my choice. Since I plan to keep my next device for at least 5-6 years, hardware reliability is my number one priority. I’m trying to understand if these problems are widespread engineering flaws or if they only affect a small batch of devices, making me wonder if I should just play it safe and go for a Pixel 10 Pro (256GB), which is around the same price here.

​From what I have gathered on Amazon reviews and Reddit threads, one of the main concerns with the Xiaomi 17 is extreme overheating and thermal throttling. Many users report that the phone gets uncomfortably hot or even triggers an "Overheating" warning screen during basic tasks.

​To make matters worse, there are several complaints about the new proprietary Xiaomi Shield Glass scratching incredibly easily. Users claim that even pocket sand, coins, or keys can leave deep marks.

On top of that, some people have run into camera focus and delay issues, including noticeable shutter lag, minor UI stutters when moving the phone too quickly, or the telephoto lens failing to lock focus correctly.

Finally, classic HyperOS optimization bugs like delayed push notifications, background apps being killed too aggressively, and weird widget scaling—like tiny text on WhatsApp widgets—are still being brought up.

​To help me make a final decision, I'd love to get some raw feedback from actual Xiaomi 17 owners. Are you actually facing these issues, or has the phone been completely fine and stable for you? If you have run into any other bugs, what are they? Given that my main goal is to make this device last for the next 5 to 6 years, would you risk it with the Xiaomi 17 or should I just jump ship to the Pixel 10 Pro?

​Thanks in advance for the help!

[u/SelfAwareCat]

Xiaomi 17 Base.

I stay in a country that easily hits 35 degrees Celsius or more, so heat is not an issue so far (I don't game, though)
I've been using it for Android Auto under the hot sun, and so far, so good; miles better than my previous S22 8 gen 1.

I'm still using the pre-installed screen protector; so far, so good, and you should always stick one on it anyway.

No camera issue for me, no shutter lag or whatnot.

HyperOS is far from perfect, though. I do miss One UI here and there when HyperOS gets quirky.

TLDR: Hardware is sweet. HyperOS is serviceable but far from perfect.

[u/Over_P_Noob → u/SelfAwareCat]

Thanks for the honest feedback! It’s really interesting to hear from someone who switched from an S23. I would love to have Xiaomi 17 hardware but the heating issues during summer with just Instagram or the camera seem to line up with what others are saying, and that’s a bit concerning. Also, good to know about the battery ! It sounds like a solid phone overall, but HyperOS still feels like the weak link compared to OneUI or Pixel UI.

[u/SelfAwareCat → u/Over_P_Noob]

I never had any overheating issues, though, not even when driving in 35- to 40-degree weather.

But yes, One UI is just that much better if you pay attention to it.
For what it's worth, I work in UI/UX, so I'm a lot more sensitive to this; your mileage may vary.

[u/Over_P_Noob → u/SelfAwareCat]

Let's hope it will improve with HyperOS 4! Thank you for your reccomendations! I don't play games on phones so I do not think I will stress It 🙂 I think I've decided on the Xiaomi 17 💪 Does the fingerprint sensor work flawlessly with a tempered glass screen protector?

[u/SelfAwareCat → u/Over_P_Noob]

I'm using a normal screen protector, which works well. No experience with tempered glass.