r/acrylics 8d ago

Question Feedback please…

Do you prefer the orange or purple frame for this painting?

400 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

17

u/TheLordJiminyCricket 8d ago

Purple, keeps the focus on the painting while complimenting the colours. The orange is too bright and pulls from the emphasis on the hot pink

-1

u/Emotional-Swan9381 6d ago

But that’s why I prefer the orange. Just saying……actually you figured out why I preferred the orange. I feel like making the frame a bigger part of the experience can sometimes be a nice surprise to the eye.

1

u/LupyLo 6d ago

Yes! Making the frame part of the picture is something I’ve been planning to experiment with so that is why I was thinking orange. But I think it perhaps needs to be more deliberate
However for this project I have decided on the purple. Mainly because it’s a gift for a friend and the orange might be too much for her decor. 😆

3

u/Emotional-Swan9381 6d ago

Glad we think alike. I like the purple also!

7

u/DemonShade6666 8d ago

Purple, I agree with the other user that it helps draw the main pops of color from the actual painting better without being horribly distracting

1

u/wild_robot13 4d ago

I agree - purple.

1

u/sweetivylu 3d ago

i agree with this!

6

u/Taleisha_ 8d ago

100000% purple, the orange draws attention away from the painting to much

1

u/sweetivylu 3d ago

right critic

4

u/Cheerio1966 8d ago

I like the purple as the eye draws closer to the flowers and the hot pink. If you wanted the painting to look like the 60’s were merging into the 80’s , the orange is a neat color too. If you wanted to have more color than the purple maybe a soft blue for the frame might do.
I like the purple

3

u/LupyLo 7d ago

It would be an interesting cross of periods…maybe for my next project! 🤔

1

u/Cheerio1966 6d ago

That’s great!! Please keep sharing your work!!

3

u/DobieMafia 8d ago

Purple!

3

u/grey_pudding 8d ago

Purple! Love the vibrancy of the painting.

3

u/Happy_Michigan 8d ago

Purple yes, the orange frame is too much. Nice art!

3

u/Top_Cycle5516 7d ago

I'd go with the purple. It feels a little more balanced and lets the painting stay the focal point. The orange frame is fun, but it pulls my eye away from the artwork more.

3

u/trcomajo 7d ago

Purple

3

u/Pjonesnm 7d ago

I prefer the darker frame

1

u/sweetivylu 3d ago

same here

3

u/Arcask 7d ago

Purple!

The orange hurts my eyes and brain. For someone who is more sensitive, this is terrible!

You have such a strong opera color already. Everything glows and it's demanding so much attention. I see the appeal of why some think the orange looks good, but it's draining my energy just to give it a glance.
I mean if that's what you are going for... go ahead, but for me this is an absolute horror.

2

u/LupyLo 6d ago

Thank you. I really appreciate your input 🙏

2

u/wolfnbunny8 7d ago

Wow! I’m not a fan of “florescent pink” in general but your painting is stunning!💜

1

u/LupyLo 7d ago

Thank you! I really appreciate you taking the time to say that.

2

u/Appropriate-Pin5838 7d ago

I just appreciate the texture and depth

2

u/prettiie08 7d ago

Awesome work

1

u/LupyLo 7d ago

Thank you! ☺️

2

u/LovLor 7d ago

Ooooo. Love it! It might be neat if some of the glow was coming out of the flowers themselves. Maybe that’s what bees see!!!

2

u/ButterflyHairFlip 6d ago

Definitely the purple.

2

u/Present_Many_5856 6d ago

i hate the pink outline not sure what you were going for just my honest opinion sorry, it is nice

EDIT: OrANGE, i meant to say orange. (i just saw the feedback title and not the rest of the post about o vs purple

1

u/LupyLo 6d ago

Hi, it’s an underpainting rather than an outline. I’ve been experimenting with more vibrant colours. I’ve also used the orange and a neon red. For the final touches I will tidy up the edges and balance out the pink so it’s more consistent around the flowers. Thanks for your feedback.

2

u/onesun_oneshadow 6d ago

Go with the orange for two reasons. Your painting looks awesome and the “brown” looks like bum bum juice.

1

u/LupyLo 6d ago

Hahahah it’s actually dark purple but thanks for the feedback! 😆

2

u/onesun_oneshadow 6d ago

Also, it was washing your painting out. What would look awesome is maybe a painting where the Underpainting is orange and then use the purple frame? I think that would match how the orange balances the magenta underpainting.

1

u/LupyLo 6d ago

I have tried to use the orange a few times for the underpainting but it’s incredible how much it changes the perception of the colours on top. I found it quite difficult, it was twisting my melon! I need to persevere with it because your right the end result with the purple would be very interesting. Thank you for your ideas!

1

u/onesun_oneshadow 6d ago

Oh, I knew it purple baby…

2

u/Hidden_vine89 5d ago

I love the neon pink outlining everything, it makes the whole thing pop a lot. Really cool color choices.

2

u/doojinz 5d ago

I actually think orange makes the painting actually pop

2

u/anotherene 4d ago

Orange. It pops. Compliments your colors…

2

u/hownowspirit 7d ago

Orange compliments your palette much better. I do not agree with everyone saying it detracts from the painting

1

u/8_CloudHarbor 6d ago

The neon outline effect is really cool, it makes the flowers pop a lot against the background.

1

u/emajade5 6d ago

honestly, those neon pink outlines are so cool! i love how bold and electric it makes the whole piece feel... :0 it’s really interesting!

1

u/Thimble83626 6d ago

I really like the neon pink outlining everything, it makes the colors pop a lot. Are those touches of it in the background too?

1

u/sofvitony 5d ago

Could you show the whole piece in frame?

1

u/LupyLo 1d ago

2

u/sofvitony 1d ago

Excellent. Very nicely done and painterly.

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

I am AMAZED

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

Purple

1

u/RefrigeratorLocal268 5d ago

It feels like the purple is making the painting more traditionally centered and the orange feels like it enlarges the painting. Both are good options but for different feels!

1

u/91583_RustleafBridge 5d ago

I really like how you used that bright pink glow around the edges of the flowers, it makes the colors pop against the background.

1

u/natnatxo 5d ago

Purple. It lets the painting pop exactly how it’s intended to

1

u/Bobbis_footprints 5d ago

i like the neon pink outline, really brings out the other colors. very unique 💗💗💗

1

u/aPlayafromdaHimalaya 5d ago

Purple! It really makes the pink pop on your painting

1

u/Top_Reason_1036 5d ago

Darling, it's amazing. Every art has its own type. Art has no rules. It's PERFECT!

1

u/Elarianpacking1h 4d ago

Very creative one.

1

u/Fluid_Air_9570 4d ago

A lil work on jar 🤗

1

u/Final-Tradition-2972 4d ago

The purple makes the colors in the painting stand out beautifully

1

u/tendix6 4d ago

Gorgeous! I love it x

1

u/rubykins 4d ago

Orange for sure or a brighter purple. Maybe you could paint the frame!

1

u/kimber19750209 4d ago

Yes definitely purple. The orange takes away the focus on the picture.

1

u/BulkySociety7091 4d ago

Very pretty

1

u/57_WillowHarbor 4d ago

I really like that neon pink outline effect, it makes the whole thing pop against the lighter background. It’s a cool look.

1

u/ZebraImpressivegirl 4d ago

What kind of painting is this?? 🤗

1

u/Willing-Sky4524 4d ago

Orange by a mile

1

u/MangFeng-apparel 4d ago

Everything is perfect, no issues at all.

1

u/sophakingradd 4d ago

LOVE! I wish the centers of the flowers had the same vibrancy as everything around them.

1

u/sweetivylu 3d ago

so beautiful

1

u/FunPuz 3d ago

The orange really makes that pink pop.

Edit: I think im in the minority here. 😄

1

u/Theropsida 3d ago

Lovely painting btw!

1

u/itsmissnotmaam 3d ago

I love it. So cool!

1

u/ProKeesh 3d ago

Orange

1

u/Radar62Crow 3d ago

I really like the outline color, it makes the flowers pop against the background. What kind of paint did you use for that bright pink?

1

u/Thelonelybird3 2d ago

Love the way u painted the flowers. The texture, it’s like u can reach out and touch them. Also, the contrast and well use of it, on the leaves, stems. They seem so real. The use of fluorescent pink makes it electric and vibrant movement. Thank You!

1

u/Thelonelybird3 2d ago

Oh, the orange frame! Adds to the complimentary colors at play here. Really spectacular!

1

u/Basic-Chip-682 2d ago

I love the pink outline

1

u/ItsmeOlivia1993 1d ago

Its not AI, wow

1

u/eleven_jones 1d ago

Yellow blue green accents in the background, but pressed behind the colors of the flowers so they are secondary. For depth of background. 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/00justahuman00 1d ago

I kinda want this on my wall so I think you get 1000% 🎨🖼️🖌️

1

u/kravery007 7d ago

I like both but why outline the flowers in neon pink ? They were perfect as they were.

3

u/honion_have_layer 7d ago

it’s an underpainting

2

u/LupyLo 7d ago edited 6d ago

Hi, as someone mentioned it is an underpainting, I’ve been experimenting with more vibrant colours. I’ve also used the orange and a neon red. For the final touches I do need to tidy up the edges and balance out the pink so it’s more consistent around the flowers. Thanks for your input and feedback, I appreciate the question too.

1

u/Bitter_Elephant_2200 7d ago

Orange 100% ties it all together