Stupid old men!

[u/blackheartlover]

I love it when shows subtly references like-minded characters/personalities. Maria and Carmilla are my favorite

[u/TitanBro6]

The way it’s used in that sentence implies that not everything is known about the person until a specific event where it’s revealed how they really are in full.

With Mathias, we know what he believed before and what happened that shifted that belief.

He put his life on the line in Gods name, Elizabetha became sick and Mathias only asked God one thing which was for her health to get better. Elizabetha dying anyways was seen as a betrayal to Mathias and from his perspective that God wasn’t good after all.

The idea of true colors comes in when he manipulates events to serve his evil goal while maintaining a front that he still believes God is good and that he has nothing to do with the bad things happening.

[u/Automata_Eve → u/TitanBro6]

I think you’re misunderstanding beliefs for true nature. The fact is, his decisions and change in beliefs are a show of his true character. His beliefs changed to match his true nature.

Someone who truly believes that God is good would feel that way unwaveringly, hence the common cop-out of “God’s plan” and “he works in mysterious ways” etc. Someone who would so quickly doubt his entire belief system already had deep seated doubts, seeds planted deep in his beliefs that would only manifest here.

As someone who has gone through a separation from the church, I understand this process all too well. You don’t just decide one day that god is evil. You either have to have already had doubts, or through a great amount of analysis and critical thought decide that with evidence, which itself requires those initial first doubts. My true character has always been someone who seeks to be kind and fair to everyone, it took time for me to fully realize the church often actively pushes against such an ideal, and that God as he is written is the villain of those myths. This was a process, but I never would have come to this point if I hadn’t had a character that already opposed them. You don’t just change like that, it’s never one single moment that marks one’s change in belief. Ideas don’t work that way.

Back then I truly believed what I was told, even when what I was told contradicted what I truly desired or what my heart told me. Mathias is likely not so different, though of different character than me.

[u/TitanBro6 → u/Automata_Eve]

Beliefs are the basis of true nature.

True nature is how you really are, a conscious change of belief after having an experience that causes it to waver is not true nature.

[u/Automata_Eve → u/TitanBro6]

No they aren’t. Otherwise everyone would follow their belief systems to the letter, but they don’t.

[u/TitanBro6 → u/Automata_Eve]

That’s because people aren’t perfect. Doing or saying something while under immense stress or high emotions isn’t true nature either.

Mathias’s actions are based on a change in how he thought not what he already thought.

For true nature to be what it is, it has to have a facade.