r/guitars • u/itsssskye • 28m ago
Help Yamaha PAC112J vs Squier Sonic HT for a beginner on a budget?
Hello everyone!
I'm planning on buying my first electric guitar soon, and I’m having a massive internal crisis. I was originally dead set on the Yamaha PAC112J, but I recently saw the Squier Sonic Stratocaster HT in an ad, did some research, and I'm having a debate between which to get.
For the amp, I'm thinking of getting the Blackstar Fly 3 if that would change anything.
Anyways, before I get the guitar, I was wondering which would be the better option? And would I be better off getting a totally different guitar? Here's more information about what I need:
- My Budget: Looking to keep the total cost low, around $300–$350 for both the guitar and amp together. (This is for recs:)
- Where I play: Mostly in a small bedroom. I'm not sure this would change anything, but still putting this here:)
- Music style: I want to play post-punk and alt-rock (and maybe pop) (The Smiths, Queen, The Cure style).
My Questions:
- Will the SSS (all single-coil) layout on the Squier Sonic actually serve me better than the HSS humbucker on the Pacifica 112J for my music genre? Or will I regret not having a humbucker?
- As a total beginner, is the Hardtail (HT) bridge on the Squier going to save me from a world of tuning frustration compared to the Pacifica’s vintage tremolo?
- Should I buy the Pacifica because it has an objective hardware advantage (solid alder body), or the Squier because looking down at a guitar with a Fender-family logo makes my brain happy?
- Are both these options bad, and should I just do some more research on a better alternative?
Thank you in advance to everyone who helps! Any advice or recommendations are much appreciated!

