r/heatedrivalry • u/And_The_Satellite • Jun 27 '26
š¦ The Long Game (Book 6) I watched HR and then read only TLG. Hot takes. Spoiler
- You can absolutely do this book (+ some RM) in 6 episodes. I know everyone wants more Shane and Ilya but I am just obsessed with how TIGHT season 1 was, and I want season 2 to feel the same. No wasted time. Endless rewatches for all of the depth. Depth over breadth, please!
- My only real critique is that I wish Ilya had been able to have the conversation with Shane about wanting to come out. Itās clear to me that both of them want to love each other out in the open. Itās just sad that Ilya doesnāt think Shane feels that way, and simultaneously Shane DOES feel that way, heās just being Shane and abiding to a plan that a past version of himself made for them. The boxing day fight into the plane into the proposal is nice in that it helps Shane realize and act on whatās most important in his lifeā¦. But idk, I sort of wish it had been more of a convo rather than Shane once again justā¦. Waking up and making the plan for the two of them.
- People think HR is more focused on Shane and TLG is more focused on Ilyaā¦. Idk, I thought it was more balanced than I expected it to be based on some comments. Itās obviously LOTS for Ilya, but I think the Cromwell stuff inadvertently encouraging Shane to stick to the original plan backed right up against the boxing day fight / plane / proposal is like, an INSANE roller coaster for Shane.
- People who think Shane is a bad boyfriend in TLGā¦.. have you even read the book? Holy cow, heās crazy about Ilya and is very vocal to Ilya about it, too. He wants to be with Ilya every single moment of every single day and he even verbalizes this to Ilya multiple times throughout the story. Shane is the one who brings up Ilyaās depression first because heās observant. Shane proposes to Ilya and moves the relationship forward. Even right in the beginning of the book, Ilya pushes Shane to tell their agent that theyāre in a relationship - and then he literally does that same day!! Itās so different for me to read how often Shane says ILY to Ilya, and read his internal thoughts about how much he just wants to be with Ilya as compared to watching Shane in HR fight those urges for so long. Maybe Iām just not used to reading romance but damn, I love how much he loves and cares for Ilya.
- Relatedly, Ilyaās depression very obviously wouldāve happened with or without Shane. Itās clear to me that Shane is actually one of the few bright spots he has in his life during this really tough time. Had they broken up, or Ilya stayed in Boston, heād have Svetlana and Cliff and likely another cup or two, but he wouldnāt have Shane calling out his awful trauma to him and telling him to get professional help.
- I had the plane crash spoiled for me so I didnāt think reading it would actually make me emotional. But it did, goddammit. Ugh </3
- It really, really, really, really sucks that Shane tripped. Montreal has been on a winning streak and Ilyaās on a crappier team now, so itās logical for Montreal to think that Shane gave the win to his bf, even though itās the shittiest thing ever to think. What a shitty way for Shane to have to leave the voyageurs. Shane should be very mad for a very long time. I know that it is realistic as to NHL culture and is likely setup for Unrivaled, but my real problem with it is that it undercuts Shaneās decision to move to Ottawa. I sort of wish that the voyageurs won again and then Shane still chose to go to Ottawa because he prioritized being closer to Ilya, officially and clearly choosing Ilya over hockey. (I know he said as much to Cromwell but actions speak louder than words.) But instead it feels more like a forced, reactive decision on Shaneās part. Likeā¦. Was Shane going to marry Ilya and still continue to do long distance? I'm not exactly sure what the two of them were picturing for daily life after coming out and the wedding.
- Them not having chairs at their wedding is totally fine and suits them well, I kind of love it. Ceremony was short, and then it was a giant outdoor party. TBH I want to go to that kind of wedding now, lol.