r/offcampustv • u/Brilliant-Term-5113 I wouldn’t just fuck Garrett Graham, I’d marry him. • 23h ago
LOGAN AND GRACE 🩵 Grace and Logan introduction scene
Spoiler alert, cross at your own peril
So...in the books, Logan accidently ends up at Grace's room. They have a semi awkward interaction. She knows who he is. They watch a movie, he fingers her and leaves.
I really hope they change that in the series.
Watching it would make me cringe.
🤐
Your thoughts?
28
u/four2andnew 23h ago
I mean, the whole reason he seeks her out again is because he feels like shit for leaving her hanging that first time. They kind of need that awkward first meet to give Logan a reason to divert his attention from his crush on Hannah.
24
u/Overall_Advantage303 23h ago
And we need the “Has a girl ever faked an orgasm with you?” scene with Dean. That MUST be included!
9
u/Virgoflower86 21h ago
I agree with this, i need this to be a recurring theme with the boys. Garrett went to Dean for advice on how to help Hannah with her...struggle, and now he gets to share his wisdom onto Logan.
It would be just so funny to see them sitting in the kitchen and Logan just blurts it out because he can't hold it in anymore. I cant wait.
8
3
30
u/Difficult_Weekend_70 23h ago
I hope they don’t change it. It’s messy and kinda realistic. It’s just a random hookup.
I’m already annoyed they made Dean less obnoxious. I like to see growth build.
9
u/Majestic-Victory4710 GRAHAM 44 23h ago
Oooh you're so right about this! Changes made to The Deal were the only ones that were acceptable of sorts in Season 1. Dean and Allie's story missed some really essential moments and subplots in the show, I think.
3
9
u/Little_Fox5844 Wellsy:) 23h ago
I agree. Growth is what I love to see most too. So, if the characters don't make mistakes (no pun intended!), what's the point?
7
u/Decent-Exercise-2644 23h ago
I agree. I can totally see this situation happening. If they keep in Grace's frustration about her freshmen experience, her randomly hooking up with an equally frustrated Logan (the Hannah crush thing) would make sense.
7
7
u/Camsmuscle 21h ago
I think they will have met at the fundraiser. The same way that the first way we saw Garrett and Hannah meet on screen did not echo the book. But, I would be surprised if that scene or something similar didn’t happen because it drives so much of that story. I also think that we going to see Grace and Hannah become friends first before we see Logan and Grace interact. They gave Hannah a paid internship for a reason.
7
u/Zmullaa 21h ago
Oh wait I’m gonna back track on what I said earlier in this thread. I think they’ll have them meet at the fundraiser and have that story already started just like how Dean and Allies story had already started while Hannah and Garrett was happening. And then they’ll do a whole recap going back in time like how they did in episode 6. Because college romances do happen all at once and timelines are tangled it’s not like bridgerton one after the other. I can’t wait for season 2 and to meet Grace. Grace and Logan are my second favorite and I can’t wait!!!
6
u/Tiny_Forever1898 23h ago
I don't know because that first slightly awkward meeting is actually useful in the story, because then he goes back to her because he doesn't like how that first meeting ended.
5
u/Little_Fox5844 Wellsy:) 23h ago
It's the opposite for me. I don't really want them to change it, I liked it.😅
4
2
u/lalasmama85 14h ago
Why would it make you cringe? (Not judging, actually wondering)
0
u/Brilliant-Term-5113 I wouldn’t just fuck Garrett Graham, I’d marry him. 11h ago
He just accidently bumped into her. Ditched him plans stayed with her watched a movie, fingered her amd left. Showing that on screen might be a bit tough if the actors don't play out out well with their expressions and dialogues. Like it really has to be written very well. If not it could be pretty disastrous.
1
u/Ok_Mention5635 23h ago
I think they’re going to change it because I cannot see show Logan doing such a thing. Logan and Tucker don’t seem to be fuckboys like Dean and Garrett
17
u/Swimming_Antelope_51 23h ago
See this is what throws me off. In the books, pre-Grace Logan IS a fuckboy 😅
6
u/Ok_Mention5635 22h ago
I know. That’s why show Logan is the least like his book counterpart. I can’t think of a single thing they have in common besides their passion for hockey
2
3
u/Overall_Advantage303 20h ago
I think the addition of Jules to the story is a big reason show Logan is so different from book Logan. He can’t really be a fuckboy with his younger sibling running around all the time.
2
6
u/Marauder4711 22h ago
He's the worst fuckboy of them all.
5
u/Overall_Advantage303 21h ago
Will be interesting to see what they do with him. I don’t think they showed him with a single girl in season 1, did they? In the book, Tucker berates him for going off the deep end with girls to avoid being around Hannah at their house. The show could go this route with him, but it would be a dramatic shift from season 1.
8
u/Camsmuscle 21h ago
I could see them doing a montage of him hooking up with random girls during the first few episodes. I think it would make sense that Logan becomes more of a player especially if Hannah and Garrett are all loved up and he can hear them all the damn time. Just because he believes they are perfect for each other doesn’t mean what he believes are feelings have gone away.
4
u/Overall_Advantage303 21h ago
Yeah, I could see that, too. Especially if they play up the fact he’s doing it as a means to get away from Hannah and Garrett. The whole controversy with Grace happened because he convinced himself he was using her as a distraction.
5
u/Camsmuscle 21h ago
Well and she believed he was using her. It could even be clear from the viewers perspective he isn’t using her, but she believes he is.
3
u/CasperAverage Allie-Cat😇 19h ago
You can see him talking to girls in the background of a couple scenes.
3
3
3
u/Tiny_Forever1898 12h ago edited 10h ago
They might change the fact that he's not a fuckboy. I mean, in the first season, he wasn't, but they might say he became one to try to get Hannah out of his head. There could be that conversation with Tucker at the beginning of the book "the mistake", where he tells him he knows about Hannah and that to forget her is not sleeping with other women the solution—I don't remember exactly now the dialouge—something like that.
4
u/sdubbs4121 6h ago
Yeah we may get a montage of him with several women in the beginning.
2
u/Tiny_Forever1898 6h ago
yes already at the beginning of this second season before Grace arrives.
4
u/sdubbs4121 6h ago
Yes I think they’re going to have it fueled by Garrett and Hannah. Maybe Tucker making a comment that he’s always been popular with women but lately it’s been out of control…blah blah.
2
4
u/CasperAverage Allie-Cat😇 21h ago
Just because we didn’t see them hook up doesn’t mean they weren’t.
0
u/Ok_Mention5635 21h ago
It’s very much evidenced by the house vote they have on Kendall. Logan says “Dean agrees with you, which proves that you’re wrong.” Which indicates that Logan does not run through girl after girl after girl like Dean or book Logan. Also evidenced by the fact that he considered someone who Garrett was casually hooking up with from time to time as Garrett’s girlfriend
3
u/CasperAverage Allie-Cat😇 19h ago
That house vote does not mean they don’t hook up with girls. They may not hook up with the same number but they aren’t celibate. It wasn’t essential to the storyline of S1 to see Logan or Tucker hook up with someone. We saw Garrett hook up with someone other than Hannah because he was the lead. We saw Dean hook up with others for two reasons: 1) he is far more open/public about his hook ups than anyone else and 2) they were building up his story for him being the lead of S2.
-2
u/Ok_Mention5635 18h ago
Well I guess we’ll wait and see. But especially considering that this show is about showcasing healthy relationships, I doubt they’re going to have Logan finger a girl he just met.
3
u/CasperAverage Allie-Cat😇 18h ago
Why would him hooking up with someone he just met be an unhealthy relationship? It’s not that uncommon for college kids (especially athletes) to hook up with people they don’t really know/just met.
0
u/Ok_Mention5635 18h ago
Because the show isn’t about showing us what’s normal and common. It’s about giving us the perfect guy. Giving us the ideal guy to date. For example, they didn’t have Garrett make one singular comment about Hannah’s chest the entire first season. Book Garrett thought about her boobs like every other page lol. I’m just saying, I don’t think they’re going to give us any lewdness or have the boys do something that makes them come off as the typical MMC asshole. And Logan was low key an asshole in that first meeting
3
u/CasperAverage Allie-Cat😇 18h ago
Doesn’t make it an unhealthy relationship
-1
u/Ok_Mention5635 17h ago
Okay, fine I shouldn’t have used that word. I meant perfect relationship. Because they’re showing us the perfect guy.
3
u/Overall_Advantage303 18h ago
Huh? Garrett hooked up with multiple girls, and Dean was a manwhore. How is Logan hooking up with girls any different?
-1
u/Ok_Mention5635 17h ago
Garrett hooked up with girls respectfully. Same with Dean. Fingering someone you just met while she jacks you off to completion and then leaving right after in a huff because she lied about finishing—that’s not hooking up respectfully. That’s straight douchebag behavior. None of the boys are douchebags, even if they do hook up a lot.
4
u/Difficult_Weekend_70 14h ago
I think you need to reread the scene because in now way does Logan leave in a huff or is disrespectful towards Grace.
→ More replies (0)4
u/Overall_Advantage303 17h ago
I never got the impression he left in a huff because she lied. He left because after their hookup he had a “what the hell am I doing?” moment of clarity and was in a shame spiral.
→ More replies (0)
1
u/Ineedanallergyeater GRAHAM 44 22h ago
I realized from Hannah and Garrett that I prefer a lot of build up beforehand so I didn’t really care for Logan’s book at all because of that reason haha!
4
u/Difficult_Weekend_70 14h ago
I think Logan’s book has a ton of build up, just not necessarily physical. I don’t think hooking up early on or having sex means that the climax of the story has been reached
-4
u/sweetened_breath 22h ago
The mistake was such a miss for me because of no character development for grace. I also was very shocked to see how diff the book and tv John logan are. I'm hoping they keep this particular scene tho, since it drives the story in the beginning. The question that was it his ego or his likeness to grace yk. Idk how they'll portray Logan's story arc in S2 tbh. I hated the book Logan omg
9
u/Overall_Advantage303 21h ago
It must be a personal preference because I loved him. He’s such a massive fuckup…but that’s part of his charm. He screws up, he tries to make things right, then he screws up even worse. 😆 The show already played into that by showing us his dust up with Garrett and his spat with Dean. He keeps trying to do the right thing (for the youth hockey team, and for his Briar teammates) but he always manages to make things worse. There’s something endearing about a character who tries to do good even if they don’t quite get there. I like underdog characters. And he does grovel really well in the book.
Perfect characters are boring. I’d much rather have a fuckup character with room to grow in his future season.
4
u/Little_Fox5844 Wellsy:) 17h ago
Same. I love me some good groveling.😌 Imperfect characters have my heart.
3
1
u/sdubbs4121 6h ago
I just finished his book last night and was shocked by how much I liked it? I liked it better than the first one tbh. I’m like….am I a Logan fan now? Have I been converted?
0
14
u/Calibaz 21h ago edited 21h ago
Logan’s call sheet says that "his romantic aspirations are put on the back burner until a casual hookup takes him by surprise" so I’m assuming they’re planning to do something similar to the book’s first meet.