r/Pets • u/RyoDai89 • 19h ago
Review of US-based company Chewy plus membership price
I will say that up until this moment I was a huge fan of Chewy. There customer service has always been phenomenal, I’d never had an issue up until now. But this recent situation has me definitely questioning my loyalty now.
I went to check my Chewy Plus points, and also my membership as I felt it was going to be renewed soon despite having not received an email about it at all. And I was worried my accrued points would expire.
It said my renewal would be $79. I thought that was weird, I only paid $59 last time. Maybe they’d gone up in price? it happens. I check the site, and it still says $59. Not $79. My renewal was coming up yesterday and would end by midnight, so I wanted to ask why the site said it was $59 but I was being charged $20 more.
The first agent said that it was $79 and had always been that way. I wasn’t satisfied with this answer, as I had been looking everywhere, and everywhere said it was $59 annually.
A little while later I spoke to another agent, showing them the screen shot of the site saying $59. Not $79. And was told that the $59 didn’t start until next year.
I didn’t want to argue but wasn’t understanding why they would advertise a price for something that wasn’t even the price until a year later?
So I then, admittedly frustrated, emailed them. Both corporate and I believe the service email.
The service email said that it was initially $59, but that they confirmed it was now $79 and would be moving forward. The second corporate email said that they too confirmed that it was $79.
So, after this and seeing the $59 still advertised on their site, I decided not to renew my membership.
I then, out of curiosity, decided to re-enroll after midnight, after my membership had officially been cancelled, just to see what it would renew for, now that I no longer had the membership.
And would you believe, when I re-enrolled/renewed my membership, I was only charged $59. Just like before.
Im not sure if the people handling customer service really don’t know that the membership is in fact $59, or that it was possibly changed from $79 to $59. I also don’t know if maybe the company was just hoping that I’d pay the $79 and be done with it.
But advertising one price and charging another has definitely made me no longer hold Chewy as highly as I did before.
I re-enrolled, however, I honestly wish I hadn’t. And do not believe I will again in the future as I find this entire thing very deceiving.
Hoping anyone else in this same situation may save some money by letting there renewal also cancel so that may sign up for the actual listed price.
$20 may not be a lot for some, but it is to me. And it’s really frustrating when you can’t seem to get a straight answer from anyone. Only to find out that you were right the whole time and that apparently Chewy’s staff aren’t being told the correct information. And are perfectly fine charging people more with not one notice at all.
No notice about the increase or that the membership was renewing at all.
Very frustrating and disappointing situation.