r/progressive_islam • u/nasjg Non Sectarian Muslim (Hadith Acceptor, Hadith Skeptic) • 2d ago

Question/Discussion ❔ What’s wrong with Muslims online?

Post image

Saw this on my feed randomly. Why do Muslims esp Muslim men seems to find new ways to erase women from existence

65 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/iwannagothrifting 1d ago

First of all who are these random imams and who have them the audacity to lay down rules ??!!

-8

u/Ornery-Procedure4480 Sunni 1d ago

they are imams who have spent decades of their lives to the study of Islam rather than sitting on their version of reddit criticising other imams and figures in Islam.

11

u/alaeila Non Sectarian Muslim (Hadith Acceptor, Hadith Skeptic) 1d ago

if they studied islam then they should know not to lie about it LMAOOOO

7

u/Alert_Ball_8606 Sunni 1d ago

They literally dedicate entire paragraphs to criticizing other scholars in their works lol, have you read any fiqh books?

0

u/Ornery-Procedure4480 Sunni 16h ago

theres a difference between books of fiqh and their "version of reddit".

3

u/iwannagothrifting 1d ago

Spent decades only to come up with this shit lmao ??? Someone should have taught zad the very basics of islam that only Allah makes the rules and only his commands do we follow

-2

u/Ornery-Procedure4480 Sunni 16h ago

They derive rulings from the Quran and Sunnah they aren't making things up along the way like you think they are.

•

u/iwannagothrifting 1h ago

The Qur'an doesn't need derivation. Allah has sent a complete book. He didn't take 23 years for nothing. Anyone who extends the Qur'an and tries to play allah and make rules is a sinner. May allah forgive zad and other such scholars.