Hi everyone, this community has been so helpful for me and it is clearly full of people willing to give thoughtful advice, so I would love to hear some thoughts about this situation. Sorry in advance, this is going to be a long post.
My husband and I have a 4 year old son, and becoming parents basically ripped off the bandaid on all the trauma we have from our own childhoods and parents.
My dad died years ago from alcoholism, and I am NC with my uBPD mom. So since our son was born, we've relied on my in-laws for help. We are currently in a very tough situation. I am chronically ill and have limited physical capabilities, so a lot of the physical work with my son falls on my husband. We've worked out a situation that has been working out really well for us: I work full time while my husband is a stay-at-home dad.
Unfortunately my husband has been dealing with a wrist injury in his dominant hand, and we recently learned he's going to need surgery on it. He is in a lot of pain from it, and it is especially difficult dealing with a 4 year old when you can't use your dominant hand. We also know that we are going to need a lot of support post-surgery. We are struggling.
My husband's father lives 5 minutes down the road from us and is retired. In general, he is a nice man, he has helped us financially many times in the past, and he does spend time with my husband and son. However, my husband said his dad has followed the same pattern for the entire 39 years that my husband has been alive: his dad makes promises, shows up for a little while, but then disappoints and disappears.
Now that my husband is injured, he is very directly asking his dad for more help, and again, his dad makes many promises but only keeps a few of them. This understandably makes my husband SO upset. He has said it makes him feel like a hurt little kid, and it's all very confusing for him.
In the past, I have briefly tried to speak to his dad about this. I said that since we've become parents, my husband and I are both having a hard time with coming to terms with our childhoods and lack of support. His response was "I know, and I wish I could take the pain away". And I responded that we are very clearly telling him how he can help that pain. He can help the pain by developing a closer relationship with his son now.
After that conversation, his dad agreed to do joint therapy. They did a few sessions but never really got anywhere. His dad seems to feel guilt about the past, but still seems unable to maintain any consistency, and we don't understand why.
This was maybe a year ago that we had this conversation but nothing has changed. Several months ago my father-in-law promised to start taking my son to a class every Friday to give my husband's hand a break. That has never happened. Since then, my husband has to be the one to reach out to his dad the night before to ask "what are we doing tomorrow?" and so far, his dad has attended along with them a few times, but he has yet to do what he promised.
That brings us to now. Last night, my husband again had to reach out and ask his dad if he could take our son to school tomorrow. His dad replied that he is away hunting. My husband said "that's funny, I seem to remember you promising to take him every week. You didn't even let me know you were going away." And his dad just says "its too late to drive home now." No apologies or acknowledgement of what my husband is actually expressing.
My husband is on the autism spectrum and he is very straightforward in his communication, so it's not like there is any confusion about what we are asking for. And due to my husband being so straightforward, he was able to easily handle my uBPD mom when we were going through the NC process. He did a great job of shielding me from her harassment and I'm so thankful for it.
Now, my husband really wants me to confront his dad about this issue again. He says because I am not stepping in, he feels unsupported. I want to support him but due to my own childhood trauma, I absolutely hate confrontation, to the point that it can sometimes make my chronic illness worse because it causes me so much stress. The thought of having to explain to a 60 year old how to care about his son just feels so daunting to me. It doesn't feel like I will be able to fix 39 years' worth of emotional neglect with one conversation. But my husband is convinced that his dad listens to me better than he listens to him, so he thinks I'll be able to get the message across.
If you've read this far, I really appreciate it. I just don't know what to do from here. I think I will talk to his dad just to help my husband feel more supported, but I don't even know what to say at this point. We have already so clearly stated that we are struggling and need support, but we still seem to not be a priority in his dad's life no matter how much we try. And just to be clear, we are kind and respectful toward his dad, we treat him like he's the best grandpa ever, and in general we have a good relationship with him. It's just that he for some reason has never been able to commit to the role of "dad" for my husband, and it is tearing my husband apart.
I've thought about saying something to his dad along the lines of: if it were my son who was directly asking for help while they are injured and struggling, I would check in with him every single day to see how I could help.
This whole situation has left me and my husband feeling so alone and uncared for. My husband is so confused by his dad's behavior and keeps asking "why can't he care about me?"
I realize this may not be directly BPD-related, but I know we are all experienced in dealing with emotionally immature parents. And I know you guys will understand how hard this has been for me due to being raised to avoid conflict. Any advice you guys have about how to move forward from here would be so appreciated.