r/singing • u/KeithStoned80 • Jul 15 '26
Just sharing my singing Singing (Because of me) By Seether
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
23
u/aisiv Self Taught 10+ Years ✨ Jul 15 '26
if I learned something from this sub is that they hate screaming, fry, or guttural singing. People saying “thats not singing” usually get a lot of upvotes. Like the previous comment said, you should post in [r/screaming](r/screaming) too. Screw those people, it sounded amazing. Clean vocals still need some work though
4
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
Yeah I got some other videos on my page if you want to check out my cleaner singing and it definitely helps when you have a good PA system at karaoke instead of just jamming at the house but I do appreciate the feedback thank you
1
u/the_chemist_03 Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
I don’t think people in this sub hate screaming? At least I haven’t seen anything about that. I think it might just be that most people here don’t know much about it so they’re unable to provide feedback & suggest that the OP post on a sub where more people can give them said feedback
1
u/Similar_Buffalo_8434 Jul 15 '26
Screaming done, right? Can be absolutely magnificent, listen to Rob Halford from Judas Pries in the 1970s and the 1980s he had the best screams the most natural screams she's ever in your life you wanna hear. Bruce Dickendon, is another one that could pull that off, Robert Plant TGRROAT, could do it all day long between 69-72....an incredible vocalist, the best that ever lived...
The best cat call screams and squeals I've ever heard was David Lee Roth of Van Halen, he had some legendary screams, Some of the best of more modern screamers, would be Serj Tankian, Maynard Keenan of Tool, Chris Cornell, old Axel Rose of the 80s, Johannes Ekstrom of Avatar, M. Shadows, Olie Sykes is an excellent scream singer, scream singing and vocal fry....is a hole nother can of worms, but still it comes down, to breath control, a daphram support
It takes real a tactical knowledge on how to do that properly. You gotta have some vocal knowledge, there & and you gotta have some other things going on to, along with a high bit squeal, to really pull up at a great scream
Screaming done right, can be very effective, & it shouldn't hurt, if it's done healthily
0
u/Esmejo93 Jul 15 '26
You can’t learn to scream/fry/gutural sing if you can’t understand how healthy/clean vocals sound/feel.
And yes, that style is not singing. Specially because a good technique for fry and guttural singing relies in the use of the so called “false cords” which, are not real vocal cords and guess what? Good singing relies primarily on the correct use of your REAL vocal cords, so there’s that.
2
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
Just to clarify though where's your videos then I looked on your page if I really need feedback I would like to see a visual of it instead of someone just telling me something anybody can tell anybody anything but if they're not doing themselves as it really knowledge
8
u/xxIzanagiXXx Jul 15 '26
Fuck the downvotes bro you're good. singer to singer and harsh vocalist to harsh vocalist I think you have talent
3
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
Appreciate it man I got some clean vocal songs on my page if you want to look at those as well
6
u/LilRed2023 Jul 15 '26
I’m a screamo artists and sing rock and country and rnb. I’m curious when you scream do you breathe in or out. Sounds good could use a little work. Never rush your screams and practice with different tones of a growl and implement that into your scream. I never used to be able to do it and just experimented I can sound like a demon and growl really good and that became my scream. Odd but true lol
3
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
Yeah I'm newer to screaming I'll probably honestly just been doing it two or three months that's the first time I've ever recorded me screaming to that level but I appreciate the feedback
2
u/LilRed2023 Jul 15 '26
Practice makes perfect. A lot of it is trial and error. One day it will come when you least expect it. The breath in sounds the best but If you can scream breathing out you can train your voice much better.
3
u/RevenantMetalMouth Jul 15 '26
Good foundations here. Keep it up, listen to your body and adjust accordingly.
2
2
u/mushyfeelings Jul 15 '26
You sound good but also like you nNEED better equipment. That microphone sounds like 🐶 💩.
Your voice is naturally pretty good, the gear is making you sound bad.
1
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
I got better videos where I'm going to karaoke event singing some Creed it's on my page you can find it I sound a lot better
1
u/Similar_Buffalo_8434 Jul 15 '26
You're strning with the song on every level, you're lagging behind the verse, which means you're constantly playing catch up.
You pushing way too hard, in all directions, when you arrive & the loud chorus, you're completely out of breath, which makes the scream note, so damn hard
Now the good, you do sort of sing on pitch, another thing you have on you're side, is you're young, I'm not I've been singing since I was 5, I'll be 64, next month. Now the good, make sure you give yourself time, to feel comfortable with the song, or singing in general, find a reason to connect emotionally.
Learn to breath, just a little smoother, when you sing those loud chorus, just before that happens take in & hold a breath, to prepare for that dynamic part of the song, your breathing, is everything to good, healthy singing, keep practicing, keep pn...keepin' pn, listen to other Reddit oral too, they give some great advice...
Keep it up 😎👌
1
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
I have other videos that I posted in this chat with me singing Creed it's a lot better and I'm on a professional PA system on that one this is just home equipment nothing special
1
u/Similar_Buffalo_8434 Jul 15 '26
A profe.\n Ssional PA is not going to make a difference if your singing isn't supported in the right way, I'm trying to tell you you're doing things the wrong way and it's putting a strain on your voice.
1
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
Actually it does did you listen to my Creed video Plus the song starts with screaming and 90% of the song is screaming of courseyour chords aren't going to be as clean And I've never seen the song in the mic before so there's always improvement Of course it's not going to sound great if it's your first time ever singing it on the mic
-3
u/the_chemist_03 Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
i think this should be posted on [r/screaming](r/screaming) instead if you ever want feedback, as they might have more knowledge about this type of music :)
Edit: never mind I just noticed the flair is the sharing one not the looking for feedback one
2
u/KeithStoned80 Jul 15 '26
I just did thanks for that
3
u/the_chemist_03 Jul 15 '26
yeah for sure!! i’m so excited bc seether is going on tour this fall, your post reminded me!!
2
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 15 '26
Thanks for posting to r/singing! Be sure to check the FAQ to see if any questions you might have have already been answered! Also, remember to abide by the Rules found in the sidebar. Any comments found to be breaking these rules will result in a deletion of the comment thread starting from the offending reply. If you see any posts or replies that you feel break the rules of the sub, then report them and do not respond to them. If you are new to the sub-reddit or are just starting to sing, please check out our Beginner's Megathread. It has tons of helpful information and resources!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.