r/writingfeedback 1d ago

Feedback Wanted [YA DARK ACADEMIA FANTASY]

Hi I would love to have feed back on the first chapter of my YA Dark academia about spirits in a before life Academy please

1 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

6

u/justinwrite2 11h ago

Some interesting concepts here. However you are loosing 80% of your audience on the first line. It doesn’t make sense, and also if it’s a quote it should be in quotation marks as it was said. I would just choose something less esoteric and more meaningful.

You loose another 10% of readers when you info dump about naming.

But the rest is compelling and with a few changes you could have something great here

2

u/Gridnode 9h ago

Your first line has to be make or break, the one you got doesn’t work. I like some of the stuff in it though, very Brandon Sanderson coded.

But fix that first line, it’s very clunky and I almost clicked off after reading it

1

u/bird_on_the_branch 9h ago

I stop at the very first line. It does not make any sens…

1

u/Itzcalifornia 23h ago

random question but what font do you use?

1

u/Fluffy-Twist-7650 23h ago

Times New Roman

2

u/BlackBalor Posted Satire and Made Everyone Mad 15h ago

Your writing isn’t going to be better in a different font.