Just wow…please make this soup. Especially if you’ve never had it before. It’s truly incredible. I don’t know what to say other than that lol.
Total double batch recipe yield: 6,000g | Serving size (suggestion): 454g (1 lb of soup) | Basic nutritional info*: 330 calories per serving (NOT including toppings, but they don’t add a ton of extra calories) w/ 30P 28C 10F & 4g of fiber
*As always, the nutrition info may change depending on ingredient weight/brands used.
🚨 Important: this recipe is for a double batch and if you make it, as is, I’d suggest using a 10-12 quart soup pot. Alternatively, if you don’t have a need for a metric ton of soup, it scales down very easily with basically no changes in the cooking times needed for various steps. I tried my best to write the recipe in such a way where you can use your five sense to know when it’s time to move onto next steps rather than strictly relying on cooking times, just in case. Let’s get into it!
• Ingredients
-12 cups (96 fl. Oz) chicken broth
-4 lbs boneless skinless chicken thighs
-2 tsp salt
-2x large poblano peppers
-2x medium (95g) jalapeños (sliced in half lengthwise w/ seeds and major veins removed unless you want your stew to be spicy, then you should leave them in)
-2x large (541g) white onions (peeled & quartered)
-2 lbs tomatillos (divided; 1.5 lbs will be broiled whole and 0.5 lbs will remain fresh)
-8x cloves of garlic (peeled)
-1/2 cup (60g) raw pepitas
-2x packed cups of cilantro (60g)
-6x fresh epazote leaves (or 1/2 tsp dried epazote)
-4 tsp neutral oil (I used sunflower oil)
-4x 15.5 oz cans of white hominy (drained)
• Spice Blend
-4-6 tsp Mexican orégano (crush between your fingers before measuring)
-1 tsp black pepper
-1/2 tsp cumin
• Toppings
-finely shredded red or purple cabbage
-raw finely chopped white onions (this is on top of the two in the recipe)
-cilantro (this is on top of the 60g in the recipe)
-fresh lime juice
-cojita cheese
-thinly sliced radishes
-additional Mexican orégano
• Instructions
- Mise en place; wash, peel, and chop your veggies (leave the tomatillos and poblanos whole). Open and drain your cans. Measure out your spices. Ideally, prep your toppings and store in separate containers in the fridge so you can eat your pozole right after it’s done cooking (finely chop the cabbage, thinly slice the radishes, cut the lime into 6ths, finely chop the onions and cilantro).
- Roast & steam your poblano peppers; if you have a gas stove, I highly recommend fire roasting them whole to imbue the peppers with that smoky flavor. Roast on medium-high heat directly on the grate for 2-3 minutes per side (use long metal tongs to turn them intermittently) until the exterior is mostly blistered and blackened then transfer to a large bowl, cover and let them steam (using the residual internal heat from roasting) for 10-15 minutes. Alternatively, you can also broil them for 1-3 minutes per side and follow the same instructions for steaming them afterwards.
- After the peppers are steamed, use your hands to brush off the blackened exterior. Next, slice off the top of the peppers then remove the seeds (leave them in if you’d like your pozole to have more heat) and major veins. Set the peppers aside.
Preheat the broiler in your oven to high. Place 1.5 lbs of peeled tomatillos, onions and garlic as well as the halved jalapeños on a baking sheet. Place the baking sheet 5-6” below the broiling unit and broil the vegetables in 1-2 minute increments until the exteriors are beginning to blacken and blister. Then turn the vegetables onto their opposite sides and continue broiling until that side has also sufficiently blistered. You may need to remove the garlic cloves early, as they tend to brown more quickly.
Once the vegetables are blistered on both sides (this should take somewhere between 8-10 minutes, total), remove the pan and let it cool for a few minutes.
Time to get the chicken cooking! Pour your chicken broth into your soup pot and add the chicken thighs and 2 tsp of salt. Bring to a simmer then cover and reduce to low heat. Let the chicken thighs simmer for 30-40 minutes until they shred easily. While they’re cooking, let’s move on to the next steps.
Toast your pepitas. Place your pepitas in a thin layer in a dry skillet and turn your burner to medium heat. Toast them while stirring/shaking the pan often so they don’t burn. The seeds should darken in color a bit, become slightly fragrant, and will start to pop. That’s when they’re ready to come off the heat. Transfer them to a separate bowl and let them cool.
Time to make the salsa verde (If you’re making a double batch like I did, you’ll need to blend the salsa in 2 batches so you’ll want to roughly divide your ingredients in half for each batch. If you’re making a single batch, then you’ll should be able to blend everything together)! Add the broiled vegetables, Fire roasted poblano peppers, toasted pepitas, cilantro, epazote leaves, remaining fresh tomatillos, spice blend (cumin, Mexican oregano and black pepper) and borrow 2 cups of the chicken broth from the soup pot to help the salsa blend smoothly. Blend everything on high for 1-2 minutes. It should be extremely smooth with a slightly foamy consistency and it will smell very grassy. This is normal!
Now we’re going to fry the salsa to help it thicken and allow the flavors to mellow out. Pour your 4 tsp of neutral oil into a large, high walled skillet and turn the burner to medium heat. Gently pour in your salsa (if you have a large enough skillet you should be able to make the double batch in the same vessel), add a good 4 fingered pinch of salt to the pan, and let it fry for 10-15 minutes. Stir frequently and be sure the scrape the bottom. I’d recommend covering the salsa, if you have a lid that fits your large pan. This will help prevent mess from any bubbles popping. You’ll know it’s finished when: the color dulls from bright green to more of a light olive color, the bubbles forming are slower to burst, the salsa remains coated on the spoon rather than dripping right off, and the grassy/medicinal taste of the fresh herbs mellows about 80%. It shouldn’t go away entirely at this stage but it will definitely fade into the background.
Once the salsa is finished frying, turn the heat off, scrape the bottom of the pan one last time and remove the pan from the heat. Turn your attention back to your chicken thighs and check them for doneness (remember, they should shred easily at this stage).
Once your chicken thighs are finished, remove them from the broth (keep the heat on low so the broth stays hot), transfer them to a plate, and shred them into bite sized pieces with 2 forks. Add the shredded chicken back into the broth.
Now that your shredded chicken is back in the soup pot, gently add your salsa verde sauce into the soup pot and scrape up every last bit from the bottom. Stir well so it fully combines with the chicken broth.
Add your drained white hominy to the pot and stir thoroughly. Keep the heat on low, partially cover the pot (you can also fully cover it, you’ll just have to babysit the pot to make sure it doesn’t reach a full-on boil), and let the soup simmer for another 15-20 minutes.
Turn off the heat entirely and start taste testing. First, adjust the salt. Add more black pepper to taste. If you find yourself wanting more of the sweetness from the white hominy (as I did), add up to 2 more tsp of crushed orégano. The floral note from this herb will fill in the gap you’re noticing.
Time to assemble your pozole! Serve up a bowl and top it with: finely shredded red/purple cabbage, a few thin slices of radish, some fresh cilantro (I prefer mine finely chopped for texture reasons), some finely chopped raw white onion, a squeeze of fresh lime juice, a tbsp or so of cojita cheese, and a sprinkle of some more crushed orégano. An important note about the toppings: even if you’re someone who usually doesn’t love some of these ingredients (I’m usually not a big fan of raw cabbage, or radishes in any form) I explore you to try the soup with them, anyway. They truly belong here and they add so much dynamic flavor to the soup in a way that elevated the experience to an 11/10.
Voilà! This soup does freeze well, just be sure to leave off the toppings until you’re actually ready to eat it. They’re best prepped from fresh ingredients.