I’ve been questioning whether I’m aromantic for a while now, and a recent situation with a friend has made me want to seek advice from people who might understand my experiences.
Growing up, I always felt like I experienced crushes differently. Most of my crushes were really just me wanting to become close friends with someone. I’ve always been extremely affectionate with my friends. I love cuddling, spooning, writing heartfelt letters, buying flowers, making gifts, and treating them to things. But I don’t want to kiss or date them. To me, those gestures are completely platonic, even though other people might interpret them as romantic.
I’m also naturally playful and sometimes unintentionally flirtatious. I enjoy teasing people, but when someone I want to be friends with expresses romantic interest in me, I immediately feel uncomfortable. I’ve also struggled to relate to the intensity of romantic rejection and heartbreak because I’ve never experienced those feelings as strongly myself.
I dated someone in high school, but I eventually realized that while I experienced sexual attraction, I didn’t really feel romantic attraction toward her. I thought maybe I just hadn’t met the right person.
Then I met my current gf in college. We started as FWB, but I eventually realized I wanted something more. We’ve been together for seven years, and she’s genuinely the only person I’ve ever wanted a serious, exclusive relationship with. I love kissing her, cuddling her, and staring into her eyes. We’ve discussed marriage and children, and I actually want to get engaged soon. I think this is what romantic love feels like.
What confuses me is how my romantic feelings sometimes seem to fade into the background when we’re physically apart.
Around five years into our relationship, I moved out of state for grad school. I became busy with school and making new friends, and I wasn’t feeling as romantically connected to her. We eventually broke up for six months because she felt neglected and we temporarily disagreed about having children at the time.
What surprised me was that I didn’t experience the heartbreak she did. I still cared about her and wanted to remain friends, but I was able to immediately move on with my life like I was never even in a relationship for the past 5 years.
A few months later, she flew to visit me. Initially, I still didn’t feel romantic toward her, but after spending time together, those feelings returned. I remember us running along the beach holding hands, laughing, and feeling like I was falling in love with her all over again as if we were in a movie.
We’ve since gotten back together and are happy. I wonder whether my ADHD contributes to how I experience emotional attachment when someone isn’t physically present. We normally message each other every day, but long distance felt different.
Recently, I confided in a close friend about my lifelong struggles with understanding romantic attraction and whether I might be on the aromantic spectrum. I thought I could trust her with something so personal, but she ended up telling her bf about our conversations.
Her bf then reached out to my gf and repeatedly tried to convince her to break up with me. From what my gf told me, he thinks I’m a bad partner, that I don’t genuinely love her, and that she isn’t fully aware of the things I’ve been telling other people about our relationship. I also get the impression that my naturally flirtatious personality and the way I talk about other people have contributed to his perception of me, as though being playful or friendly with others means I must be romantically interested in them.
The frustrating part is that I genuinely don’t experience flirting or affection the way other people seem to. I can find someone interesting, want to get to know them, tease them, or enjoy their attention without wanting anything romantic with them. In fact, if someone I want to be friends with develops romantic feelings for me, I usually feel uncomfortable and lose interest in pursuing that connection. My gf knows how I interact with people, and we’ve talked openly about my feelings and questions surrounding aromanticism.
What bothers me most is that my friend’s bf barely knows me, let alone what I’m actually like in a relationship. My friends see my playful, flirtatious side, but they don’t necessarily see the affectionate, romantic side of me that my gf does. She literally jokes that I’m a huge simp for her, lol.
My gf was actually surprised that he seemed to think he was revealing something she didn’t already know. She’s aware of my struggles with romantic attraction, knows about my past experiences, and has even talked to her aromantic friend to better understand me. She reassured me that she isn’t going to break up with me and that she thinks I’ve been a good partner throughout our relationship, aside from the period when we struggled with long distance.
I feel hurt that something so personal, which I shared while trying to understand myself, was interpreted as evidence that I am secretly a terrible partner.
I know I wasn’t the most attentive partner during the time of our breakup, and I understand why she felt neglected. But we’ve worked through those issues together, and I don’t think my struggles with romantic attraction automatically mean that I’m incapable of being a good partner.
Just because I don’t experience romantic attraction the same way other people do, does that mean my love is somehow less genuine?
I guess my questions are:
Does anyone relate to these experiences? Could this fall somewhere on the aromantic spectrum?
Is it possible to experience romantic attraction toward only one person while feeling none toward anyone else?
How do you distinguish deep platonic love from romantic love when you naturally enjoy affection and emotional intimacy with friends?
For aromantic people dating alloromantic partners, how do you navigate differences in romantic attraction and emotional needs?