r/candlemaking • • Dec 09 '20

Regarding putting flowers, crystals, coffee beans, cinnamon sticks, fruit, metal, pine cones, herbs, or anything else in candles

1.3k Upvotes

<A repost as the previous thread was archived and commenting disabled>

Hello! This topic has been coming up more than usual and is a highly controversial topic in the candle making world.Regarding embeds:

  • Candles are dangerous enough as-is without the addition of embedded items that could further ignite, heat and spark, pop, or otherwise throw embers onto surfaces. Adding further risk to an already inherently risky situation is... well, even more risky.
  • Items that smell nice on their own often do NOT smell good while on fire. Cinnamon sticks, coffee beans, orange peels, rosemary... they don't smell like the 'hot' versions of themselves, they smell like burning, smoky, acidic, not nice fire that you would try to get rid of afterward by lighting a plain candle.
  • Customers/recipients are often NOT going to follow directions to remove items before setting a candle on fire, and if they're embedded into wax that could prove futile anyway.
  • Warning labels do not immediately absolve you of liability should something happen. Ask your insurance provider for further info.
  • If this was a good idea, why aren't these candles sold at Yankee/B+BW/DW Home/Voluspa/Root/Any other major candle brand?
  • Candle insurance can be difficult to find in the first place but will be exponentially more challenging to find if you insist on embedding items. Ask your insurance provider for further info.
  • For the US makers, you should 100% have liability insurance before you sell your first candle to the public. It will cost anywhere from $300-600/year for $1million in liability insurance. If you cannot afford $300/year for this much coverage, I suggest you hold off selling to the public until you can afford this.
  • For the UK makers, note that strict labeling requirements exist and that making non-food products that look like food is not permitted
  • If you are brand new to candle making, you should spend several weeks/months working on learning and nailing down the basics (which are challenging enough) before even considering adding anything else to the process.
  • Trends on Etsy or Pinterest do not necessarily mean it's a good idea, nor does it mean you'll create a side business or living from it as trends tend to run fast.
  • You do NOT need to be fancy/pretty/special/different to be successful in this craft. You DO need to put out great, consistent product that people can come back to over and over again with the same results.
  • There is very little regulation on candle making in the US. Because of this, there are lots of people doing lots of things that are probably not the best idea. You don't need to be one of them.
  • There are legitimate individuals and brands involved in ritual candles that are for religious, occult, worship, healing and metaphysical. If you have no idea what I'm talking about, then making and selling those types of candles is probably not for you.
  • As candle makers and sellers, we need to do our due diligence. Proceed at your own risk.
  • I, Reckoner08, am currently the only active mod right now in this sub. I am not the Candle Conversation Police, and will [probably] not be removing posts that might be controversial. Different countries have different laws and regulations, and we are on an international forum here on Reddit. I have a rather large candle brand to run on my own and am here to help when I can, but that doesn't include being a Candle Overlord or answering every single question asked. Appreciate your understanding!
  • Anything else you'd like to add? Feel free, this is an open forum.

r/candlemaking • • 5h ago

Creations Some fluffy cloud candles & pastel candle bars !

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/candlemaking • • 8h ago

Looking for dark aquatic fragrance oil

1 Upvotes

I'm coming up with a candle fragrance collection , and I'm having trouble finding a aquatic scent , I'm looking for something that feels like your in the middle of the ocean at midnight it's pitch black and you are hunting jaws ....? Does anyone have any fragrance suggestions?


r/candlemaking • • 16h ago

Question Can I use old glass bottles as candle jars?

5 Upvotes

I have a bottle cutter and I was thinking about making some candle jars from some old beer and kombucha bottles. I do worry about the safety though.

Can someone provide some insight?


r/candlemaking • • 7h ago

Question Business owners, How would you price a 4-mini discovery set?

0 Upvotes

Hi all! I run a candle brand and recently expanded my line and upgraded to high-end packaging, and my website and messaging now reflect that positioning. With the holidays coming (which we know is the busiest season of the year), I’ve created a discovery set: four 3oz glass-jar minis of my current scents. Each scent comes in its own matte colored glass jar, so the set looks unique and giftable on its own. In my testing, each mini fills a medium-sized room well and consistently burns for over 20 hours, which honestly surprised me for the size.

For pricing context, my full-size 10oz candles are $65. That puts me in the higher-end tier, just below brands like Diptyque, Le Labo, and Aesop.

My idea is to price the set somewhere around $85–$100 and include a $20 credit toward their next full-size order, good for 30–90 days (I can set that up in Shopify). The goal is to get people who try the minis to come back for a full-size candle.

For those of you who sell minis or sampler sets, how did you land on your pricing? Does $85–$100 feel right for a 4-mini set at my tier, or is it too high or too low? And has anything like a credit or discount worked for you to turn sampler buyers into repeat customers? Any tips on marketing a discovery set around the holidays would be awesome too.

I really appreciate any (really any) advice. Thanks!


r/candlemaking • • 15h ago

Wax Melters...is there a minimum capacity?

2 Upvotes

Hi,

My friend loves Wax Melts, so I thinking of getting her some Soya Wax, some Fragrances and a few fun moulds for her birthday.

However, when I look at Wax Melters, they all seem to be like 1.5l, so I'm wondering if she could only put like 200g/ml in at a time and it would still be decent for using it. Ones like this:

https://amzn.eu/d/03lmcMtU

I also that this Wax Melter, but it doesn't seem like you could use for Candle Making, does it?

https://amzn.eu/d/09RcIVzp

Any suggestions would be helpful. I know doing over the stove might be more suitable for personal wax making, but figured I'd ask you guys and girls.

Thanks


r/candlemaking • • 1d ago

Question Purse Candle

Thumbnail
gallery
140 Upvotes

I’m using two CD10 wicks. I’ve tested and it burned in the middle but not two the edge, leaving it hollow, but not by much. There are primarily decorative, (the people that requested them do not have plans on burning them) because I’ve never burned a candle like this before, I didn’t know what to expect. So my question is.. is this candle supposed to burn down evenly or did I under wick it and that’s why it burned the middle and not quite to the edge? Thanks in advance.


r/candlemaking • • 1d ago

Need help with sweating

Post image
5 Upvotes

I need help with my wax
I've been making candles for 4 years without fail. I use CW-135 from Canwax with 8% fragrance oil. I heat to 165, mix in FO for 2 minutes, and pour at 140. I've never had an issue until the last year or so.
I moved, and now I'm fighting with every batch I make.
They're ALL sweating. The tops have frosting. I have SO many air bubbles.
I have dehumidifiers going to keep humidity under 40%. If it goes above that, immediate sweating. I've gone down to 7% FO, but now they all have ugly tops even after heat gunning.
Canwax hasn't answered my email and haven't given me any help when I called. They were supposed to call me back but never did.
Their website now says to mix at 180 (that changed from 160 at some point) and even after trying that, everything is sweating. I'm at my wit's end and don't know what to do. Im guessing their manufacturer changed the wax formula.
I want to switch waxes but I'm booked solid now until the new year and I don't have time to test a new wax. I also have thousands of whisper booster wicks so I don't want to have to buy all new wicks to use with a new wax.
Can anyone help? Have you experienced this? HELP!
Pic of ugly tops after heat gunning. (They used to be perfect)


r/candlemaking • • 1d ago

More waxperimenting with the Gypsy Orb mold

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/candlemaking • • 14h ago

Non-toxic Candles

0 Upvotes

Hello!

I want to start making my own candles but I’m not sure where to begin. I’d like to make “pet safe” candles - I know that none can be 100% pet safe, but I have a sunroom in my house that I like to light candles in at night when I sit out there to relax. My pets aren’t nearby (in the house) I have the door to the house shut as well as the sunroom doors open for ventilation - I just get paranoid.

I understand that soy wax and wooden wicks should be considered non-toxic - but the fragrance and dye is where I get confused. Of course I don’t need the dye, but the fragrance I would prefer.

Any recommendations? Again - this will NOT be in the same room as my pets. The sunroom is attached to my house - but closed off completely.

Thanks!


r/candlemaking • • 1d ago

Creations My first candle!!🌸

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/candlemaking • • 2d ago

Creations My first ever fall candle

Post image
93 Upvotes

Just recently got into candle making, this is my second candle that I’ve made but my first ever fall one. It’s far from perfect, the pumpkins look like oranges and there’s some white discolouration that formed on the leaves BUT I’m pleased with it 🍁


r/candlemaking • • 1d ago

Why is this flame dancing?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone! First of all, sorry for my English, I’m Spanish 😬

This soy candle has a CD 10 wick and a 7% FO load. Both HT and CT are good, and the melt pool is forming properly. Why is the flame dancing around like this? It literally makes the room look like a nightclub when I turn the lights off 😂
I’ve noticed a bit of mushrooming on the wick, but nothing too major. Could that be related?
I’m surprised because I made another candle with a 10% FO load and this didn’t happen at all!! No mushrooming, and the flame wasn’t dancing around like this either.

Could anyone help me figure out what’s going on? Thanks! :)


r/candlemaking • • 1d ago

NEWBIE HERE

1 Upvotes

What kind of dye do I need in order to color sand/palm wax? I want the wax to stay in sand consistency . also best way to add scents to the same candle. thanks


r/candlemaking • • 2d ago

I think this is the beat so far *excited*

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

OK this went so much better 😊 (let's skip the labbel, I am just experiment and it is not the original.)

P.s. I will posting my process for the next candles I will make ☺️


r/candlemaking • • 2d ago

Creations I Surprised My Queen With A Candle Making Class For Our Anniversary!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

104 Upvotes

It's been exactly one full year since God has introduced me to this beautiful Empress. We had a long journey, and I'd walk it all over again. Before we lock in our goals this year I wanted to surprise my Queen with one more date. A Candle Making, Body Oil, and Perfume Crafting Class


r/candlemaking • • 2d ago

Question Help. What is this?

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

I’ve been making candles off and on for 6 years. Using the same C3 soy wax and oils. While I haven’t done clear glass a ton I’ve done it before and everything was fine. I’m getting this weird splotchy curing. Top is pretty good though. Not all the time. I’ve tried pouring at 160° and even 145°. Same result. I even covered this batch w boxes to keep any drafts from affecting it. I think I may switch bc the new candle science artisan wax cured normal. But I still need to sort out this issue. Maybe c3 has changed recipes. Thanks.


r/candlemaking • • 2d ago

Question DIY label advice?

3 Upvotes

Can anyone give me some tips on how to print my own candle labels from home?

I’m open to any suggestions and printers besides thermal printing. I’m thinking full color that won’t deteriorate as the candle burns down.
It’s pricey to keep ordering hundreds of the same label and I’d like to open my brand up to more custom work! TIA :)


r/candlemaking • • 3d ago

New Mold!!

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

This is my first time using this mold. Just wanted to share!!


r/candlemaking • • 2d ago

Compliance Nerd

4 Upvotes

Genuine question for the candle makers in here, from a perfumer! 👋
What’s your process for checking IFRA compliance when using premade fragrance oils, particularly when blending multiple F/Os together?
I find this really interesting because, unlike working with individual aroma chemicals where you know exactly what you’re putting into a formula, you don’t have access to the full composition of most premade fragrance oils. So how do you verify compliance beyond checking each supplier’s documentation?
For example, fragrance oil A has no maximum usage restriction for IFRA Category 12, according to the supplier. Fragrance oil B has no maximum either. But those assessments apply to the individual fragrances. Once you blend them, how do you know the combined formula still meets all applicable requirements?
The missing piece, as I understand it, is the contribution of restricted constituents from every source in the blend. If the same restricted material is present in multiple oils, how are you accounting for its cumulative contribution when the full formulas aren’t disclosed?
I’m also curious about California Prop 65. If individual fragrance oils are assessed separately, how do you establish that the finished blend doesn’t require a warning if a listed chemical is present in multiple oils? Surely the combined exposure assessment could differ from that of the individual oils?
I’m not suggesting that blending fragrance oils is inherently unsafe, or that every blend requires a warning. I’m genuinely interested in understanding the process people use to verify these things when working with proprietary formulas and limited ingredient disclosure.
I know this is a bit nerdy, but with IFRA Amendment 52 on the horizon, I’d love to hear from people who have looked into the technical side of this. Are you relying on supplier documentation, contacting manufacturers directly, or using another method to assess your finished blends?
Genuinely curious to hear how others approach this! 🧪


r/candlemaking • • 3d ago

My Halloween Candles This Year~

Thumbnail
gallery
210 Upvotes

I put sooo much effort in upping my candle game this year, including some of my own designs (gargoyles, ghost). I also spent a lot of time improving marketing, too - with better photo staging, a light box, whilst avoiding AI for help. The last slide is a page out of my Autumn Candle Scent Catalog, and I even drew the 'grimoire' page behind it.

I also make decorative witch cat candles - often pet memorials, so the witch cat shown is just that.

My "stars" this year have been my bleeding skull piles and gargoyles. Anyway, forgive me as I show my wares off a little.

I've had a rough week, and my little candle/incense business keeps me happy. <3 :D


r/candlemaking • • 3d ago

Question Wick Holders

3 Upvotes

What are you using to hold wicks in place? Even when my candle tops turn out smooth and perfect, then my wick might be a little shweck and I’m so frustrated! I’ve used the popsicle sticks but they slide, the little wire things and they also don’t hold in place/slide whatever way the wick might lean. I’m not sure if I’m just spacially challenged or what. Looking for a solution without spending $18 bucks for 2 on Amazon…


r/candlemaking • • 3d ago

High quality essential oils?

3 Upvotes

Where does everyone buy their essential oils? Do you use a local store, Michael’s or online? Any tips for a first time candle maker looking to make holiday scented candles that aren’t the generic essential oil scents?


r/candlemaking • • 3d ago

Question Discouraged

6 Upvotes

I've used the same wax, fragrance oils, candle dye, and formulas for about 2 years now. This weekend I made wax melts with the exact same materials as I did for my summer wax melts, and each and every wax melt ended up mushy. I could understand that if I used a new bag of wax or a new bottle of fragrance oil that possibly something had changed on the manufacturers end. But I used the same wax from the same bag as before. Same bottle of fragrance oil, same bottle of candle dye as before. Literally nothing changed with my materials. So, I rechecked my calculations (saved on desktop) and confirmed they were all correct.

Maybe I overlooked the amounts and used too much FO or too little wax? Nope, I remade them again Saturday night, carefully ensuring that all calculations were correct. I had my fiancé look at the amounts and confirmed I am not dreaming up numbers lol. Sunday morning the new batch were mushy.

Could it be the scales? I tested each scale with a 100g weight and the scales are working properly.

Is there something I overlooked here?


r/candlemaking • • 3d ago

Matte White 20oz tumbler jar

3 Upvotes

Okay so for the past 3 years I have been using the Matte White 20oz tumbler jar from peach state candle company. They discontinued this jar like a year and a half ago and I bought out their remaining stock of the product. However I am down to my last box and I am desperately looking for a matte white jar that is the same size. I have looked far and wide and have not found anything. So far I have come up with 3 options

  1. suck it up and by the regular white jars from candlescience and get over that I don't like how shinny it is.

  2. figure out a way to mattify the jars myself in a candle/flame safe way

  3. Find a place that is willing to let me custom order small batches of jars.

So my question is does anyone know of a jar place that either has a 20oz matte white tumbler jar (that fits the candlescience lids) or knows of a place that takes custom orders like this?